Reviews of DC: Rose Of Death by VQuintessence - Webnovel

95評論

4.74

  • 寫作品質
  • 更新的穩定性
  • 故事發展
  • 人物形象設計
  • 世界背景

與他人分享您的想法

寫檢討
VQuintessence

Please pay attention to the tags before you read. The novel will be mainly adventures, exploring the worlds of DCU and The Witcher. There will be romance on the side, and as you might've noticed from the tags, it's a harem. I have never written one, so I wanted to try it. However, I am not into large harem, so I will make it as small as possible, only including the characters I like, and it will take a while to build the relationships. Also, Ian is basically just a human, he has the death resistance, but it doesn't make him any stronger. The question is, can he gain any other superpower? Well, I'll leave you to it and I hope you enjoy ^-^.

3yr
查看45條回復
Shadow_Magus

I really liked your one ouece fic and came here from there. Unfortunately, 10 chaps in and it feels lacking. Not from your side, I think it’s from me. I feel like compared to marvel where the MCU timeline exists as a framework for writers, dc has no such things. No fixed way things progress. I’m not a reader of dc comics or animated series so I only know from the movies, and found nothing I could connect to here. It felt like watching a series of short episodes where on thing happens after the next with little to no effect on the mc… I’m not sure how to put it, but I felt bored. I’m sorry but this one is not for me personally, and yet it was really well written so I have given the rating based on that fact. I hope you continue writing and best of luck with your future works!

img
24d
查看0條回復
Butter_King11111

the beginning part of the novel is good, but I feel like things slowly start to go down hill, the MC's personality is entertaining and its fun to see how it slightly changes over time, my biggest problem is the feeling he's dumbing down some characters(such as nightwing), the action scenes dont really feel immersing and feel slightly dull at times and the mc power carries everything even him getting girls. the only reason I'm even tempted to finish this novel is to know about the mc's power

2mth
查看0條回復
Loverofthebeans

Good but I wished to hear more about his epilogue tho I’m glad you did not draw it out just for it to turn bland

5mth
查看0條回復
LastGod

Tags lie author doesnt know what OVERPOWERED means.

8mth
查看0條回復
WannabeMC

First time I've read smut in an American Comics fic. Eventually the smut was stopped but it was still awkward. The story is decent. There are parts which feel boring and made me want to quit. The writing style can be confusing at times like fragments, run on sentences, and poor transitions. The DC characters and world feel legit. Overall, it's okay.

9mth
查看0條回復
Xander_Bittinger

Great, one of the best things I have read in awhile.

9mth
查看0條回復
DaoistosrKh6

writing quality is very good , they way you write the characters are also good but the mc is faking lame and why are you even putting overpower tags when the mc us this weak

10mth
查看0條回復
Deuteragonista

En general fue una historia muy interesante, ciertamente muy confusa, me dejó más preguntas que respuestas (Mala traducción talvez?) pero sin duda entra en mi top 5 de Fanfics favoritos. Gracias por la historia.

1yr
查看0條回復
Slingshot

I loved this story even though I didn't like the author's other books. it has a great mc although many wouldn't like it because of the stereotypes already present but this one's different, not smart or high iq, just thinks a lot and certainly not struggling with someone or something trying to control him and not always the strongest but also strong enough 'logically' and side characters may throw a lot of people off because of how they change, but i do wanna ask, a character's personality is dependant on their circumstances and people they meet so i dont understand why people expect them to be the same, overall I loved it

1yr
查看0條回復
JRCaste

Thank you for the wonderful read, truly. Tis' was the best read I've had in a long time, I usually go crzy about Harems but this one, this made me continue on reading not because of the harem but because of your story in general, heck if it wasn't even a harem I'd still say it was great read over all. Thank you once again, much love for you Author!

img
1yr
查看0條回復
MellyK9
LV 15 Badge

this is actually one of the best DC fanfic books I have ever read. It has everything I want in a good. The mc is very unique and actually has progressive character development.

1yr
查看0條回復
WalkerRen

Without a doubt, one of the best stories I've ever read, I really enjoyed it. I would have liked more interactions with Diana, but hey, thank you so much for creating something so beautiful.

1yr
查看1條回復
the_banana_catfrfr

thanks for the wonderful novel, I started reading this novel when it was released right at the start, and now I came back after a long time to this novel and it did not disappoint

1yr
查看0條回復
Tom_Bombadil

One of the best DC novels on here.........................................................................................................................

1yr
查看0條回復
Arkzero

Best Dc fanfic I read so far, the mc is so confusing at first but you kind to like him the more you read I say the character are all good and the story is so fun to read.Thanks for writing such good fanfic,❤️ and some of the other fanfic you write is amazing so keep up the good work author

img
1yr
查看0條回復
Dick_Wizard

[img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend]

1yr
查看0條回復
LemarMarley

I have never wrote a review before but I’ve read at least a hundred books on here and this fanfic is really good to the point I had to write a review after finishing it… now I’m at the sad point where such a good story and world that captured you has come to an end

2yr
查看1條回復
CH1LLGUY

First off I wanna say thank you author. The novel was great and enjoyable to read. I really liked your one piece novel. Which led me to read this novel. As I thought if the one piece ff was great. I wouldn’t have a problem with this one. Which was a good call I made. NOW FOR THE READERS. I am not a picky reader and wannabe alpha male. Lots of the hate readers I saw throughout. We’re dudes that kept calling mc a simp for talking to females. Then I look at their bio which says “no simps, cucks, or romance”. This giving me the type of info to know what type of community they attract to. I’m giving this a five star, so it doesn’t drop because of hate readers. If I actually had to review. It would still be a high 4.5 star. Dropping the writing quality. It was the most obvious problem to me as non picky reader. Not to bad where it is non readable. Just a few small mistakes every chapter. Which I am alright with since it is still readable. I recommend to anyone that doesn’t just cry or hate reads.

2yr
查看0條回復
Lutz_
LV 11 Badge

I enjoyed it, that's all I can say. good work [img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend]

2yr
查看0條回復
kingfish_01

... .... .. ..... .. ..... .. ..... . .......... . .. ....... ... . ... ... .......... .. ...... .. .. .. . . ... ..... . ... ..... .. .. ........ .... . .. .

揭示劇透
2yr
查看0條回復
sazzert
LV 12 Badge

Great story👍read the author's other work

2yr
查看0條回復
6SalemSafe9

I loved this story so much!! I kind of wish for more chapters, but also I love the fact, that I was entertained through out the hole story. I was also so curios of what answer will Ian learn, and you don't disappoint. love the story and can't wait to read more of your other stories Mr. author.

2yr
查看0條回復
YGhost

I never wrote reviews but this novel is a novel you need to read if you are ever debating that have fun and give the man his charity

img
2yr
查看0條回復
YohannSch

....................…….........….......….......

2yr
查看0條回復
GRV
LV 4 Badge

A great fanfic to read. Enjoyed it from beginning to end. ..............................................................................

2yr
查看0條回復
Namelian

I want to read but it's harem man ,I don't like harem. hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

img
2yr
查看0條回復
Bendi_rism31

It's a fun read. MC is a pretty good character.

2yr
查看0條回復
Rigchel

The novel has the two essential elements that make a good story: It's understandable and entertaining. It also avoids the common trope of being based on either the Arrowverse or the Young Justice TV Series instead it's based on the DC comics universe. The updates of the fanfic have remained stable and the story has a satisfactory conclusion which many authors struggle with. I guess it's because the author kept a clear vision for the novel. The only unresolved element for me is what is Ian Rose's race exactly. Still one of the best fanfics on comic books

2yr
查看0條回復
Rolling_thunder_

Amazing read …………………………..…………………………………………

2yr
查看0條回復
VQuintessence

Please pay attention to the tags before you read. The novel will be mainly adventures, exploring the worlds of DCU and The Witcher. There will be romance on the side, and as you might've noticed from the tags, it's a harem. I have never written one, so I wanted to try it. However, I am not into large harem, so I will make it as small as possible, only including the characters I like, and it will take a while to build the relationships. Also, Ian is basically just a human, he has the death resistance, but it doesn't make him any stronger. The question is, can he gain any other superpower? Well, I'll leave you to it and I hope you enjoy ^-^.

3yr
查看45條回復
Shadow_Magus

I really liked your one ouece fic and came here from there. Unfortunately, 10 chaps in and it feels lacking. Not from your side, I think it’s from me. I feel like compared to marvel where the MCU timeline exists as a framework for writers, dc has no such things. No fixed way things progress. I’m not a reader of dc comics or animated series so I only know from the movies, and found nothing I could connect to here. It felt like watching a series of short episodes where on thing happens after the next with little to no effect on the mc… I’m not sure how to put it, but I felt bored. I’m sorry but this one is not for me personally, and yet it was really well written so I have given the rating based on that fact. I hope you continue writing and best of luck with your future works!

img
24d
查看0條回復
Butter_King11111

the beginning part of the novel is good, but I feel like things slowly start to go down hill, the MC's personality is entertaining and its fun to see how it slightly changes over time, my biggest problem is the feeling he's dumbing down some characters(such as nightwing), the action scenes dont really feel immersing and feel slightly dull at times and the mc power carries everything even him getting girls. the only reason I'm even tempted to finish this novel is to know about the mc's power

2mth
查看0條回復
Loverofthebeans

Good but I wished to hear more about his epilogue tho I’m glad you did not draw it out just for it to turn bland

5mth
查看0條回復
LastGod

Tags lie author doesnt know what OVERPOWERED means.

8mth
查看0條回復
WannabeMC

First time I've read smut in an American Comics fic. Eventually the smut was stopped but it was still awkward. The story is decent. There are parts which feel boring and made me want to quit. The writing style can be confusing at times like fragments, run on sentences, and poor transitions. The DC characters and world feel legit. Overall, it's okay.

9mth
查看0條回復
Xander_Bittinger

Great, one of the best things I have read in awhile.

9mth
查看0條回復
DaoistosrKh6

writing quality is very good , they way you write the characters are also good but the mc is faking lame and why are you even putting overpower tags when the mc us this weak

10mth
查看0條回復
Deuteragonista

En general fue una historia muy interesante, ciertamente muy confusa, me dejó más preguntas que respuestas (Mala traducción talvez?) pero sin duda entra en mi top 5 de Fanfics favoritos. Gracias por la historia.

1yr
查看0條回復
Slingshot

I loved this story even though I didn't like the author's other books. it has a great mc although many wouldn't like it because of the stereotypes already present but this one's different, not smart or high iq, just thinks a lot and certainly not struggling with someone or something trying to control him and not always the strongest but also strong enough 'logically' and side characters may throw a lot of people off because of how they change, but i do wanna ask, a character's personality is dependant on their circumstances and people they meet so i dont understand why people expect them to be the same, overall I loved it

1yr
查看0條回復
JRCaste

Thank you for the wonderful read, truly. Tis' was the best read I've had in a long time, I usually go crzy about Harems but this one, this made me continue on reading not because of the harem but because of your story in general, heck if it wasn't even a harem I'd still say it was great read over all. Thank you once again, much love for you Author!

img
1yr
查看0條回復
MellyK9
LV 15 Badge

this is actually one of the best DC fanfic books I have ever read. It has everything I want in a good. The mc is very unique and actually has progressive character development.

1yr
查看0條回復
WalkerRen

Without a doubt, one of the best stories I've ever read, I really enjoyed it. I would have liked more interactions with Diana, but hey, thank you so much for creating something so beautiful.

1yr
查看1條回復
the_banana_catfrfr

thanks for the wonderful novel, I started reading this novel when it was released right at the start, and now I came back after a long time to this novel and it did not disappoint

1yr
查看0條回復
Tom_Bombadil

One of the best DC novels on here.........................................................................................................................

1yr
查看0條回復
Arkzero

Best Dc fanfic I read so far, the mc is so confusing at first but you kind to like him the more you read I say the character are all good and the story is so fun to read.Thanks for writing such good fanfic,❤️ and some of the other fanfic you write is amazing so keep up the good work author

img
1yr
查看0條回復
Dick_Wizard

[img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend]

1yr
查看0條回復
LemarMarley

I have never wrote a review before but I’ve read at least a hundred books on here and this fanfic is really good to the point I had to write a review after finishing it… now I’m at the sad point where such a good story and world that captured you has come to an end

2yr
查看1條回復
CH1LLGUY

First off I wanna say thank you author. The novel was great and enjoyable to read. I really liked your one piece novel. Which led me to read this novel. As I thought if the one piece ff was great. I wouldn’t have a problem with this one. Which was a good call I made. NOW FOR THE READERS. I am not a picky reader and wannabe alpha male. Lots of the hate readers I saw throughout. We’re dudes that kept calling mc a simp for talking to females. Then I look at their bio which says “no simps, cucks, or romance”. This giving me the type of info to know what type of community they attract to. I’m giving this a five star, so it doesn’t drop because of hate readers. If I actually had to review. It would still be a high 4.5 star. Dropping the writing quality. It was the most obvious problem to me as non picky reader. Not to bad where it is non readable. Just a few small mistakes every chapter. Which I am alright with since it is still readable. I recommend to anyone that doesn’t just cry or hate reads.

2yr
查看0條回復
Lutz_
LV 11 Badge

I enjoyed it, that's all I can say. good work [img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend]

2yr
查看0條回復
kingfish_01

... .... .. ..... .. ..... .. ..... . .......... . .. ....... ... . ... ... .......... .. ...... .. .. .. . . ... ..... . ... ..... .. .. ........ .... . .. .

揭示劇透
2yr
查看0條回復
sazzert
LV 12 Badge

Great story👍read the author's other work

2yr
查看0條回復
6SalemSafe9

I loved this story so much!! I kind of wish for more chapters, but also I love the fact, that I was entertained through out the hole story. I was also so curios of what answer will Ian learn, and you don't disappoint. love the story and can't wait to read more of your other stories Mr. author.

2yr
查看0條回復
YGhost

I never wrote reviews but this novel is a novel you need to read if you are ever debating that have fun and give the man his charity

img
2yr
查看0條回復
YohannSch

....................…….........….......….......

2yr
查看0條回復
GRV
LV 4 Badge

A great fanfic to read. Enjoyed it from beginning to end. ..............................................................................

2yr
查看0條回復
Namelian

I want to read but it's harem man ,I don't like harem. hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

img
2yr
查看0條回復
Bendi_rism31

It's a fun read. MC is a pretty good character.

2yr
查看0條回復
Rigchel

The novel has the two essential elements that make a good story: It's understandable and entertaining. It also avoids the common trope of being based on either the Arrowverse or the Young Justice TV Series instead it's based on the DC comics universe. The updates of the fanfic have remained stable and the story has a satisfactory conclusion which many authors struggle with. I guess it's because the author kept a clear vision for the novel. The only unresolved element for me is what is Ian Rose's race exactly. Still one of the best fanfics on comic books

2yr
查看0條回復
Rolling_thunder_

Amazing read …………………………..…………………………………………

2yr
查看0條回復
next page