The unknown nature of the red ball makes it scary. It does things that normal balls don't do, like rolling on its own or floating in the air.
Once upon a time, there was a little girl who found a red ball in an old attic. Every night when she went to sleep, the red ball would start to roll on its own. It made strange noises as it rolled across the wooden floor. One night, she woke up to see the red ball floating in the air, with a pair of glowing eyes on it. She was so scared that she ran out of her room and never went back to that attic again.
Red eyes are often associated with danger or the unknown. In nature, some predatory animals have red eyes, which gives us an instinctual fear. In a scary story, red eyes can represent an evil or supernatural entity that is lurking in the shadows, waiting to harm the protagonist.
The unknown nature of it. We don't know what the red spot really is, whether it's a sign of something evil or a portal to a bad place.
The color red is often associated with danger, blood, and aggression. So when it's on a mask in a scary story, it immediately gives a sense of threat. Also, a mask hides the face, creating an air of mystery. We can't see the emotions or intentions of the person (or thing) behind it. It could be anyone or anything, and that uncertainty is very frightening.
The fact that it starts with a normal childhood game makes it scary. We all know Red Rover as a fun game, so when it turns into something spooky, it's unexpected.
The mystery around the red spot. Not knowing what it is or what it represents can be really scary.
The 'Red Man' in the scary story might be terrifying because of his appearance. Maybe he has a menacing red face and glowing eyes. His actions could also be very spooky, like suddenly appearing in the dark and chasing people.
It could be that the character wearing the red cloak is very mysterious. If the story doesn't reveal much about who or what is under the cloak, our imagination runs wild and we tend to think of the scariest possibilities. For example, it could be a ghost or a monster. Also, the actions associated with the red cloak wearer, like suddenly disappearing or leaving strange marks, can add to the scariness.
Well, it's not just how she looks. It's also her actions. She haunts people, makes their vehicles malfunction, and gives them this feeling of impending doom. She seems to have a malevolent intent, like she's out to harm or terrify those who cross her path. For example, the way she made the young man in the car feel a cold hand on his shoulder was really scary.
Red eyes in a scary story can be terrifying because they are often associated with the unknown. It could be a demon, a ghost, or some kind of malevolent spirit. Their redness might suggest anger, evil intentions, or a connection to the darker forces. For example, in many horror movies, the villain or the monster has red eyes to make it look more menacing and to instill fear in the audience.