Some people might create this kind of fanfiction out of a desire for a very different and edgy take on the characters. They want to explore the darker side of relationships, even if it's completely against the original portrayal of Ron and Harry's friendship.
One possible reason could be that the creators are trying to explore the 'what if' scenarios in a very extreme way. They might think that by introducing such a dark element like abuse into a relationship that was originally based on friendship, they can create a new and unique narrative. However, this often goes against the core values of the original Harry Potter series, which is centered around love, friendship, and courage. It could also be a sign of some creators having a very different view of the characters, perhaps influenced by their own personal issues or a desire to be different from the mainstream fanfiction.
One reason could be for shock value. Some authors like to create extreme and unexpected scenarios to get a reaction from readers. Another could be a different interpretation of Harry's character. Maybe they see some latent flaws in him that could lead to such behavior in certain extreme situations.
One reason could be to explore the dark side of human nature. By having Harry kill Ron, the writer might be showing how a good character can be corrupted. Another reason could be to create a shock factor. It's a very unexpected and extreme scenario that can draw readers in.
Some people might just want to explore alternative scenarios for the sake of creativity. They may think it's interesting to see how the story would unfold if there was animosity between them.
Well, it might be because some fans feel that Slytherin has been somewhat demonized in the original books. So, they create fanfiction where Slytherin is the victim of abuse, perhaps as a way to give the house more depth and sympathy. Also, the idea of abuse can create a lot of drama and conflict, which are elements that make a story interesting. Fanfiction writers might be using this concept to attract readers who are interested in more complex and edgy storylines. Additionally, it could be a form of exploring the morality and ethics within the Harry Potter universe in a very extreme way.
It could also be a form of catharsis for those who have experienced abuse in real life, though this is a rather controversial way of dealing with it. By writing or reading about abuse in a fictional context, they may feel they are processing their own feelings, but it can also be triggering for others. Another reason might be that some writers simply want to create shock value to get more attention for their work.
One possible reason is that some fanfiction writers simply want to break the rules and norms of the original story. They see the established relationships as something to be toyed with, without considering the implications. Also, there might be a small subset of people who have some sort of personal issues or biases that they project onto the characters, leading to the creation of such a negative and untrue scenario in fanfiction.
Well, some writers might be interested in exploring the 'what if' scenarios that are not part of the original story. It could also be a way to express their own views on relationships that are different from what was presented in the 'Harry Potter' series. Additionally, it could be a means to add a sense of realism, as in real life, relationships can face such challenges, even if it's not what we expect for these beloved characters.
Some writers might be exploring dark themes for the sake of drama. They think it can create intense emotions and complex character arcs.
Some writers might be interested in exploring the darker side of human nature. They could use the well - known Batman - Robin relationship and twist it to show how power dynamics can go wrong. It's also possible that they want to create shock value to get more attention for their work.
One reason could be a desire for a darker, more edgy take on the characters. Some fans like to explore the 'what if' scenarios that are completely different from the original narrative. They might want to add more conflict and drama to the relationship between Legolas and Thranduil.