Reviews of Classroom of the Elite: A tale of Nanaya by TypicalFicEnjoyer6 - Webnovel

25評論

4.5

  • 寫作品質
  • 更新的穩定性
  • 故事發展
  • 人物形象設計
  • 世界背景

與他人分享您的想法

寫檢討
Luohuo
LV 14 Badge

Well I started this fanfic after it ended since I was pretty off by the first review I saw of this. And oh well you really shouldn't make your mind for a book with the first thing you see or read about it is prob the best way to put it. it was overall a pretty fine novel imo. slow paced since it only had the island exam arc to work with but for what it had, it did a pretty good job. To no one's surprise the ending was a quintessential cliffhanger type of ending and apparently that was planned by the og auth. Mc does get a ki*s with honami near the end and we know airi loves him and kei seems to be in the process of becoming a lich to Mc. Mc knows of kushida nature, and the normal stuff you would expect from him. he also earned 70mil with the guessing vip exam which was nice but ultimately since the fic only had first sem to work with,kinda pointless. Mc and koji are of same type so expect the same. ultimately the flaw of this novel is it's the time at which this was made.

4mth
查看0條回復
poison_testerrrrr2

One of the best fanfic out here. A bit sad that the story ends but hey thumps up for creating a good story.

5mth
查看0條回復
Chaitanya_Gondane

very good story, like it very much, keep my time equipped with it

5mth
查看0條回復
Gazze
LV 1 Badge

[img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it]

5mth
查看0條回復
Arisuisthebest2

The story is Perfect. I really like it. Compared to many classroom of elite fanfictions the MC is actif in the plot.

5mth
查看0條回復
Arisuisthebest2

I love the story so far. Can the author please tell me who the MC is shipped with? I really really want to know .

5mth
查看0條回復
Mazin0_0

Nanya Business Nanya Business Nanya Business

6mth
查看0條回復
Discarded

early story, mc is taking a rather passive and reactive stance so when somethinh have nothing to do with him, he just ignored those so mc presence doesnt affect the world much initially. things getting interesting when ryueen found mc presence and talent, ryueen decide to challenge mc and things starting happened. unknowingly and unintentionally mc prowess is noticed by few others. and current story, mc actually actively start Influencing class d directly. this story is one of the few and better fanfic than other fanfic because the plot pace is steady and perfect. many fanfic ia just "im new character here so break the world right now with my awesomeness" but not this fanfic. its like proper novel complete with elements of a good plot sequence like : early part is introduction, then mc mystery setting, then growth of relationship, stakes of failure, conflict, climax, and resolution". this is my second most favorite cote fic for me

8mth
查看7條回復
Ezrain

Can you provide a Link to the original novel? I tried searching but it's hard to find. Thank you for your hard work...............................................................

8mth
查看1條回復
_KON
LV 12 Badge

I don't really see why there are people saying this is the same as COTE. It is different. The differences aren't very subtle at all... The overall story is progressing very well. Even though we pretty much JUST got to a major event, which is also definitely going differently from COTE, the stuff before was decent stuff. The translation is surprisingly really good too. This is my first time reading translations from this person. Most translated experiences I've had so far can only be described as negative. So I was expecting to have an aneurysm while reading this. Thankfully, that was not the case. This has been pleasant so far.

9mth
查看0條回復
DaoistQqYsyN

this fic is really boring, there is nothing changed. The mc is really similar to ayanokouji, mc background is basically useless. Might as well read the light novel there is no difference

9mth
查看0條回復
DiabloRedfox

since this is just a TL I can't really blame the translator but man the author is a retard like absolutely nothing has been fking changed.. the MC doesn't add anything to the plot he's just there, we already have kiyotaka idk this retard thought adding an MC that's like 90% same as him would do anything, he's in class D, isn't interested in going to up to class A, doesn't join the student council or any club for that matter, emotionless guy, apparently is a "perfect prodigy" and bro's marks are in the 60s because he doesn't care.. and is one lonely mfer, so for your own good don't read this garbage

9mth
查看5條回復
Mixj
LV 4 Badge

honestly, this was a waste of time, just like any other MTL. the story is basically the same as Cote's only this time with a character who pretends to be indifferent. It wouldn't be so bad if the author wasn't constantly trying to demonstrate how good the protagonist is and putting him in the spotlight. This causes many classic Chinese clichés to be repeated like : "wow, this trash is actually a genius !🤯" not to mention how the author makes girls stick to him like a tick. overview : 😮‍💨

9mth
查看2條回復
Sebastym

I wait more.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................

9mth
查看0條回復
Remero

dear god i hope this is not a harem story

10mth
查看1條回復
Talal77

[img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend] [img=update][img=recommend][img=recommend]

10mth
查看0條回復
HollyRisk

the perfect anime with the perfect story and a perfect translator earns my highest respect in this fanfic, amongst the translator works, this fic is without a doubt something I would highly look forward everytime. don't get me wrong, his other two translating fits are somewhat good, but this one is a god tier reading. when author revealed that LoL arcane story gonna be bad later on, I lost all motivation reading it. The same goes to miracle summons as it was boring for my preference. Until this COTE banger came. THANK YOU TRANSLATOR [img=recommend]

10mth
查看0條回復
1412_04
LV 13 Badge

i really hope this can go until 2nd year arc....

10mth
查看0條回復
SynthWaveRider45

It's definitely a translation worth reading.

img
10mth
查看0條回復
LoreiVonAtaraxia

The story of Nanaya from Classroom of the Elite is a spin-off story from Mc's fanfiction whose name is Nanaya Fang-Li (Hori) who has Mystic Eyes of Dead (like Ryougi Shiki's). Novel ini bagus dan sangat menyenangkan untuk dibaca👍 saya rekomendasikan untuk kalian yang suka Mc yang cerdas dan licik tapi dari sudut pandang Pembunuh bukan Detektif😁

10mth
查看1條回復
Fragasile

The MC here is based on the original authors work “Illimitable Until Death”. This little side story where he’s an “ordinary” human is probably the best part he’s written about all things considered, so hope all the newcomers enjoy.

10mth
查看0條回復
Slammeron01

"Classroom of the Elite: A Tale of Nanaya""Nanaya?""Nanaya business, scum."Saw an opportunity, and I took it. Don't hate the player, hate the game

10mth
查看0條回復
LunaKindred

Peak translator, also it's a COTE fics... There's no reason to not giving it 5 stars. Keep your good working translator-san 👍 👍 👍 👍 . . . . . Here's the universal question, is this fics has harem?

10mth
查看0條回復
dankoku

So far so good, translation is peak as always.

10mth
查看0條回復
TypicalFicEnjoyer6

Man, my third translation. Third time's the charm or something like that. I can guarantee the story quality so just read it!!!!!

img
10mth
查看12條回復
Luohuo
LV 14 Badge

Well I started this fanfic after it ended since I was pretty off by the first review I saw of this. And oh well you really shouldn't make your mind for a book with the first thing you see or read about it is prob the best way to put it. it was overall a pretty fine novel imo. slow paced since it only had the island exam arc to work with but for what it had, it did a pretty good job. To no one's surprise the ending was a quintessential cliffhanger type of ending and apparently that was planned by the og auth. Mc does get a ki*s with honami near the end and we know airi loves him and kei seems to be in the process of becoming a lich to Mc. Mc knows of kushida nature, and the normal stuff you would expect from him. he also earned 70mil with the guessing vip exam which was nice but ultimately since the fic only had first sem to work with,kinda pointless. Mc and koji are of same type so expect the same. ultimately the flaw of this novel is it's the time at which this was made.

4mth
查看0條回復
poison_testerrrrr2

One of the best fanfic out here. A bit sad that the story ends but hey thumps up for creating a good story.

5mth
查看0條回復
Chaitanya_Gondane

very good story, like it very much, keep my time equipped with it

5mth
查看0條回復
Gazze
LV 1 Badge

[img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it][img=Feeling it]

5mth
查看0條回復
Arisuisthebest2

The story is Perfect. I really like it. Compared to many classroom of elite fanfictions the MC is actif in the plot.

5mth
查看0條回復
Arisuisthebest2

I love the story so far. Can the author please tell me who the MC is shipped with? I really really want to know .

5mth
查看0條回復
Mazin0_0

Nanya Business Nanya Business Nanya Business

6mth
查看0條回復
Discarded

early story, mc is taking a rather passive and reactive stance so when somethinh have nothing to do with him, he just ignored those so mc presence doesnt affect the world much initially. things getting interesting when ryueen found mc presence and talent, ryueen decide to challenge mc and things starting happened. unknowingly and unintentionally mc prowess is noticed by few others. and current story, mc actually actively start Influencing class d directly. this story is one of the few and better fanfic than other fanfic because the plot pace is steady and perfect. many fanfic ia just "im new character here so break the world right now with my awesomeness" but not this fanfic. its like proper novel complete with elements of a good plot sequence like : early part is introduction, then mc mystery setting, then growth of relationship, stakes of failure, conflict, climax, and resolution". this is my second most favorite cote fic for me

8mth
查看7條回復
Ezrain

Can you provide a Link to the original novel? I tried searching but it's hard to find. Thank you for your hard work...............................................................

8mth
查看1條回復
_KON
LV 12 Badge

I don't really see why there are people saying this is the same as COTE. It is different. The differences aren't very subtle at all... The overall story is progressing very well. Even though we pretty much JUST got to a major event, which is also definitely going differently from COTE, the stuff before was decent stuff. The translation is surprisingly really good too. This is my first time reading translations from this person. Most translated experiences I've had so far can only be described as negative. So I was expecting to have an aneurysm while reading this. Thankfully, that was not the case. This has been pleasant so far.

9mth
查看0條回復
DaoistQqYsyN

this fic is really boring, there is nothing changed. The mc is really similar to ayanokouji, mc background is basically useless. Might as well read the light novel there is no difference

9mth
查看0條回復
DiabloRedfox

since this is just a TL I can't really blame the translator but man the author is a retard like absolutely nothing has been fking changed.. the MC doesn't add anything to the plot he's just there, we already have kiyotaka idk this retard thought adding an MC that's like 90% same as him would do anything, he's in class D, isn't interested in going to up to class A, doesn't join the student council or any club for that matter, emotionless guy, apparently is a "perfect prodigy" and bro's marks are in the 60s because he doesn't care.. and is one lonely mfer, so for your own good don't read this garbage

9mth
查看5條回復
Mixj
LV 4 Badge

honestly, this was a waste of time, just like any other MTL. the story is basically the same as Cote's only this time with a character who pretends to be indifferent. It wouldn't be so bad if the author wasn't constantly trying to demonstrate how good the protagonist is and putting him in the spotlight. This causes many classic Chinese clichés to be repeated like : "wow, this trash is actually a genius !🤯" not to mention how the author makes girls stick to him like a tick. overview : 😮‍💨

9mth
查看2條回復
Sebastym

I wait more.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................

9mth
查看0條回復
Remero

dear god i hope this is not a harem story

10mth
查看1條回復
Talal77

[img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend] [img=update][img=recommend][img=recommend]

10mth
查看0條回復
HollyRisk

the perfect anime with the perfect story and a perfect translator earns my highest respect in this fanfic, amongst the translator works, this fic is without a doubt something I would highly look forward everytime. don't get me wrong, his other two translating fits are somewhat good, but this one is a god tier reading. when author revealed that LoL arcane story gonna be bad later on, I lost all motivation reading it. The same goes to miracle summons as it was boring for my preference. Until this COTE banger came. THANK YOU TRANSLATOR [img=recommend]

10mth
查看0條回復
1412_04
LV 13 Badge

i really hope this can go until 2nd year arc....

10mth
查看0條回復
SynthWaveRider45

It's definitely a translation worth reading.

img
10mth
查看0條回復
LoreiVonAtaraxia

The story of Nanaya from Classroom of the Elite is a spin-off story from Mc's fanfiction whose name is Nanaya Fang-Li (Hori) who has Mystic Eyes of Dead (like Ryougi Shiki's). Novel ini bagus dan sangat menyenangkan untuk dibaca👍 saya rekomendasikan untuk kalian yang suka Mc yang cerdas dan licik tapi dari sudut pandang Pembunuh bukan Detektif😁

10mth
查看1條回復
Fragasile

The MC here is based on the original authors work “Illimitable Until Death”. This little side story where he’s an “ordinary” human is probably the best part he’s written about all things considered, so hope all the newcomers enjoy.

10mth
查看0條回復
Slammeron01

"Classroom of the Elite: A Tale of Nanaya""Nanaya?""Nanaya business, scum."Saw an opportunity, and I took it. Don't hate the player, hate the game

10mth
查看0條回復
LunaKindred

Peak translator, also it's a COTE fics... There's no reason to not giving it 5 stars. Keep your good working translator-san 👍 👍 👍 👍 . . . . . Here's the universal question, is this fics has harem?

10mth
查看0條回復
dankoku

So far so good, translation is peak as always.

10mth
查看0條回復
TypicalFicEnjoyer6

Man, my third translation. Third time's the charm or something like that. I can guarantee the story quality so just read it!!!!!

img
10mth
查看12條回復