One horror valentine story could be about a girl who received a box of chocolates on Valentine's Day. When she opened it, instead of normal chocolates, she saw human teeth inside. It turned out her deranged ex - boyfriend was behind it, trying to terrify her as revenge for their break - up.
There was a couple who went on a Valentine's Day trip. They checked into a supposedly romantic hotel. But at night, they heard strange noises in the room. When they called the front desk, no one answered. They were terrified all night, and in the morning, they found out that the hotel had a history of hauntings and the staff had left early to avoid the place on Valentine's Day.
One Valentine's Day, a girl received a box of chocolates from a secret admirer. When she opened it, a swarm of spiders crawled out. It turned out an evil neighbor who had a grudge against her family had sent it to terrify her.
One Valentine's Day, a girl received a box of chocolates from an anonymous sender. When she ate one, it tasted strange. Later that night, she started seeing strange apparitions in her room. Turns out, the chocolates were laced with a hallucinogenic drug by a deranged stalker who had been watching her for months.
Once on Valentine's Day, a girl received a box of chocolates from an anonymous sender. When she ate one, it tasted strange. Later she found out the chocolates were laced with a hallucinogenic drug. She started seeing terrifying visions of a faceless figure following her everywhere. It was a truly horrifying Valentine's Day experience.
One funny Valentine's story is about a guy who accidentally sent his love letter to his grandma instead of his girlfriend. His grandma thought it was the sweetest thing and called him up to say how much she loved him. It was really embarrassing for him at first but then it became a hilarious family joke.
One Valentine Swappin Scary Story could be about a couple who exchanged Valentine's gifts. The girl gave the boy a locket. But every time he opened it, he saw a different, menacing face. At night, he would hear strange whispers that seemed to come from the locket, as if it was cursed.
One well - known Christian Valentine love story is about Saint Valentine himself. Legend has it that he was a priest in Rome. He defied the emperor's ban on marriage for young men (as the emperor thought single men made better soldiers). Valentine secretly performed marriage ceremonies for young lovers. He was eventually martyred, but his name became associated with love. His acts of kindness towards the lovers in the name of Christian love are an important part of this story.
One dark Valentine's story could be about a couple where one partner has been secretly plotting revenge all along. On Valentine's Day, instead of a romantic gesture, they reveal all the lies and betrayals they've been hiding, shattering the other's heart.
In a Christian school, on Valentine's Day, they had a special event. There was a girl, Lucy, who was known for her strong faith. She received a Valentine's gift from a boy who wasn't very religious. Along with the gift was a note asking her to go on a date. Lucy politely declined but used the opportunity to share her Christian values with him. She gave him a small cross and a booklet about Christian love. The boy was so intrigued that he started attending the school's chapel services.
Some Cosmo Valentine's Day horror stories could involve the idea of love gone wrong in a very spooky way. For example, a Valentine's card that when opened, released a swarm of black moths. These moths were a symbol of a past lover's dark magic, trying to disrupt the current relationship.