Reviews of Harry Potter and the transmigrated twat by THE_alpinism - Webnovel

13Reviews

4.12

  • Writing Quality
  • Stability of Updates
  • Story Development
  • Character Design
  • World Background

Share your thoughts with others

Write a review
Emu_Lator

The writting and story progress made me hate everything about it. A lot of the cast is acting out of character from canon and the personality changes as well as what mc does... reading about it only produces anciety, annoyance and frustration. I dont feel good reading this at all

5d
View 0 Replies
Godsreader_15

One of the better Harry Potter fics I've read. The MC is entertaining, the flow of the story is good. My problem is the external part of the writing, please download some grammar correcting application or just get a beta reader because sole of these paragraphs are barely legible.

img
1yr
View 0 Replies
Ashish_Kumar_1835

The grammar is abysmal. The story has no purpose. Infrequent updates are also a big factor.

1yr
View 0 Replies
JustAlitleShadow

This some gud sh Mc is super likable and quite funny The grammar is good Over all the book is a must read

1yr
View 0 Replies
LGK_maore

really nice ,,i liked the mc personality and the mentality he goes by 🔥🔥🔥🔥

1yr
View 0 Replies
Harry_Brennan

One of the best HP fanfics around it is worth spending a good hour to read it (I read very fast) I hope you check this story out if your going thru the reviews for quality control

1yr
View 0 Replies
THE_alpinism

is 300k views and 1k collection in one month good or average???

1yr
View 8 Replies
MrCoconut

While the story was interesting, the grammar is awful. It reads like somebody trying to text but has a character limit for their cell phone plan. Not only that, but the premise kinda killed it for me. Neville being the Boy-Who-Lived isn't terrible, but the Author decided to make the trio focus (Neville, Hermione, and Harry) similar to team 7 in Naruto. Neville has crazy amounts of power, Hermione is the talented one, and Harry just has control. Author really made his version of Harry turn into Sakura, which explains all the monologues and sass. It was all Harry's CHA moments.

img
1yr
View 3 Replies
Nine11P2

okay I will list all the key things in this fanfic:- 1) writing quality :- it isn't the best of the best,if you expect very edited perfect grammar writing then this isn't ,it almost feels like you are messaging someone but not bad enough to be considered bad webnovel is full of obnoxious writing so this is average i guess 2) character:- now this is where I was surprised,mc is a cautious one, he has a good humour(finally),he also has flaws which I am thankful for cuz nobody likes perfect mc aka Mary Sue. he feels like a normal adult just put down in Harry Potter . 3)story:- the plot is good if you read ahead you will feel like the fic has many plot holes but later the author fills it by giving information. whole idea is not new but it's around mc and almost feels like an AU which the author said it's not. 4):-updating stability:- it's just the starting author proves it by giving us chapters 4-5 per week minimum idk how long it will go.... fyi this a a neutral review feel free to point out the wrong facts

1yr
View 0 Replies
Joe_momma

The mcs personality is great. It is funny.

1yr
View 0 Replies
Jacob_Hobbs_7913

A lot of people are turned off by the obnoxious writing in the first couple chapters but honestly it was not that bad to me. it is a little obnoxious in the beginning but gets better a few chapters in. I like the character interactions so far (as of chapter 25), as it isn’t cringe. I honestly have a hard time conveying other good points without sounding biased, so I’ll just leave it there.

1yr
View 0 Replies
v2_765

GOOD interesting GOOD interesting GOOD interesting GOOD interesting GOOD interesting GOOD interesting GOOD interesting GOOD interesting GOOD interesting

img
1yr
View 0 Replies
Awriter

Please don't drop; This is very interesting.

1yr
View 1 Replies
Emu_Lator

The writting and story progress made me hate everything about it. A lot of the cast is acting out of character from canon and the personality changes as well as what mc does... reading about it only produces anciety, annoyance and frustration. I dont feel good reading this at all

5d
View 0 Replies
Godsreader_15

One of the better Harry Potter fics I've read. The MC is entertaining, the flow of the story is good. My problem is the external part of the writing, please download some grammar correcting application or just get a beta reader because sole of these paragraphs are barely legible.

img
1yr
View 0 Replies
Ashish_Kumar_1835

The grammar is abysmal. The story has no purpose. Infrequent updates are also a big factor.

1yr
View 0 Replies
JustAlitleShadow

This some gud sh Mc is super likable and quite funny The grammar is good Over all the book is a must read

1yr
View 0 Replies
LGK_maore

really nice ,,i liked the mc personality and the mentality he goes by 🔥🔥🔥🔥

1yr
View 0 Replies
Harry_Brennan

One of the best HP fanfics around it is worth spending a good hour to read it (I read very fast) I hope you check this story out if your going thru the reviews for quality control

1yr
View 0 Replies
THE_alpinism

is 300k views and 1k collection in one month good or average???

1yr
View 8 Replies
MrCoconut

While the story was interesting, the grammar is awful. It reads like somebody trying to text but has a character limit for their cell phone plan. Not only that, but the premise kinda killed it for me. Neville being the Boy-Who-Lived isn't terrible, but the Author decided to make the trio focus (Neville, Hermione, and Harry) similar to team 7 in Naruto. Neville has crazy amounts of power, Hermione is the talented one, and Harry just has control. Author really made his version of Harry turn into Sakura, which explains all the monologues and sass. It was all Harry's CHA moments.

img
1yr
View 3 Replies
Nine11P2

okay I will list all the key things in this fanfic:- 1) writing quality :- it isn't the best of the best,if you expect very edited perfect grammar writing then this isn't ,it almost feels like you are messaging someone but not bad enough to be considered bad webnovel is full of obnoxious writing so this is average i guess 2) character:- now this is where I was surprised,mc is a cautious one, he has a good humour(finally),he also has flaws which I am thankful for cuz nobody likes perfect mc aka Mary Sue. he feels like a normal adult just put down in Harry Potter . 3)story:- the plot is good if you read ahead you will feel like the fic has many plot holes but later the author fills it by giving information. whole idea is not new but it's around mc and almost feels like an AU which the author said it's not. 4):-updating stability:- it's just the starting author proves it by giving us chapters 4-5 per week minimum idk how long it will go.... fyi this a a neutral review feel free to point out the wrong facts

1yr
View 0 Replies
Joe_momma

The mcs personality is great. It is funny.

1yr
View 0 Replies
Jacob_Hobbs_7913

A lot of people are turned off by the obnoxious writing in the first couple chapters but honestly it was not that bad to me. it is a little obnoxious in the beginning but gets better a few chapters in. I like the character interactions so far (as of chapter 25), as it isn’t cringe. I honestly have a hard time conveying other good points without sounding biased, so I’ll just leave it there.

1yr
View 0 Replies
v2_765

GOOD interesting GOOD interesting GOOD interesting GOOD interesting GOOD interesting GOOD interesting GOOD interesting GOOD interesting GOOD interesting

img
1yr
View 0 Replies
Awriter

Please don't drop; This is very interesting.

1yr
View 1 Replies