How would fans react to the concept of 'Dumbledore steals from Harry fanfic'?

Well, it could be that Dumbledore steals Harry's Invisibility Cloak for some 'greater good' he believes in. Maybe he thinks it's too dangerous for Harry to have at a certain point in time.

Some fans write it because they feel Dumbledore made a lot of morally ambiguous decisions. For example, his use of Snape was really rough on Snape. He made Snape endure a lot while using him as a spy. Fans might not like this and write bashing fanfics to express their dissatisfaction.

Some fans are intrigued by the idea of Ahsoka Tano's betrayal in fanfic. They like to see different takes on her character and how she might develop in non - canonical situations. It gives a fresh perspective on a well - known character.

On the other hand, some fans might be interested in seeing a different and more complex side of the characters. They could view it as an exploration of what could happen if the characters were faced with different challenges and temptations. However, there would likely be a lot of debate among fans, with some firmly against it and others more open - minded.

Harry might be initially confused. He has just found out about his lordship and now Dumbledore wants to take it away. He would likely question Dumbledore's motives.

Some fans write it because they feel Dumbledore has some controversial aspects that the original books didn't fully explore. They want to dig deeper into his character and show the darker side that they think exists.

No. I don't think it's a popular concept. Most Harry Potter fans are more interested in the main storylines, characters' relationships, and the magic system in the original series. A concept like 'harry potter is skull fanfic' is so out - of - the - ordinary that it's not likely to be widely popular.

Some fans would be horrified. The Harry Potter series is often associated with positive values and this kind of dark and immoral concept goes against what they love about the original. They might even condemn the fanfic.

Harry might initially be confused. He has always looked up to Dumbledore, so when he realizes Dumbledore is trying to control him, he could start to question everything he thought he knew about their relationship. He may become more rebellious as a result, trying to break free from Dumbledore's influence and make his own decisions.

Dumbledore would probably first have a long conversation with Harry. He would want to understand Harry's concerns thoroughly. Then, he would talk to Snape privately. Dumbledore is very protective of Hogwarts and its students. If he found that Snape's actions were truly endangering the students or the school's harmony, he might consider some form of disciplinary action, but firing Snape might not be his first option. He would also weigh Snape's contributions to the Order of the Phoenix and the fight against Voldemort. He has a lot of faith in Snape, but he also respects Harry's instincts and would take his feelings into account.