Reviews of My Disciples Are All Villains by MSRZP - Webnovel

380Critiques

4.51

  • Qualité de la traduction
  • Stabilité des mises à jour
  • Développement de l’histoire
  • Conception des personnages
  • Contexte du monde

Partagez vos pensées avec les autres

Écrire un avis
LazyAce
LV 12 Badge

This is one of my favorite fantasy/cultivation novels. I really enjoy the protagonist’s journey and the development of his disciples. Each character undergoes significant growth and becomes integral to the story. What sets this novel apart from others in its genre is its emphasis on self-realization and the healing of the bond between the protagonist and his disciples. Instead of just having an overpowered protagonist, we see a protagonist with depth, as well as characters who have their own individual purposes and ambitions. If I had to critique anything, it would be the length of the story. While it's long, it felt somewhat unfinished at the end. Additionally, some of the villains felt a bit two-dimensional. Nevertheless, it's a captivating story.

3mth
Voir 0 Réponses
zcritser

Honestly, it's one of my favorite books. It's really well thought out and amazing characters and development. 10/10 book. some chapters had some bad translation, but very few compared to how many this book has.

6mth
Voir 0 Réponses
SteliosR

Great story, makes you wanna read non-stop

7mth
Voir 0 Réponses
Paytone_Mayberry

I know I'm heavily biased with transmission novels but this novel deserves praise for being funny and knowing when to be serious,the character development is Fantastic and even years later not reading the novel I still have great metal image of them. That's how you know it's good(or I have an great memory)

9mth
Voir 0 Réponses
Panlong_deen

wasnt a huge fan. i could not get past 100 chs. he had like zero real progress and it just became super boring

1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Bigkingman

Sooo great hate that it ended I needed more of it, but I understand everything has to end

1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Daoist1MgQJV

Can i ask if Little Yuan'er is also a transmigrator?

1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Lordofall2000

Mid at best...........................................................................................,................................................................................................

1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Sonyvaio

Fantastic novel Spoiler alert The story is complete but somehow it feels like a couple sentences are missing at the end in the epilogue.

Spoiler de révélation
1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
WhoIsIsaac

"I got to tell you, it was perfect. Perfect. Everything, down to the last chapter details." "I got to tell you, it was perfect. Perfect. Everything, down to the last chapter details." "I got to tell you, it was perfect. Perfect. Everything, down to the last chapter details."

1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Yatendoouji

another trash cultivation novel. his acting is absolutely horrid and yet the entire story revolves around his act that he's still powerful. his system is trash and worthless and barely helps. the only times it does is exactly when it needs to which makes this read worthless since you can basically guess everything that will happen. can't believe i wasted my time with another awful novel like this one. -10/10 would not recommend

1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Nandani_Rathore_9181

Hello, I would like to talk to you about your book. Can you please contact me via Instagram. I am there as @penetratingoutlook

1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
paschal

great work, first time finishing a Chinese translation novel most translational novels tend to get boring toward the middle of novel this one is an exception it kept on getting better and better. The name of novel doesn't suit it and the end of the novel doesn't seem like the end still need extra chapter

1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
CouchPotatoDandy

A good novel. I somewhat enjoyed reading this novel since the plot was good but at about chapter 1000 you could already see things weren't adding up and we're inconsistent overall... The grammar didn't have any problems from what I could see, which is something I consider a must when reading... All in all, I would recommend this novel to anyone who likes this gender.

1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
MrNewbie

After reading the entire book, I can only day that it's rare to find such a good story. This definitely goes in my top collection! .........

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Bigkingman

One of the best books on here that I feel should go to Amazon or any other big book place and hope the author does that one day don’t stop writing.

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Dracula_9623

good novel but it s too long ........................................... ................cjuggcjkutxvji ........................... .....

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
nyastro
LV 14 Badge

it's very good novel......... ..................................................................................................................................

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
JustPassing123

the best. .. Some translations mishaps once in a while but worth reading it. ... .. .. .. .. .. .. .. . . .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Vcor2302

This novel has been with me for awhile now, I hate to see it go already but it's story and characters helped me pass the time and imagine a world where amazing and ever changing things happen every chapter. Thank you for for writing this story and letting me use my imagination to see this story like a movie in my head. It was a blast.

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
SURIDON9

This is a isekai story and the protagonist was misunderstood but he don't correct them and bluff his way to the top with the help of the system.

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Jolly3630

[img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp]

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
1chocolate_queen

I can't believe that Lu Zhou's story has come to an end. This book was worth me following up on updates. It was masterfully written with excellent characters and an amazing plot. The author really did well❤❤❤❤

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
kawatta21

This has been one of the best web novels I’ve read. It had an interesting plot - a transmigrator having to reform his wicked disciples that are plotting to kill him and take off with his treasures. Though, he starts off in the worst possible way…. Old and weak. There was plenty of humor and fight scenes in the novel, as well as many interesting subplots. There’s also no romance which I liked. The translation was great though it did get weird every now and then in a few chapters. But really, the majority of the novel has a great translation. Now, there are some things in the novel that I think could have used a bit more detail… such as more details on why the 9th disciple. They always write her off as just being talented, but at a certain point one starts to wonder if it’s something more than talent. More details on the MC previous life would have been nice. He adapts so well to being thrown in another world, but rarely thinks about the old life he left behind. There are other little things that are brushed over, but nothing so major that it takes away from the enjoyment factor. Anyway, I enjoyed the novel. I hope there’s a sequel or something because the ending ended on a cliffhanger.

Spoiler de révélation
2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
kevim
LV 14 Badge

Amazing novel! The story development is smoth. The teacher/student relationship works just fine, great thouths about The duties of a teacher, The duties of a student, father and son... I Recommend!

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Wyatt_Marcum

100% one of the best novels. character development feels real and peeing up and going out into the world feels natural. great book to let build up chairs between be books and binge in

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Vgbprom

I like it, The only thing that confuses me is the fact that I do not know how many chapters are left. Novelupdates has 1714, but it doesn't seem to be the case. Does anybody knows how many chapters are left?

2yr
Voir 4 Réponses
Brix_Branzuela

not a good novel I don't know if the author knows how to count in the novel the remaining life of the mc doesn't match the added of the old and new

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Wyatt_Marcum

I love this story. The character development feels real, and the MC takes the role he is given and runs with it. the best way to read this story is to let chapters build up so you don't have to interrupt the story too much. one of my top five novels on here

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
C137Rick

Honestly couldn’t wait so long to see all the unreleased chapters after 1500+ chapters of reading. Went into mtl and finished it up there, I love the book. Author is by far one of the few who has genuinely taken their time to ensure that the plot holes are explained and that the story is well connected. Reminded me a little of ”Release that witch”. Do give this book a shot, it is definitely worthwhile reading this.

2yr
Voir 1 Réponses
LazyAce
LV 12 Badge

This is one of my favorite fantasy/cultivation novels. I really enjoy the protagonist’s journey and the development of his disciples. Each character undergoes significant growth and becomes integral to the story. What sets this novel apart from others in its genre is its emphasis on self-realization and the healing of the bond between the protagonist and his disciples. Instead of just having an overpowered protagonist, we see a protagonist with depth, as well as characters who have their own individual purposes and ambitions. If I had to critique anything, it would be the length of the story. While it's long, it felt somewhat unfinished at the end. Additionally, some of the villains felt a bit two-dimensional. Nevertheless, it's a captivating story.

3mth
Voir 0 Réponses
zcritser

Honestly, it's one of my favorite books. It's really well thought out and amazing characters and development. 10/10 book. some chapters had some bad translation, but very few compared to how many this book has.

6mth
Voir 0 Réponses
SteliosR

Great story, makes you wanna read non-stop

7mth
Voir 0 Réponses
Paytone_Mayberry

I know I'm heavily biased with transmission novels but this novel deserves praise for being funny and knowing when to be serious,the character development is Fantastic and even years later not reading the novel I still have great metal image of them. That's how you know it's good(or I have an great memory)

9mth
Voir 0 Réponses
Panlong_deen

wasnt a huge fan. i could not get past 100 chs. he had like zero real progress and it just became super boring

1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Bigkingman

Sooo great hate that it ended I needed more of it, but I understand everything has to end

1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Daoist1MgQJV

Can i ask if Little Yuan'er is also a transmigrator?

1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Lordofall2000

Mid at best...........................................................................................,................................................................................................

1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Sonyvaio

Fantastic novel Spoiler alert The story is complete but somehow it feels like a couple sentences are missing at the end in the epilogue.

Spoiler de révélation
1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
WhoIsIsaac

"I got to tell you, it was perfect. Perfect. Everything, down to the last chapter details." "I got to tell you, it was perfect. Perfect. Everything, down to the last chapter details." "I got to tell you, it was perfect. Perfect. Everything, down to the last chapter details."

1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Yatendoouji

another trash cultivation novel. his acting is absolutely horrid and yet the entire story revolves around his act that he's still powerful. his system is trash and worthless and barely helps. the only times it does is exactly when it needs to which makes this read worthless since you can basically guess everything that will happen. can't believe i wasted my time with another awful novel like this one. -10/10 would not recommend

1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Nandani_Rathore_9181

Hello, I would like to talk to you about your book. Can you please contact me via Instagram. I am there as @penetratingoutlook

1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
paschal

great work, first time finishing a Chinese translation novel most translational novels tend to get boring toward the middle of novel this one is an exception it kept on getting better and better. The name of novel doesn't suit it and the end of the novel doesn't seem like the end still need extra chapter

1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
CouchPotatoDandy

A good novel. I somewhat enjoyed reading this novel since the plot was good but at about chapter 1000 you could already see things weren't adding up and we're inconsistent overall... The grammar didn't have any problems from what I could see, which is something I consider a must when reading... All in all, I would recommend this novel to anyone who likes this gender.

1yr
Voir 0 Réponses
MrNewbie

After reading the entire book, I can only day that it's rare to find such a good story. This definitely goes in my top collection! .........

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Bigkingman

One of the best books on here that I feel should go to Amazon or any other big book place and hope the author does that one day don’t stop writing.

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Dracula_9623

good novel but it s too long ........................................... ................cjuggcjkutxvji ........................... .....

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
nyastro
LV 14 Badge

it's very good novel......... ..................................................................................................................................

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
JustPassing123

the best. .. Some translations mishaps once in a while but worth reading it. ... .. .. .. .. .. .. .. . . .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Vcor2302

This novel has been with me for awhile now, I hate to see it go already but it's story and characters helped me pass the time and imagine a world where amazing and ever changing things happen every chapter. Thank you for for writing this story and letting me use my imagination to see this story like a movie in my head. It was a blast.

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
SURIDON9

This is a isekai story and the protagonist was misunderstood but he don't correct them and bluff his way to the top with the help of the system.

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Jolly3630

[img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp][img=fp]

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
1chocolate_queen

I can't believe that Lu Zhou's story has come to an end. This book was worth me following up on updates. It was masterfully written with excellent characters and an amazing plot. The author really did well❤❤❤❤

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
kawatta21

This has been one of the best web novels I’ve read. It had an interesting plot - a transmigrator having to reform his wicked disciples that are plotting to kill him and take off with his treasures. Though, he starts off in the worst possible way…. Old and weak. There was plenty of humor and fight scenes in the novel, as well as many interesting subplots. There’s also no romance which I liked. The translation was great though it did get weird every now and then in a few chapters. But really, the majority of the novel has a great translation. Now, there are some things in the novel that I think could have used a bit more detail… such as more details on why the 9th disciple. They always write her off as just being talented, but at a certain point one starts to wonder if it’s something more than talent. More details on the MC previous life would have been nice. He adapts so well to being thrown in another world, but rarely thinks about the old life he left behind. There are other little things that are brushed over, but nothing so major that it takes away from the enjoyment factor. Anyway, I enjoyed the novel. I hope there’s a sequel or something because the ending ended on a cliffhanger.

Spoiler de révélation
2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
kevim
LV 14 Badge

Amazing novel! The story development is smoth. The teacher/student relationship works just fine, great thouths about The duties of a teacher, The duties of a student, father and son... I Recommend!

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Wyatt_Marcum

100% one of the best novels. character development feels real and peeing up and going out into the world feels natural. great book to let build up chairs between be books and binge in

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Vgbprom

I like it, The only thing that confuses me is the fact that I do not know how many chapters are left. Novelupdates has 1714, but it doesn't seem to be the case. Does anybody knows how many chapters are left?

2yr
Voir 4 Réponses
Brix_Branzuela

not a good novel I don't know if the author knows how to count in the novel the remaining life of the mc doesn't match the added of the old and new

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Wyatt_Marcum

I love this story. The character development feels real, and the MC takes the role he is given and runs with it. the best way to read this story is to let chapters build up so you don't have to interrupt the story too much. one of my top five novels on here

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
C137Rick

Honestly couldn’t wait so long to see all the unreleased chapters after 1500+ chapters of reading. Went into mtl and finished it up there, I love the book. Author is by far one of the few who has genuinely taken their time to ensure that the plot holes are explained and that the story is well connected. Reminded me a little of ”Release that witch”. Do give this book a shot, it is definitely worthwhile reading this.

2yr
Voir 1 Réponses
next page