Reviews of Is that a Wisp? by Suiyan - Webnovel

665Reviews

4.62

  • Writing Quality
  • Stability of Updates
  • Story Development
  • Character Design
  • World Background

Share your thoughts with others

Write a review
Suiyan
LV 12 Badge

Hi guys, this is the very first chapter, and I would like to make some things clear. 1- There will be romance? Well, a little, but I'm not a romanticist. Hence, this will take place 'SUPER FU***NG LATE' in the story. So don't worry about Feifei for now. She isn't the main point here, Krune's life as a wisp is. 2- If you haven't noticed the spaceship yet, you better know that this is a novel where technology exists. Still, it is mostly used for convenience. It takes almost no part in the cultivators' strength, so don't expect super mechas or spiritual armors or whatever. Think about this universe as if our nowadays technology meets the ancient cultivation world and they just get well together. It also helps to create a lot of funny events, so... 3- The first 20 chapters or so doesn't picture it well. Still, like a wisp, Krune only has the little knowledge that he learned in the forest and by secretly visiting the nearby villages. He knows about the technological world but had barely involved himself with it before leaving the Katiu Forest. 4- As a nonhuman, Krune has no EQ when considering the humans' culture and habits. It is definitely one of the top trends of this novel, so you can expect a lot of 'smashing my face against the common sense wall' after chapter 20 more or less. 5- Will there be harem in this novel? No, there won't be any, be it Krune or any other character in the entire story. 'Sorry, Mario, but your princess is in another castle.' I'm the type of person that can't accept a world where a man having several wives is okay. Still, a woman having more than one man is considered a betrayal, this is BS! I have no problem with novels where both genres have the same rights, though. 6-The book is now passing through a re-edition. The story won't change anywhere, just the grammar will be fixed. You will notice that the grammar will turn bad at some point, and then it will come back to normal after chapter 100. Thanks to my editor for all the work on the existing chapters so far. o/

4yr
View 100 Replies
Dao_Vanquisher

Dao Vanquisher is back to strike upon thee with great vengeance and furious anger! This novel is a typical low-effort, poorly written trash that makes people cry later for having wasted their time on it. The MC is a kid that never grows emotionally or intellectually. The enemies are either baddies or goddies lol. They either bully him or protect him. I was hoping for something unique but the author can't even replicate the good points of those cliche' novels: the thrill of life and death battles, high risk - high rewards situations, grand ambitions, the satisfaction of revenge, etc. You will not find any of that here. The author doesn't understand English grammar or runs his writing through a proofreader to polish it before publicising - he just wants to make quick money and take advantage of the ignorant kids who have yet to see a real Dao and will consume his garbage novel.

2d
View 0 Replies
peppermnt

I love the writers mind fr. I have read two of their books that are pretty long and I am so amazed by how they are able to come up with such interesting, unique and diverse worlds and plots. its so nice to read a story and be amazed by all the connections and adventures the characters are going through. if I had to say one thing tho is that the author really writes women like they only have one functioning brain cells and its pretty apparent in their books unfortunately. I can understand one girl being a tsundere but every bloody woman thats not the main interest is always freaking annoying?? Like they are hundreds of years old but still acting like 12 year old girls still shy and not speaking their minds? Make it make sense ohh. Anyways I still love the girlies cause the author doesn't leave them just like that but we get to see other sides of their personalities and I end up loving them as well. Its just that for all your femal characters in your whole UNIVERSES to act the same way EVERY time they meet the main lead is strange is all I'm saying šŸ™ˆ. absolutely no hate to the author, please keep writing and please give the girlies something different PLEASE!

Reveal Spoiler
5mth
View 0 Replies
Jayden_Brown_9837

Awwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwsssssssssssssooooooooooommmmmmmmmeeeeeeeeeee really like this

9mth
View 0 Replies
RESHI_RAM

Peak. Like one of the first I ever read. Read it so long ago. Never even finished it because I got to the end of the chapter that were out at the time and got side tracked. But peak novel.

11mth
View 0 Replies
Ermaac

waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time

11mth
View 0 Replies
KayaReads

Great novel by Suiyan. I think this is there first novel on here so the beginning is a little rough, but it smoothes out quickly and developed into a great story. Has good world building and a good mix of serious/comedy.

11mth
View 0 Replies
DaoistMygx5K

Li regret going to the final chapters.. Now I no longer want to read this story I was only on 30 Iā€™m gonna go read something else..

1yr
View 0 Replies
kabri_Lyon

This book is one of the best ever, am missing my krune šŸ˜­šŸ˜­šŸ˜­ I'll think of him whenever I see a rainbow šŸ˜

1yr
View 0 Replies
lucaskubo

I honestly asked for the willingness to read, I really liked the story but in chapter 263 it was the FOURTH time they got the MC's age wrong. Like it's been 2, or at most 3, months since he went to the alchemy competition. A few weeks before the alchemy competition he said he was 12. He said it had been 5 months since they were in this universe, before he talked about participating in the competition. And before I came to this universe he was 11, how did the author have the incompetence to calculate his age so badly? HOW DOES IT MAKE ANY SENSE THAT HE WILL BE 13 NEXT MONTH? Honestly there has been an increase of about 3 years so far, this would be the 4th, at this rate it's as if the author doesn't know basic mathematics! For a story that likes to highlight the MC's remaining lifespan, this ruined the story for me. Other than that, the system of parallel professions and the monetary system are horribly poorly explained. The currency is as always, the spiritual stone, so far so good, but from then on it is divided into rank and quality, quality conversion was never given, and rank took 240 chapters. He gained many stones throughout the story but it never made sense, because it took very little time and chapters for him to gain a higher rank.

1yr
View 1 Replies
Michelle_Aspberg

I have to say that this is my all time favorite book. The story is amazing and deep. Itā€™s been a few years since I last read this but it still feels like I can remember everything! I wish there was more stories like this ā™„ļø

1yr
View 0 Replies
Alex_Lopez_7731

I feel like the overall story is good but the forced comedy kinda takes away from the story, additionally the characters on his team are kind of annoying to me mainly because they blatantly disrespect the mc for in some cases stupid reasons.

1yr
View 0 Replies
SD_Axium

it took me a long time to get around to reading this in its entirety. It's a really fun read with an interesting power system and many fun characters. Definitely recommend it

1yr
View 0 Replies
1Kevoer
LV 13 Badge

I read more than 330 chapters, and I can say that the story is relatively good, but it has glaring flaws in the description of scenarios and characters, not to mention that for me the story seems very slow and dragged, in general I give it a 3.8, even more I feel that a soul is missing from the story.

1yr
View 0 Replies
FlyingSnowFox

,............................,....................

1yr
View 0 Replies
HugeHaddock_3301

This is an amazing novel if you love a mix of a slow paced story but fast-paced action. The MC isn't completely OP from the start and works to become powerful. The humor is amazing, and I love the take on a wisp cultivating. The characters are great and enjoyable, and the power system is well thought out. There are some minor grammatical errors in the beginning but it really improves around chapter 50.

1yr
View 0 Replies
Evan_Schoenwald

Absolutely one of my Favorite books to read.

1yr
View 0 Replies
NoM_No

wheeee....wheeee.... "..." "..." waaaa waaaaaaaaaaa waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

2yr
View 0 Replies
r210
LV 15 Badge

was just great, could have added more chapters at the end explaining about the rest

Reveal Spoiler
2yr
View 0 Replies
Vincent_Gosset

good story with links with autorsā€™s authers works. nice to follow MCs with good nature not just some tyran who kills all opposition. good balance between tolernace and violence for auto protection.

2yr
View 0 Replies
SatanicPuppy

Fantastic story I just wish it didnā€™t have to end

2yr
View 0 Replies
nathan_henderson

Loved the story. From the world building to all the side characters. It was very fulfilling and ended with just the right amount of closure.

2yr
View 0 Replies
Trulylifted_60

Such a great read I love it. One of the best books on here

img
2yr
View 0 Replies
DaoistazVFGr

Dull, boring, repetitive. First chapters looked interesting and fresh. But very fast everything came down to "just yet another generic novel". There is no goal, no conflict, no struggles, no mysteries. Nothing. The whole story about MC undertakes missions "go from place A to place B and retrieve some thing", participates in dull fightings with small flies and explores dungeon. And everything endlessly repeats itself from city to city, from universe to universe, from realm to realm: the same events, the same organisations and guilds, even the phrases and "jokes" the same (if you consider calling someone idiot to be a joke in the first place). Out of the blue fantasy world have technologies, but not all - just internet, smartphones and computers and spaceships, while lacking necessary science foundation and necessary infrastructure. There aren't even cars. Author's world have spaceships while not have cars and everything else our own civilization have. This setting looks very crude, artificial and untrue. Author was just lazy to make up fantasy substitution for technologies but also doesn't bother to properly integrate technologies in the setting. "MC needs a way to long distance communication? Well, here is a smartphones" - that's author's attitude. The whole novel about monotonous grind with little amount of boring fights. That's all.

2yr
View 1 Replies
FizzywigHoid

the concept for the story is good and the world building is as well. unfortunately, at least in the first 50 chapters almost all the characters are very one dimensional. while the comedy does have its moments, much of it feels forced to the detriment of the story. there is enough potential there that I might come back and read more someday.

2yr
View 0 Replies
XxEyeDragonxX

WARNING!!! I have not read the story, nor did I want to read it after seeing that the chapters barely have 1 or 2 pages of word and the chapters begin to be paid after chapter 60.... The story has 1500 chapters... and from what I've read in the reviews this story is not worth it... 2 or 3 euro cents per chapter... 1520 chapters if we remove the free chapters, between 30 and 45 euros, sincerely congratulations to whoever pays that, sincerely I prefer people who ask for donations through patreon or similar but still have access to all the content, free, anyway to pay for that I'm going to buy a few novels, which will surely have better quality and will be much more content

2yr
View 0 Replies
Sinteyr

Honestly I'm not sure how to feel about this novel. The first I'd say 900 chapters were probably some of the best written story I've ever read so far. It constantly had interesting characters with massive developments into the larger world; and I loved some of the plot points like the god path realm. However I really can't say much after somewhere in the 900's It started to feel like a completely different novel, the only somewhat interesting character that was introduced was Cultivator and all the other interesting characters were basically scrapped. We basically saw a whole new side to Krune; he was alone after so long. And it is that point that unfortunately made me lose interest, while I did eventually finish it after a 2'd try; after a while it become fairly boring. I still think it's a lovely novel, but it lost what made it unique.

Reveal Spoiler
2yr
View 0 Replies
SomeAnotherMan

I like it to the end including some boring parts. It's first completed book for me.

2yr
View 0 Replies
SoulBringer

I'm only on chapter 7 and this is my first time reading a cultivation novel that I enjoy and I LOVE IT! Normally i hate cultivation but this is something else! I love how original it is like wisps are the creatures that are never taken seriously. The only thing I would like could there be an chapter stating all the cultivation levels because I really struggle to understand how strong some people are but it could just be that these levels are basic cultivation fan knowledge. Overall though, great novel!

2yr
View 0 Replies
Kancha_T

F**king great move Webnovel! Well done. You have crossed all heights I believe. It takes 2 FP to now unlock a chapter. Greedy pigs.

2yr
View 0 Replies
Drunken_Shifu

Astounding! I like the unique lead. I started reading this after watching the Slime anime, and I was pleased to find it so interesting. Krune's low EQ is just hilarious.

2yr
View 0 Replies
Suiyan
LV 12 Badge

Hi guys, this is the very first chapter, and I would like to make some things clear. 1- There will be romance? Well, a little, but I'm not a romanticist. Hence, this will take place 'SUPER FU***NG LATE' in the story. So don't worry about Feifei for now. She isn't the main point here, Krune's life as a wisp is. 2- If you haven't noticed the spaceship yet, you better know that this is a novel where technology exists. Still, it is mostly used for convenience. It takes almost no part in the cultivators' strength, so don't expect super mechas or spiritual armors or whatever. Think about this universe as if our nowadays technology meets the ancient cultivation world and they just get well together. It also helps to create a lot of funny events, so... 3- The first 20 chapters or so doesn't picture it well. Still, like a wisp, Krune only has the little knowledge that he learned in the forest and by secretly visiting the nearby villages. He knows about the technological world but had barely involved himself with it before leaving the Katiu Forest. 4- As a nonhuman, Krune has no EQ when considering the humans' culture and habits. It is definitely one of the top trends of this novel, so you can expect a lot of 'smashing my face against the common sense wall' after chapter 20 more or less. 5- Will there be harem in this novel? No, there won't be any, be it Krune or any other character in the entire story. 'Sorry, Mario, but your princess is in another castle.' I'm the type of person that can't accept a world where a man having several wives is okay. Still, a woman having more than one man is considered a betrayal, this is BS! I have no problem with novels where both genres have the same rights, though. 6-The book is now passing through a re-edition. The story won't change anywhere, just the grammar will be fixed. You will notice that the grammar will turn bad at some point, and then it will come back to normal after chapter 100. Thanks to my editor for all the work on the existing chapters so far. o/

4yr
View 100 Replies
Dao_Vanquisher

Dao Vanquisher is back to strike upon thee with great vengeance and furious anger! This novel is a typical low-effort, poorly written trash that makes people cry later for having wasted their time on it. The MC is a kid that never grows emotionally or intellectually. The enemies are either baddies or goddies lol. They either bully him or protect him. I was hoping for something unique but the author can't even replicate the good points of those cliche' novels: the thrill of life and death battles, high risk - high rewards situations, grand ambitions, the satisfaction of revenge, etc. You will not find any of that here. The author doesn't understand English grammar or runs his writing through a proofreader to polish it before publicising - he just wants to make quick money and take advantage of the ignorant kids who have yet to see a real Dao and will consume his garbage novel.

2d
View 0 Replies
peppermnt

I love the writers mind fr. I have read two of their books that are pretty long and I am so amazed by how they are able to come up with such interesting, unique and diverse worlds and plots. its so nice to read a story and be amazed by all the connections and adventures the characters are going through. if I had to say one thing tho is that the author really writes women like they only have one functioning brain cells and its pretty apparent in their books unfortunately. I can understand one girl being a tsundere but every bloody woman thats not the main interest is always freaking annoying?? Like they are hundreds of years old but still acting like 12 year old girls still shy and not speaking their minds? Make it make sense ohh. Anyways I still love the girlies cause the author doesn't leave them just like that but we get to see other sides of their personalities and I end up loving them as well. Its just that for all your femal characters in your whole UNIVERSES to act the same way EVERY time they meet the main lead is strange is all I'm saying šŸ™ˆ. absolutely no hate to the author, please keep writing and please give the girlies something different PLEASE!

Reveal Spoiler
5mth
View 0 Replies
Jayden_Brown_9837

Awwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwsssssssssssssooooooooooommmmmmmmmeeeeeeeeeee really like this

9mth
View 0 Replies
RESHI_RAM

Peak. Like one of the first I ever read. Read it so long ago. Never even finished it because I got to the end of the chapter that were out at the time and got side tracked. But peak novel.

11mth
View 0 Replies
Ermaac

waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time waste of time

11mth
View 0 Replies
KayaReads

Great novel by Suiyan. I think this is there first novel on here so the beginning is a little rough, but it smoothes out quickly and developed into a great story. Has good world building and a good mix of serious/comedy.

11mth
View 0 Replies
DaoistMygx5K

Li regret going to the final chapters.. Now I no longer want to read this story I was only on 30 Iā€™m gonna go read something else..

1yr
View 0 Replies
kabri_Lyon

This book is one of the best ever, am missing my krune šŸ˜­šŸ˜­šŸ˜­ I'll think of him whenever I see a rainbow šŸ˜

1yr
View 0 Replies
lucaskubo

I honestly asked for the willingness to read, I really liked the story but in chapter 263 it was the FOURTH time they got the MC's age wrong. Like it's been 2, or at most 3, months since he went to the alchemy competition. A few weeks before the alchemy competition he said he was 12. He said it had been 5 months since they were in this universe, before he talked about participating in the competition. And before I came to this universe he was 11, how did the author have the incompetence to calculate his age so badly? HOW DOES IT MAKE ANY SENSE THAT HE WILL BE 13 NEXT MONTH? Honestly there has been an increase of about 3 years so far, this would be the 4th, at this rate it's as if the author doesn't know basic mathematics! For a story that likes to highlight the MC's remaining lifespan, this ruined the story for me. Other than that, the system of parallel professions and the monetary system are horribly poorly explained. The currency is as always, the spiritual stone, so far so good, but from then on it is divided into rank and quality, quality conversion was never given, and rank took 240 chapters. He gained many stones throughout the story but it never made sense, because it took very little time and chapters for him to gain a higher rank.

1yr
View 1 Replies
Michelle_Aspberg

I have to say that this is my all time favorite book. The story is amazing and deep. Itā€™s been a few years since I last read this but it still feels like I can remember everything! I wish there was more stories like this ā™„ļø

1yr
View 0 Replies
Alex_Lopez_7731

I feel like the overall story is good but the forced comedy kinda takes away from the story, additionally the characters on his team are kind of annoying to me mainly because they blatantly disrespect the mc for in some cases stupid reasons.

1yr
View 0 Replies
SD_Axium

it took me a long time to get around to reading this in its entirety. It's a really fun read with an interesting power system and many fun characters. Definitely recommend it

1yr
View 0 Replies
1Kevoer
LV 13 Badge

I read more than 330 chapters, and I can say that the story is relatively good, but it has glaring flaws in the description of scenarios and characters, not to mention that for me the story seems very slow and dragged, in general I give it a 3.8, even more I feel that a soul is missing from the story.

1yr
View 0 Replies
FlyingSnowFox

,............................,....................

1yr
View 0 Replies
HugeHaddock_3301

This is an amazing novel if you love a mix of a slow paced story but fast-paced action. The MC isn't completely OP from the start and works to become powerful. The humor is amazing, and I love the take on a wisp cultivating. The characters are great and enjoyable, and the power system is well thought out. There are some minor grammatical errors in the beginning but it really improves around chapter 50.

1yr
View 0 Replies
Evan_Schoenwald

Absolutely one of my Favorite books to read.

1yr
View 0 Replies
NoM_No

wheeee....wheeee.... "..." "..." waaaa waaaaaaaaaaa waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

2yr
View 0 Replies
r210
LV 15 Badge

was just great, could have added more chapters at the end explaining about the rest

Reveal Spoiler
2yr
View 0 Replies
Vincent_Gosset

good story with links with autorsā€™s authers works. nice to follow MCs with good nature not just some tyran who kills all opposition. good balance between tolernace and violence for auto protection.

2yr
View 0 Replies
SatanicPuppy

Fantastic story I just wish it didnā€™t have to end

2yr
View 0 Replies
nathan_henderson

Loved the story. From the world building to all the side characters. It was very fulfilling and ended with just the right amount of closure.

2yr
View 0 Replies
Trulylifted_60

Such a great read I love it. One of the best books on here

img
2yr
View 0 Replies
DaoistazVFGr

Dull, boring, repetitive. First chapters looked interesting and fresh. But very fast everything came down to "just yet another generic novel". There is no goal, no conflict, no struggles, no mysteries. Nothing. The whole story about MC undertakes missions "go from place A to place B and retrieve some thing", participates in dull fightings with small flies and explores dungeon. And everything endlessly repeats itself from city to city, from universe to universe, from realm to realm: the same events, the same organisations and guilds, even the phrases and "jokes" the same (if you consider calling someone idiot to be a joke in the first place). Out of the blue fantasy world have technologies, but not all - just internet, smartphones and computers and spaceships, while lacking necessary science foundation and necessary infrastructure. There aren't even cars. Author's world have spaceships while not have cars and everything else our own civilization have. This setting looks very crude, artificial and untrue. Author was just lazy to make up fantasy substitution for technologies but also doesn't bother to properly integrate technologies in the setting. "MC needs a way to long distance communication? Well, here is a smartphones" - that's author's attitude. The whole novel about monotonous grind with little amount of boring fights. That's all.

2yr
View 1 Replies
FizzywigHoid

the concept for the story is good and the world building is as well. unfortunately, at least in the first 50 chapters almost all the characters are very one dimensional. while the comedy does have its moments, much of it feels forced to the detriment of the story. there is enough potential there that I might come back and read more someday.

2yr
View 0 Replies
XxEyeDragonxX

WARNING!!! I have not read the story, nor did I want to read it after seeing that the chapters barely have 1 or 2 pages of word and the chapters begin to be paid after chapter 60.... The story has 1500 chapters... and from what I've read in the reviews this story is not worth it... 2 or 3 euro cents per chapter... 1520 chapters if we remove the free chapters, between 30 and 45 euros, sincerely congratulations to whoever pays that, sincerely I prefer people who ask for donations through patreon or similar but still have access to all the content, free, anyway to pay for that I'm going to buy a few novels, which will surely have better quality and will be much more content

2yr
View 0 Replies
Sinteyr

Honestly I'm not sure how to feel about this novel. The first I'd say 900 chapters were probably some of the best written story I've ever read so far. It constantly had interesting characters with massive developments into the larger world; and I loved some of the plot points like the god path realm. However I really can't say much after somewhere in the 900's It started to feel like a completely different novel, the only somewhat interesting character that was introduced was Cultivator and all the other interesting characters were basically scrapped. We basically saw a whole new side to Krune; he was alone after so long. And it is that point that unfortunately made me lose interest, while I did eventually finish it after a 2'd try; after a while it become fairly boring. I still think it's a lovely novel, but it lost what made it unique.

Reveal Spoiler
2yr
View 0 Replies
SomeAnotherMan

I like it to the end including some boring parts. It's first completed book for me.

2yr
View 0 Replies
SoulBringer

I'm only on chapter 7 and this is my first time reading a cultivation novel that I enjoy and I LOVE IT! Normally i hate cultivation but this is something else! I love how original it is like wisps are the creatures that are never taken seriously. The only thing I would like could there be an chapter stating all the cultivation levels because I really struggle to understand how strong some people are but it could just be that these levels are basic cultivation fan knowledge. Overall though, great novel!

2yr
View 0 Replies
Kancha_T

F**king great move Webnovel! Well done. You have crossed all heights I believe. It takes 2 FP to now unlock a chapter. Greedy pigs.

2yr
View 0 Replies
Drunken_Shifu

Astounding! I like the unique lead. I started reading this after watching the Slime anime, and I was pleased to find it so interesting. Krune's low EQ is just hilarious.

2yr
View 0 Replies
next page