I don't know who created it. There are so many horror stories out there and without more information, it's difficult to determine the creator of this particular one.
There's no way to tell for sure who wrote it. It might be a new or emerging horror writer trying to make a name for themselves with a unique and disturbing concept like a horror story centered around the big toe. It could also be someone who had a personal experience related to the big toe (maybe a minor accident that they turned into a horror - filled narrative) and decided to write it down without much public attention or recognition yet.
I'm not sure specifically as there could be many 'big toe horror stories'. It might be about something really scary involving a big toe, like a big toe getting cut off in a really gruesome way in a horror scenario, or maybe a big toe being possessed by some evil spirit in a fictional horror story.
There was a girl who woke up in the middle of the night feeling something tickling her big toe. She thought it was just her cat at first. But when she turned on the light, she saw a huge spider on her toe. It was hairy and had big fangs. She screamed and was too terrified to move for a few seconds. Eventually, she managed to shake it off, but she was haunted by that moment for a long time.
I'm not sure specifically what 'the big toe horror story' is as there could be many such stories. It might involve something terrifying related to a big toe, like a grotesque injury, a cursed big toe, or a spooky encounter involving a big toe.
The scariest part might be when there is a sudden and unexpected pain in your big toe with no obvious cause. Like in a horror story where a person is just sitting quietly and suddenly feels a sharp pain in their big toe as if it's being cut or bitten, and there's no one around and no explanation for it.
One scary big toe story could be about a person waking up in the middle of the night and seeing a strange, long shadow over their big toe. As they try to move, they find they're paralyzed and the shadow starts to inch closer, like something is about to grab their toe. It's a classic case of sleep paralysis mixed with a spooky apparition focused on the toe.
Since there's no more context about this 'cut off big toe with axe story', it's impossible to say who did such a thing. It could be anyone in the story's context, but without further details, we can't determine it.
Yes, there are some big toe scary stories that claim to be based on real events. For example, there was a story about a surgical mistake where a patient's big toe was amputated wrongly. After that, the patient reported seeing apparitions of their lost big toe at night. They said it would float around their room, which was really terrifying for them.
In a horror story, your big toe could be the target of a cursed object. For example, you find an old ring at a flea market and put it on your toe. But then, every time the clock strikes midnight, your big toe feels like it's being squeezed by an invisible hand, and the pain is excruciating.