40Reviews
4.37
- Writing Quality
- Stability of Updates
- Story Development
- Character Design
- World Background
Share your thoughts with others
Write a review
Writing Quality: 5/5 This is one of the most decent ones in this platform in terms of writing. The structure is well thought out without much noise. Never felt too cramped. Story Development: 3.5/5(overall) 2/5(personal) Not really blaming the author as I'm in that phase where I can't really enjoy any slow paced story. And this story is as slow as it gets. Wouldn't be surprised if only the childhood arc took 50+ chapters. So, this one will be a downvote from me. Not necessarily bad but not to my taste. Character Design: 4/5 At times I felt like I gave too much of a score here but then again some characters are really fleshed out. This one is really all over the place tbh. Some characters are totally monochromatic while others are totally defined with all dynamics. Then again it's only 20 chapters so far. Could change in future. Updating Stability: As I read the whole 20 chaps in one go, I honestly am not informed well enough to comment on the updating Stability. But tbh I never really had any problem with anyone's updating schedule, so long the story remains interesting. So a 5/5 from me World Background: 4/5 While teenager me would've ranked "ASOIAF" as 10/5, unfortunately the adult me disagrees. My experience has already been soured with the catastrophe of the "Last Season" of GOT. Since there hasn't been much of a world building to this point, I'm assuming it to follow the original, Hence 4/5 Overall it's a good fanfic to pass time. One where I can guarantee that you aren't gonna lose your braincell in every second sentence or shiver with cringe with every dialogue. This is no masterpiece by any means. Not yet at least. But there isn't anything fundamentally wrong with it, aside from slow pace. But that's my personal gripe. So I'd implore everyone to give it a try at least.
GoodDay! Prospective Readers. It's my review of my own work, so obviously I am going to follow in the footsteps of the writers that came before me and give it a 5 Star. Anyway, some warning for the new readers. I am going to be here for the long haul, so if you are one of those who want action or something happening every chapter, I suggest you wait for about 3 chapters to be released before reading them,
Круть[img=update] все очена хорошо, ну просто жаль, что глав вышло так мало, ведь хочется читать и читать. А так работа вполне на уровне в отличии от прочих клонов.
Something that I have always wondered is if the Valyrians conquered the continent of Essos because all the noble families of Valyria died? It just doesn't make sense, who ruled the big cities in Essos? the slaves? Weren't there dragon lords ruling those cities? Didn't the families of Valyria have their own territories?
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐💟💟💟💟💟 well, so far so good. It was a nice and enjoyable reading for me. I wish you best of luck to continue your wonderful work. Thanks.
This is really good the only fall back for me is there is not enough chapters and the weekly chapters is kinda low
Man I'm loving this story, Game of Thrones is one of my favorite fictional universes and I'm very happy to see someone making such a good story using this world as a base. My only complaint is the frequency of posts, which is somewhat irregular, if you can, try posting more frequently or create a schedule so your readers know when a chapter is coming out. Great fanfic keep up the good work!!!!!!
this novel is so fun, can't understand why someone would leave a bad review .............................................................................
Dissapointment is what I felt when I read the story. Waste of reincarnation. I was so dissapointed that I feel dissapointed in my dissapointment at my dissapointment in your story.
Very nice story More chapter update please 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏I liked the story 🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯
5 stars from me. Very interesting plot and pace is alright. I like it. I hope Jon becomes the Business Tycoon of Westeros world. Powerful and richer than everyone.
Hello, is it possible to translate your work on other resources into another language? By crediting you as the author, of course.[img=обновить]
This story is a year old, ONE YEAR! And less than 100 chapters, the author wrote another 3 fanfictions and never finished them. The story is very good, but it seems to me to be one of thousands that will eventually be abandoned. Author, just remember that anyone can clone your story with some modifications.
This is one of the best GOT novels I have ever read on this platform. The novel is well thought out and exciting. The only problem is updates, don't be fooled by the 3 chapters a week, sometimes theres only 1 chapter a week which is seriously disappointing since I enjoy this novel so much. So far there has been no indication of any love interest, I can only hope that if there is one (hope there is) that it remains 1. If this turns into some kind of harem i'm out, although the MC does not seem to be the kind of guy who would be into a harem but u never know.
It’s definitely nicely written. A jon snow si story with exploration on warging as well as some semi modern technology. Definitely one of the best ASOIAF fic i have read.
This story is so slow it makes you want to rip your hair out. I'm 75 chapters in and the most significant thing that has happened was Jon making a trade deal with Olenna. The slow and pretty frequent useless chapters just make it a slog to read. The story itself is fine but it could have been told just as well in like half the time. Also, Val's presence in the story ruins it for me. She's obnoxious and doesn't listen and yet Jon still doesn't do anything cause she's pretty and related to Mance.
............................................................................................................................................................ SLOOOWW
Reveal Spoiler love love love this story. Author will there be romance and if there is will it be harem? Pls don't turn it into a harem. I'm always worried abt getting into a story then out of the blue getting Hit by a harem.
There's one thing I'm just really annoyed about, story is decent. But in c50 Starks and mc plan to build port on western side of their territory, but somehow that translates to building one on freaking Bear ISLAND. I mean what? How does that help north? It's an island, it won't help with trade or any proper military action. If we assume it would be used, which it wouldn't, it it would be very expensive detour, and you still would need to make one larger port on western shores of north just so that you can use that detour to freaking transport stuff to anyone but Mormonts. Please just look at the freaking westoros map, it's island + it's just in awful position for any kind of trade or naval action. Just PLEASE fix this absurdity. I mean just imagine US building their first proper port, but instead of building it on US mainland, they build it on puerto rico :D I mean clearly this whole thing was just way by author to hook up Jon with the Mormont girl, but it was just idiotic forced plot. Think of better excuse ;D I'm willing to remove this review as long as this issue is fixed, but till then it's going to stay, it's just so stupid and beyond all logic. Otherwise story is pretty nice.
SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!!
author if you can increase your updatses it will be better . waiting for more chapters . my views on noval . This fanfic is better than other but not the best . It has some plus point eg kingdom building and change in character how they are different from the show . cons are easy to go life . Got one of darkest show but in noval we didn't see .( i am 27 chapter btw ). so yeah its worth the time .
[img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update]
Waste of a reincarnation, very slow. I read all the chapters. Despite the minor changes it was 1 of the worst GOT fanfic I would've read why? Mc doesn't have any goals or use his knowledge in a way to affect the story. It feels like if u remove the reincarnation as the story might have progressed they seem...its like he's utilizing the knowledge.
It's an awesome read.and a interesting concept keep up the good work!![img=recommend]
Warning! Although this is a great fanfic, it's a pure slice-of-life fanfic with cute moments and all that good stuff but don't read it expecting anything to happen that is plot relevant I mean none!
The story is great, good character and world building. The only hang ups for me would be the pace of the story. more than 40 chapters and it's still during the greyjoy rebellion. It's a very slice of life story but I just want more story development or something.
The story is very good, maybe even one of the best GoT fanfics on this app. But the update speed is abysmal, and the chapters are very short.
`for the love of god you can make it go faster, he seems to be the type of author who follows the canon but it would not make sense not to prevent brandon from crippling or ned from dying and allow those things.
Evaluation: Subpar. (didn't you notice? same review content, since you did the same thing here from your HPSI). WQ: With less to no mistake grammatical error, however, monotonous dialogues/interaction & redundant thought process which is just a repeat of the cannon book of ASOIFVerse. 4/5 SD: With a slow to average pace of development and it also lacks MC & story progression since author-san decided to follow cannon or just go with the flow which is lackluster. 2/5 CD: MC is a transmigrator but his foreknowledge & adult mentality are lacking. Lack of utilization of ASOIAFVerse foreknowledge & his earth/previous life experiences. Too wholesome for my tastes. The only difference MC-SI made here is to stabilize Jon Snow mental state. 2/5 Advice: Author-san, I highly recommend reading enough SI/OC/Reader Insert FF more to help you create your own writing style when it comes to creating your SI FF as I have noticed that you are just tweaking the characters SI you have chosen as well as the story to make it yours which wouldn't help you in the long run. US: the stability of the updates are good enough as author-san make sure to prioritize quality work with less mistakes over quantity. 4/5 WB: There's nothing new as author-san decided that MC follows/observe cannon. 3/5 Don't be discouraged by the reviews but take it as a challenge to do better. Kudos to author-san and well wishes! xD
Writing Quality: 5/5 This is one of the most decent ones in this platform in terms of writing. The structure is well thought out without much noise. Never felt too cramped. Story Development: 3.5/5(overall) 2/5(personal) Not really blaming the author as I'm in that phase where I can't really enjoy any slow paced story. And this story is as slow as it gets. Wouldn't be surprised if only the childhood arc took 50+ chapters. So, this one will be a downvote from me. Not necessarily bad but not to my taste. Character Design: 4/5 At times I felt like I gave too much of a score here but then again some characters are really fleshed out. This one is really all over the place tbh. Some characters are totally monochromatic while others are totally defined with all dynamics. Then again it's only 20 chapters so far. Could change in future. Updating Stability: As I read the whole 20 chaps in one go, I honestly am not informed well enough to comment on the updating Stability. But tbh I never really had any problem with anyone's updating schedule, so long the story remains interesting. So a 5/5 from me World Background: 4/5 While teenager me would've ranked "ASOIAF" as 10/5, unfortunately the adult me disagrees. My experience has already been soured with the catastrophe of the "Last Season" of GOT. Since there hasn't been much of a world building to this point, I'm assuming it to follow the original, Hence 4/5 Overall it's a good fanfic to pass time. One where I can guarantee that you aren't gonna lose your braincell in every second sentence or shiver with cringe with every dialogue. This is no masterpiece by any means. Not yet at least. But there isn't anything fundamentally wrong with it, aside from slow pace. But that's my personal gripe. So I'd implore everyone to give it a try at least.
GoodDay! Prospective Readers. It's my review of my own work, so obviously I am going to follow in the footsteps of the writers that came before me and give it a 5 Star. Anyway, some warning for the new readers. I am going to be here for the long haul, so if you are one of those who want action or something happening every chapter, I suggest you wait for about 3 chapters to be released before reading them,
Круть[img=update] все очена хорошо, ну просто жаль, что глав вышло так мало, ведь хочется читать и читать. А так работа вполне на уровне в отличии от прочих клонов.
Something that I have always wondered is if the Valyrians conquered the continent of Essos because all the noble families of Valyria died? It just doesn't make sense, who ruled the big cities in Essos? the slaves? Weren't there dragon lords ruling those cities? Didn't the families of Valyria have their own territories?
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐💟💟💟💟💟 well, so far so good. It was a nice and enjoyable reading for me. I wish you best of luck to continue your wonderful work. Thanks.
This is really good the only fall back for me is there is not enough chapters and the weekly chapters is kinda low
Man I'm loving this story, Game of Thrones is one of my favorite fictional universes and I'm very happy to see someone making such a good story using this world as a base. My only complaint is the frequency of posts, which is somewhat irregular, if you can, try posting more frequently or create a schedule so your readers know when a chapter is coming out. Great fanfic keep up the good work!!!!!!
this novel is so fun, can't understand why someone would leave a bad review .............................................................................
Dissapointment is what I felt when I read the story. Waste of reincarnation. I was so dissapointed that I feel dissapointed in my dissapointment at my dissapointment in your story.
Very nice story More chapter update please 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏I liked the story 🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯
5 stars from me. Very interesting plot and pace is alright. I like it. I hope Jon becomes the Business Tycoon of Westeros world. Powerful and richer than everyone.
Hello, is it possible to translate your work on other resources into another language? By crediting you as the author, of course.[img=обновить]
This story is a year old, ONE YEAR! And less than 100 chapters, the author wrote another 3 fanfictions and never finished them. The story is very good, but it seems to me to be one of thousands that will eventually be abandoned. Author, just remember that anyone can clone your story with some modifications.
This is one of the best GOT novels I have ever read on this platform. The novel is well thought out and exciting. The only problem is updates, don't be fooled by the 3 chapters a week, sometimes theres only 1 chapter a week which is seriously disappointing since I enjoy this novel so much. So far there has been no indication of any love interest, I can only hope that if there is one (hope there is) that it remains 1. If this turns into some kind of harem i'm out, although the MC does not seem to be the kind of guy who would be into a harem but u never know.
It’s definitely nicely written. A jon snow si story with exploration on warging as well as some semi modern technology. Definitely one of the best ASOIAF fic i have read.
This story is so slow it makes you want to rip your hair out. I'm 75 chapters in and the most significant thing that has happened was Jon making a trade deal with Olenna. The slow and pretty frequent useless chapters just make it a slog to read. The story itself is fine but it could have been told just as well in like half the time. Also, Val's presence in the story ruins it for me. She's obnoxious and doesn't listen and yet Jon still doesn't do anything cause she's pretty and related to Mance.
............................................................................................................................................................ SLOOOWW
Reveal Spoiler love love love this story. Author will there be romance and if there is will it be harem? Pls don't turn it into a harem. I'm always worried abt getting into a story then out of the blue getting Hit by a harem.
There's one thing I'm just really annoyed about, story is decent. But in c50 Starks and mc plan to build port on western side of their territory, but somehow that translates to building one on freaking Bear ISLAND. I mean what? How does that help north? It's an island, it won't help with trade or any proper military action. If we assume it would be used, which it wouldn't, it it would be very expensive detour, and you still would need to make one larger port on western shores of north just so that you can use that detour to freaking transport stuff to anyone but Mormonts. Please just look at the freaking westoros map, it's island + it's just in awful position for any kind of trade or naval action. Just PLEASE fix this absurdity. I mean just imagine US building their first proper port, but instead of building it on US mainland, they build it on puerto rico :D I mean clearly this whole thing was just way by author to hook up Jon with the Mormont girl, but it was just idiotic forced plot. Think of better excuse ;D I'm willing to remove this review as long as this issue is fixed, but till then it's going to stay, it's just so stupid and beyond all logic. Otherwise story is pretty nice.
SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!! SOON!!
author if you can increase your updatses it will be better . waiting for more chapters . my views on noval . This fanfic is better than other but not the best . It has some plus point eg kingdom building and change in character how they are different from the show . cons are easy to go life . Got one of darkest show but in noval we didn't see .( i am 27 chapter btw ). so yeah its worth the time .
[img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update]
Waste of a reincarnation, very slow. I read all the chapters. Despite the minor changes it was 1 of the worst GOT fanfic I would've read why? Mc doesn't have any goals or use his knowledge in a way to affect the story. It feels like if u remove the reincarnation as the story might have progressed they seem...its like he's utilizing the knowledge.
It's an awesome read.and a interesting concept keep up the good work!![img=recommend]
Warning! Although this is a great fanfic, it's a pure slice-of-life fanfic with cute moments and all that good stuff but don't read it expecting anything to happen that is plot relevant I mean none!
The story is great, good character and world building. The only hang ups for me would be the pace of the story. more than 40 chapters and it's still during the greyjoy rebellion. It's a very slice of life story but I just want more story development or something.
The story is very good, maybe even one of the best GoT fanfics on this app. But the update speed is abysmal, and the chapters are very short.
`for the love of god you can make it go faster, he seems to be the type of author who follows the canon but it would not make sense not to prevent brandon from crippling or ned from dying and allow those things.
Evaluation: Subpar. (didn't you notice? same review content, since you did the same thing here from your HPSI). WQ: With less to no mistake grammatical error, however, monotonous dialogues/interaction & redundant thought process which is just a repeat of the cannon book of ASOIFVerse. 4/5 SD: With a slow to average pace of development and it also lacks MC & story progression since author-san decided to follow cannon or just go with the flow which is lackluster. 2/5 CD: MC is a transmigrator but his foreknowledge & adult mentality are lacking. Lack of utilization of ASOIAFVerse foreknowledge & his earth/previous life experiences. Too wholesome for my tastes. The only difference MC-SI made here is to stabilize Jon Snow mental state. 2/5 Advice: Author-san, I highly recommend reading enough SI/OC/Reader Insert FF more to help you create your own writing style when it comes to creating your SI FF as I have noticed that you are just tweaking the characters SI you have chosen as well as the story to make it yours which wouldn't help you in the long run. US: the stability of the updates are good enough as author-san make sure to prioritize quality work with less mistakes over quantity. 4/5 WB: There's nothing new as author-san decided that MC follows/observe cannon. 3/5 Don't be discouraged by the reviews but take it as a challenge to do better. Kudos to author-san and well wishes! xD
It's still early but it's nicely writen