What are the most well - known Fire Island Lighthouse ghost stories?

The most well - known might be the story of the spectral keeper. He's often seen as a shadowy figure maintaining the lighthouse in the afterlife. It gives an eerie feeling as if the past and present are intertwined. People who have visited the lighthouse at night sometimes swear they can sense his presence.

A story about a phantom horse and rider is also popular. The rider is said to gallop through the island's forests at night. No one knows who the rider was in life, but the sound of hoofbeats in the still of the night can send shivers down your spine. Some think it could be a lost soul from the island's past.

Some say that at night, you can hear the cries and whispers of the dead on Poveglia Island. This is because of the large number of people who died there in a very cruel and difficult way. The collective memory of all that death seems to have left a spectral presence. There are reports of strange lights as well, which might be related to these ghostly manifestations.

A story about a phantom boatman is also quite famous. It is said that there was once a boatman who had an accident on the waters around Roosevelt Island. His spirit is now seen on moonlit nights, rowing a phantom boat near the shore. It's a spooky sight for those who are out late at night.

One popular Fire Island Lighthouse ghost story is about a former lighthouse keeper. It's said that his spirit still roams around the lighthouse at night. People claim to have seen a shadowy figure near the top of the lighthouse, as if he is still on duty, checking the light.

The most well - known might be the one about the haunted lighthouse. The lighthouse has a long history, and with that history comes the legend of the keeper's ghost. His presence is felt by many who visit at night. It gives an eerie feeling, as if you're being watched by someone from a different time.

The story of the club member's ghost is quite well - known. People see his apparition as a sign of the club's long and storied past. It's a connection to the old days of the club when it was a hub for the rich and famous.

The story of the haunted Roche Harbor Resort is quite well - known. The apparition of the woman in white there has been reported by many over the years. It gives the resort an air of mystery.

One of the ghost stories is about a lighthouse keeper who is said to still haunt the area. He might be seen as a shadowy figure near the lighthouse at night.

Well, the story of the wandering maid is quite well - known. People often say that late at night, you can hear the soft rustling of her skirt as she moves along the hallways. It's as if she's still making sure the rooms are clean and the guests are comfortable.