9Reviews
- Writing Quality
- Stability of Updates
- Story Development
- Character Design
- World Background
Share your thoughts with others
Write a review
It’s a story worth a read for sure, just the original idea of an Hagrid SI give it a twist that very few HP stories take and the story itself is well written.
ahem, bro, I read your amazing books on ffnet. I just wanted to bring your attention to another book "Harry Potter: Reborn as Hagrid" by Demonun. Its the exact same as your book. Now, I just wanted to know if thats your alt or if it's someone else you gave permission to(which wouldn't make sense since you're on webnovel as well). I'll write the same review on FFnet in case you miss this.
fantastic ff, beautifully written. The ingenuity and resourcefulness of the author are surprising. I live the strange relationship between Hagrid, Tom, and Minerva. 10/10 would recommend
Reveal Spoiler
I didn't like the story too much, I consider it too pedantic. The author wants to give it more realism or depth by writing dialogues with the teachers about magical theory or describing theory books. In my opinion it makes the story more boring, in the movie or in the books don't tell you how magic works, so in the end it's justo the author giving a speech about what he considers magic. It's a bit like what some Naruto novels do about chakra,It seems the excuse that the author gives to tell you why he is going to learn all the spells si easy, the trick or the key that only the MC has discovered about how magic works, that only he could learn. Finally, I don't like the MC, I don't know why specifically but I don't like it. I think it may be because it doesn't seem like being Hagrid is of any use. He doesn't have any similar personality traits and I don't see him using his giant complexion for anything either, he's from Ravenclaff, he doesn't like Dumbeldor, he doesn't have a strange pet, nothing. I don't quite understand why he chose that character instead of an OC, if he doesn't take advantage of it. Although all this is based on the first chapters, it may change in the future.
I have been reading this story on fanfiction. The only flaw it has is the lack of updates, but other than that its a good read . Was left wanting more chapters. 4 stars
All your stories are great! thanks for taking the Time and efforts to share your stories with us ![img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend] please keep writing ![img=recommend][img=recommend][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend]
I have been following this story for a while in fanfiction. Very well written. A bit slow pacing which i often do not like, but this novel is the exception. 5 stars
Only a few chapters out right now but so far it's been great. Good grammar, especially when compared to 99% of the other stories you see around here, and the character seems interesting so far. Not too sure how much I like that he doesn't have any of Hagrid's memories or even a little of his personality but that's a personal preference so I won't comment on that too much. I don't think I've seen many Hagrid-HP fanfics. Maybe one other one? But not nearly enough. Half-Giants are basically the perfect race in HP. Physically superhuman, resistant to magic AND capable of magic too. Either way this story's got a fun and original idea, and I hope the author keeps writing and continuing the story! [img=recommend][img=update][img=recommend][img=update][img=recommend]
Reveal Spoiler
You can submit a DMCA on the copycats patreon. That should kill his motivation. The only reason he copies is to get his bag. Patreon takes DMCA very seriously and I don't think bro can fight it. If it keeps repeating you can file a claim to compensation for the someone profiting of your IP
It’s a story worth a read for sure, just the original idea of an Hagrid SI give it a twist that very few HP stories take and the story itself is well written.
ahem, bro, I read your amazing books on ffnet. I just wanted to bring your attention to another book "Harry Potter: Reborn as Hagrid" by Demonun. Its the exact same as your book. Now, I just wanted to know if thats your alt or if it's someone else you gave permission to(which wouldn't make sense since you're on webnovel as well). I'll write the same review on FFnet in case you miss this.
fantastic ff, beautifully written. The ingenuity and resourcefulness of the author are surprising. I live the strange relationship between Hagrid, Tom, and Minerva. 10/10 would recommend
Reveal Spoiler I didn't like the story too much, I consider it too pedantic. The author wants to give it more realism or depth by writing dialogues with the teachers about magical theory or describing theory books. In my opinion it makes the story more boring, in the movie or in the books don't tell you how magic works, so in the end it's justo the author giving a speech about what he considers magic. It's a bit like what some Naruto novels do about chakra,It seems the excuse that the author gives to tell you why he is going to learn all the spells si easy, the trick or the key that only the MC has discovered about how magic works, that only he could learn. Finally, I don't like the MC, I don't know why specifically but I don't like it. I think it may be because it doesn't seem like being Hagrid is of any use. He doesn't have any similar personality traits and I don't see him using his giant complexion for anything either, he's from Ravenclaff, he doesn't like Dumbeldor, he doesn't have a strange pet, nothing. I don't quite understand why he chose that character instead of an OC, if he doesn't take advantage of it. Although all this is based on the first chapters, it may change in the future.
I have been reading this story on fanfiction. The only flaw it has is the lack of updates, but other than that its a good read . Was left wanting more chapters. 4 stars
All your stories are great! thanks for taking the Time and efforts to share your stories with us ![img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend] please keep writing ![img=recommend][img=recommend][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend]
I have been following this story for a while in fanfiction. Very well written. A bit slow pacing which i often do not like, but this novel is the exception. 5 stars
Only a few chapters out right now but so far it's been great. Good grammar, especially when compared to 99% of the other stories you see around here, and the character seems interesting so far. Not too sure how much I like that he doesn't have any of Hagrid's memories or even a little of his personality but that's a personal preference so I won't comment on that too much. I don't think I've seen many Hagrid-HP fanfics. Maybe one other one? But not nearly enough. Half-Giants are basically the perfect race in HP. Physically superhuman, resistant to magic AND capable of magic too. Either way this story's got a fun and original idea, and I hope the author keeps writing and continuing the story! [img=recommend][img=update][img=recommend][img=update][img=recommend]
Reveal Spoiler
You can submit a DMCA on the copycats patreon. That should kill his motivation. The only reason he copies is to get his bag. Patreon takes DMCA very seriously and I don't think bro can fight it. If it keeps repeating you can file a claim to compensation for the someone profiting of your IP