Reviews of Hogwarts: Harry Potter’s Return from the Witcher World by michaeI - Webnovel

21Opiniões

4.43

  • Qualidade de Escrita
  • Estabilidade das atualizações
  • Desenvolvimento de Histórias
  • Design de Personagens
  • Antecedentes do mundo

Compartilhe seus pensamentos com outras pessoas

Escreva uma avaliação
MeLucawolf

Im really loving this so much I love Harry personality I can’t stop laughing

5d
Ver 0 Respostas
voidark
LV 14 Badge

this is one of the best books I've ever read

6d
Ver 0 Respostas
Ironlotuce

Although I usually don't enjoy fanfiction where the MC is harry potter, this book managed to pull it off spectacularly. I particularly enjoy the fact that this is not harry going back and redoing everything, but really harry experiencing this magical world for the first time, just with the added Witcher experiences. The story seems realistic, mentioning how harry was only in the Witcher world for 40 years and how he was not like a legendary Witcher yet since he had no title and hadn't started his path yet. I do love the dynamic brought on by his Witcher physiology, namely how he no longer has green eyes and how that impacts his interactions with Snape. In the end, the author does a great job building up the characters, slowly developing them while avoiding annoying clichés and bias (like Ron being annoying and Dumbledore being manipulative, they still are those things but its toned down to more realistic levels). I will enjoy reading this book for a while to come. In the future, I would love to see some more realistic fights (like he killed the basilisk pretty easily, which although might be a testament of his skills, I would assume would be harder than that). I would also love to see Harry start something, not just reacting to the upcoming trials. maybe he can try to go back to the Witcher world, or try some Witcher sorcerer style elemental magic (so not just sword/armor stuff that has become his focus), right now it feels too much like he is just reacting and preparing which I'm not complaining too much since its the smart thing to do.

Revelar Spoiler
9d
Ver 0 Respostas
DaoistXziFAy

i am too confused there are changes chapter by chapter

12d
Ver 0 Respostas
Tiktark
LV 14 Badge

so far this fic is interesting and good. I assume if Chris was responsible for sending him back she may have also been responsible for bringing him to the witcher world as when the older Harry was sent back de aged, the younger Harry may have been brought to the time he was found, or he was sent to an alternate timeline or another Force capable of manipulating space and time was behind his appearance and departure. looking forward to reading further chapters and I highly suggest other to read this fanfic!

Revelar Spoiler
23d
Ver 0 Respostas
BigBud

Good quality writing. OP Harry fic, but reasonable for an 11 year old. The teachers are not incompetent or malicious and Voldemort feels like a real threat despite Harry’s new strength.

25d
Ver 0 Respostas
mothblade

Ok here’s the deal after 60 chapters. This book follows a Harry Potter that is truly insightful. This attribute is not an easy this to write in an HP story with your MC knowing seemingly knowing the future. This story is very well done the at is a must read for HP fans. My suggested improvements would be towards including more of Harries history in the Witcher world and to make use of POV of those near harry to show not tell the differences his more mature behavior has on other character growth.

26d
Ver 0 Respostas
Reincarnation_God

WQ: decent, its easy to read and there are few grammar errors. 3/5 stars SD:I've only read a few chapters not all of them but the story is devolping nicely, don't know if it stays that way so 3/5 stars. CD: The idea is fasinating, but it does seem to be a hermione bash. And it has put Ron and Albus in good light. Both characters I hate. Also the reason I dropped so SD didn't get a better rating. Ignore that if your fine with it. Also Harry was a little too open to showing off whitcher magic. 1/5. US: A nice update shcedule, but that can always change so 3/5 stars. WB: it's the harry potter world. 4/5 stars

29d
Ver 2 Respostas
scyfly

this trash. its a chinese translation, a bad one at that, with the typical racism towards anything not percieved right. i could actually relate wizards to chinese in that aspect. the format is shit, typical webnovel where ppl think one sentence needs a new paragraph or worse in dialogue it cuts mid sentece for a new paragraph. plot is shit too, nothing about how he started in witcher, plot hole after plot hole. it chinese counterfit, it looks the same just not the same quality how ppl can rate this 5 stars is beyond me

1mth
Ver 2 Respostas
Ravven2769

Better than I expected but has it's flaws.

1mth
Ver 0 Respostas
Artem_5195

The story is very interesting, which deserves 5 stars. I can't judge the grammar, I read through a translator. But if you came to read the comments to decide whether to read or not, then the story is super, you won't regret it.

1mth
Ver 0 Respostas
ReMormo

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

1mth
Ver 0 Respostas
Darius_Chromwell

Phenomenal work, I’m a huge fan of Harry Potter fanfics and to throw in some Witcher aspects especially in such a clean way that it feels seamless has made this one of my new favorites, i look forward to seeing more from this masterpiece!

1mth
Ver 1 Respostas
Vengeful_Slave

The only thing I can say is, I'm surprised. Like I for real came here with near zero expectations, but now I am thoroughly enjoying this. Harry character is amazing, all the other characters retain their personalities and they don't feel like one dimensional characters. Honestly I absolutely recommend it.

1mth
Ver 0 Respostas
SORCERERSUPREME_7

👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

1mth
Ver 0 Respostas
captainfatbelly

I'm loving this book so far really investing concept wonder if he will look into the mirror kinda want to know what he'll see

1mth
Ver 0 Respostas
R0B
LV 2 Badge

Good for now (chapter 18) ........................................................... ........................................................... ........................................................... ........................................................... ........................................................... ...........................................................

1mth
Ver 1 Respostas
Black_Hat_

Absolutely great read till CHP 10 author PLZ keep posting don't stop will give you power stone tomorrow. What a writing style just great .keep up the good work

img
1mth
Ver 0 Respostas
Cevahir_Gezer

I read the same version of this story, where the lead character is a reincarnated MC. Is it an imitation or did you write the other one as well? If it is an imitation, it would be nice if you wrote it in the summary. The story progresses very well. I personally liked it very much.

1mth
Ver 10 Respostas
MasterOfTheDadJoke

TL;DR Off to a great start, awesome job. Give it a go! Full: Only 10 chapters in, but I feel like I’ve found a hidden gem. It’s refined, a little quirky, a little funny, but it’s got heart. It’s also nice to see a perceptive, talented, smart and determined Harry in the making. I’m looking forward to how he handles the future dangers and a potential return to the Witcher World! Please keep up the good work bro! Sincerely, DadJoke.

img
1mth
Ver 0 Respostas
mothblade

Still new 4 chapters in but I see a good future with this story. It’s a Harry Potter that has a intense life experience as a Witcher making him far more mature before entering the wizard of world. This author is great at slice of life so I can’t wait to see how a mature dangous Harry without regression knowledge or being raised in secret like many other authors do before he tackles his dark rival while learning about his original work. Can’t wait to see if when his time in his home world is over will be go back to the Witcher world with his new knowledge?

1mth
Ver 0 Respostas
MeLucawolf

Im really loving this so much I love Harry personality I can’t stop laughing

5d
Ver 0 Respostas
voidark
LV 14 Badge

this is one of the best books I've ever read

6d
Ver 0 Respostas
Ironlotuce

Although I usually don't enjoy fanfiction where the MC is harry potter, this book managed to pull it off spectacularly. I particularly enjoy the fact that this is not harry going back and redoing everything, but really harry experiencing this magical world for the first time, just with the added Witcher experiences. The story seems realistic, mentioning how harry was only in the Witcher world for 40 years and how he was not like a legendary Witcher yet since he had no title and hadn't started his path yet. I do love the dynamic brought on by his Witcher physiology, namely how he no longer has green eyes and how that impacts his interactions with Snape. In the end, the author does a great job building up the characters, slowly developing them while avoiding annoying clichés and bias (like Ron being annoying and Dumbledore being manipulative, they still are those things but its toned down to more realistic levels). I will enjoy reading this book for a while to come. In the future, I would love to see some more realistic fights (like he killed the basilisk pretty easily, which although might be a testament of his skills, I would assume would be harder than that). I would also love to see Harry start something, not just reacting to the upcoming trials. maybe he can try to go back to the Witcher world, or try some Witcher sorcerer style elemental magic (so not just sword/armor stuff that has become his focus), right now it feels too much like he is just reacting and preparing which I'm not complaining too much since its the smart thing to do.

Revelar Spoiler
9d
Ver 0 Respostas
DaoistXziFAy

i am too confused there are changes chapter by chapter

12d
Ver 0 Respostas
Tiktark
LV 14 Badge

so far this fic is interesting and good. I assume if Chris was responsible for sending him back she may have also been responsible for bringing him to the witcher world as when the older Harry was sent back de aged, the younger Harry may have been brought to the time he was found, or he was sent to an alternate timeline or another Force capable of manipulating space and time was behind his appearance and departure. looking forward to reading further chapters and I highly suggest other to read this fanfic!

Revelar Spoiler
23d
Ver 0 Respostas
BigBud

Good quality writing. OP Harry fic, but reasonable for an 11 year old. The teachers are not incompetent or malicious and Voldemort feels like a real threat despite Harry’s new strength.

25d
Ver 0 Respostas
mothblade

Ok here’s the deal after 60 chapters. This book follows a Harry Potter that is truly insightful. This attribute is not an easy this to write in an HP story with your MC knowing seemingly knowing the future. This story is very well done the at is a must read for HP fans. My suggested improvements would be towards including more of Harries history in the Witcher world and to make use of POV of those near harry to show not tell the differences his more mature behavior has on other character growth.

26d
Ver 0 Respostas
Reincarnation_God

WQ: decent, its easy to read and there are few grammar errors. 3/5 stars SD:I've only read a few chapters not all of them but the story is devolping nicely, don't know if it stays that way so 3/5 stars. CD: The idea is fasinating, but it does seem to be a hermione bash. And it has put Ron and Albus in good light. Both characters I hate. Also the reason I dropped so SD didn't get a better rating. Ignore that if your fine with it. Also Harry was a little too open to showing off whitcher magic. 1/5. US: A nice update shcedule, but that can always change so 3/5 stars. WB: it's the harry potter world. 4/5 stars

29d
Ver 2 Respostas
scyfly

this trash. its a chinese translation, a bad one at that, with the typical racism towards anything not percieved right. i could actually relate wizards to chinese in that aspect. the format is shit, typical webnovel where ppl think one sentence needs a new paragraph or worse in dialogue it cuts mid sentece for a new paragraph. plot is shit too, nothing about how he started in witcher, plot hole after plot hole. it chinese counterfit, it looks the same just not the same quality how ppl can rate this 5 stars is beyond me

1mth
Ver 2 Respostas
Ravven2769

Better than I expected but has it's flaws.

1mth
Ver 0 Respostas
Artem_5195

The story is very interesting, which deserves 5 stars. I can't judge the grammar, I read through a translator. But if you came to read the comments to decide whether to read or not, then the story is super, you won't regret it.

1mth
Ver 0 Respostas
ReMormo

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

1mth
Ver 0 Respostas
Darius_Chromwell

Phenomenal work, I’m a huge fan of Harry Potter fanfics and to throw in some Witcher aspects especially in such a clean way that it feels seamless has made this one of my new favorites, i look forward to seeing more from this masterpiece!

1mth
Ver 1 Respostas
Vengeful_Slave

The only thing I can say is, I'm surprised. Like I for real came here with near zero expectations, but now I am thoroughly enjoying this. Harry character is amazing, all the other characters retain their personalities and they don't feel like one dimensional characters. Honestly I absolutely recommend it.

1mth
Ver 0 Respostas
SORCERERSUPREME_7

👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

1mth
Ver 0 Respostas
captainfatbelly

I'm loving this book so far really investing concept wonder if he will look into the mirror kinda want to know what he'll see

1mth
Ver 0 Respostas
R0B
LV 2 Badge

Good for now (chapter 18) ........................................................... ........................................................... ........................................................... ........................................................... ........................................................... ...........................................................

1mth
Ver 1 Respostas
Black_Hat_

Absolutely great read till CHP 10 author PLZ keep posting don't stop will give you power stone tomorrow. What a writing style just great .keep up the good work

img
1mth
Ver 0 Respostas
Cevahir_Gezer

I read the same version of this story, where the lead character is a reincarnated MC. Is it an imitation or did you write the other one as well? If it is an imitation, it would be nice if you wrote it in the summary. The story progresses very well. I personally liked it very much.

1mth
Ver 10 Respostas
MasterOfTheDadJoke

TL;DR Off to a great start, awesome job. Give it a go! Full: Only 10 chapters in, but I feel like I’ve found a hidden gem. It’s refined, a little quirky, a little funny, but it’s got heart. It’s also nice to see a perceptive, talented, smart and determined Harry in the making. I’m looking forward to how he handles the future dangers and a potential return to the Witcher World! Please keep up the good work bro! Sincerely, DadJoke.

img
1mth
Ver 0 Respostas
mothblade

Still new 4 chapters in but I see a good future with this story. It’s a Harry Potter that has a intense life experience as a Witcher making him far more mature before entering the wizard of world. This author is great at slice of life so I can’t wait to see how a mature dangous Harry without regression knowledge or being raised in secret like many other authors do before he tackles his dark rival while learning about his original work. Can’t wait to see if when his time in his home world is over will be go back to the Witcher world with his new knowledge?

1mth
Ver 0 Respostas