Reviews of One Piece: I'm Yamamoto Genryusai by FFAddict - Webnovel

24Các đánh giá

3.26

  • Chất lượng bài viết
  • Tính ổn định của các bản cập nhật
  • Phát triển câu chuyện
  • Thiết kế nhân vật
  • Bối cảnh thế giới

Chia sẻ suy nghĩ của bạn với người khác

Viết đánh giá
Aris82
LV 15 Badge

this Yamamoto Genryusai fanfiction is well made. this translation work is also top notch. so i will rate it as a must read for those interested and looking for this type of novel. the 1st world is one piece and the second is naruto. still on the second arc. so waiting for more. thank you.

3mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
AlastorGF

Sinceramente es una buena historia pero el simple hecho que no interfiera en nada y todo resulte prácticamente igual con algunos cambios me hizo abandonar esta historia

4mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Abdul_Ayad

It boring after the one piece part of the story and I think it just boring in general and hope that nobody waste time something so trash kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkjkjkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk

4mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Blood_soaked_bar

The idea is good, but the implementation is very bad. Giving the strongest power from the beginning is a wrong idea. If he had given him 1% of the power and then made him train to get more power, the story would have been more interesting instead of this rushed story full of filler and problems with its logic. And all his enemies turned into a group of fools before or when they fought with him, but before that, when they were not among his enemies, they were smart. Two stars for the idea.

5mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Tumis
LV 4 Badge

Well, typical webnovel translated story. Many consistent mistakes in Name, title, terms, ability-name. The translator doesn't edit or even proof read. In short, writing quality is bad. But still above machine-translated story. Now onto the story... Well, like another reviewer pointed; one-two line turned into whole chapter. Then another chapter or two are just 'reaction' chapter from random characters. Character Design is... You have to already know One Piece and... what is that anime called, the one that uses ryujin jakka, flame, bankai etc. All references from them will suddenly be mentioned. Also, mc is not murder-hobo. But because One Piece is pirate vs marine, mc will kill, but not like civilians or random people Updating Stability is... idk, so will place 4. World Background... this is a fanfiction. Overall this story have interesting plot and the mc is not murder-hobo. But very bad writing, not just because of the translation, but the way the author wrote the story. In case not clear, i don't recommend this story.

5mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Bob_Uchiha_XD

ZzzzzzZzzzzZzzzZzzzZzz The story have only one character, is Mc. [img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap]

5mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
YoDarki

en general es interesante pero solitario. y sin descanso todo el tiempo peleando se vuelve bastante básico pero es bueno en todo caso

6mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
SOMBRIO

Chega um momento que vc não consegue mais ler cheguei no 50 mas a enrolação é muito chata.[img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap]

6mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Jordi_Hardiansyah

..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................

6mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
YoungMaster_Oogway

I like this fic very much which is due to the latest chapters and the fights are insane. I hope you continue your work. All the best for your endeavour.

img
6mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Daoist6wNNDc

it's good. even though the grammar of writing isnt't. i can just imagine everything just fine.

6mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Ssantos
LV 13 Badge

Terrible translation, short chapters, many inconsistencies, no context, weak story (seriously? Chinese people can't make a strong protagonist without a system? Years of training to become a "colonel" navy...)

6mth
Xem 1 lời trả lời
Daoist906425

Tried to read it but had an aneurysm in the middle of it thanks to the horrible MTL translation

6mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Chris457

The grammar is all over the place, as is the stories factual information. Nothing seems consistent with Canon details, e.g. baileys vs belli, colonel vs captain, sky gold vs heavenly gold. I like the premise of the story, however the incorrect details in the story from canon, without any forewarning or explanation has put me off. If this is a translation, the author should be noticing and fixing these issues, or getting a Beta reader to do it for them.

7mth
Xem 2 lời trả lời
ShinigamiNoInochi

Yamamoto alone can raze the whole one piece world

7mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Aris82
LV 15 Badge

by far the best One Piece fanfiction I have ever read. the concept of having characters or templates of another anime inserted in One Piece is not new, but the story, the characters, the update speed and also the fun in reading this novel is very very good! im looking for more chapters!!!

7mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
ImWatchingYou

One of my favorites Chinese fanfic... Thank you for translation author ........... ............ .............. ............ .............. Weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

7mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
malhiharjot

Writer only have one good ability, one and only ability to brag about and stretch anything to make it long enough to made one chapter out one single line ,some time make two chapters from one single line. Last 10 or so should be one chapter and author Bragg and stretch them into 10 or many more chapters.

7mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Leonz
LV 6 Badge

Author ch 38 is wrong, control it because the content are for your Naruto fanfiction

8mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
dertyp2021

This fanfic is just bad. Just imagine a machine translated fanfic, but about 10% better.

8mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Max_Kaster

Ich finde die Idee gut ein starken Charakter in den teil der Geschichte wurden von one piece einzufügen. Aber die Umsetzung ist schlecht da die Geschichte nicht wirklich von dem hauptcharakter handelt sondern eher die Reaktion auf ihm, die dann auch mehrfach von allen möglichen Parteien wiederholt dargestellt wird weshalb die einzelnen Kapitel kaum Inhalt bieten die die Geschichte voranbringt. Daher erinnert mich die Geschichte stark an chinesischen KI stories.

8mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
markwew

source? what the source? Chinese title? ofj

8mth
Xem 1 lời trả lời
CocumberMonster

upto chapter 16. every chapter are toooooo stretch. it could be summarized as " he retired, got cheat, buster call on his hometown, and killed the celestial dragon. i hope next chapter will not be stretch to much. some sentences are repeated over and over. ot has good story just toooo stretch.

img
8mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
VerzVerx

Excellent book! Can't wait for more... [img=Your move][img=Your move][img=Your move][img=Your move]

8mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Aris82
LV 15 Badge

this Yamamoto Genryusai fanfiction is well made. this translation work is also top notch. so i will rate it as a must read for those interested and looking for this type of novel. the 1st world is one piece and the second is naruto. still on the second arc. so waiting for more. thank you.

3mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
AlastorGF

Sinceramente es una buena historia pero el simple hecho que no interfiera en nada y todo resulte prácticamente igual con algunos cambios me hizo abandonar esta historia

4mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Abdul_Ayad

It boring after the one piece part of the story and I think it just boring in general and hope that nobody waste time something so trash kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkjkjkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk

4mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Blood_soaked_bar

The idea is good, but the implementation is very bad. Giving the strongest power from the beginning is a wrong idea. If he had given him 1% of the power and then made him train to get more power, the story would have been more interesting instead of this rushed story full of filler and problems with its logic. And all his enemies turned into a group of fools before or when they fought with him, but before that, when they were not among his enemies, they were smart. Two stars for the idea.

5mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Tumis
LV 4 Badge

Well, typical webnovel translated story. Many consistent mistakes in Name, title, terms, ability-name. The translator doesn't edit or even proof read. In short, writing quality is bad. But still above machine-translated story. Now onto the story... Well, like another reviewer pointed; one-two line turned into whole chapter. Then another chapter or two are just 'reaction' chapter from random characters. Character Design is... You have to already know One Piece and... what is that anime called, the one that uses ryujin jakka, flame, bankai etc. All references from them will suddenly be mentioned. Also, mc is not murder-hobo. But because One Piece is pirate vs marine, mc will kill, but not like civilians or random people Updating Stability is... idk, so will place 4. World Background... this is a fanfiction. Overall this story have interesting plot and the mc is not murder-hobo. But very bad writing, not just because of the translation, but the way the author wrote the story. In case not clear, i don't recommend this story.

5mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Bob_Uchiha_XD

ZzzzzzZzzzzZzzzZzzzZzz The story have only one character, is Mc. [img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap]

5mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
YoDarki

en general es interesante pero solitario. y sin descanso todo el tiempo peleando se vuelve bastante básico pero es bueno en todo caso

6mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
SOMBRIO

Chega um momento que vc não consegue mais ler cheguei no 50 mas a enrolação é muito chata.[img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap]

6mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Jordi_Hardiansyah

..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................

6mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
YoungMaster_Oogway

I like this fic very much which is due to the latest chapters and the fights are insane. I hope you continue your work. All the best for your endeavour.

img
6mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Daoist6wNNDc

it's good. even though the grammar of writing isnt't. i can just imagine everything just fine.

6mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Ssantos
LV 13 Badge

Terrible translation, short chapters, many inconsistencies, no context, weak story (seriously? Chinese people can't make a strong protagonist without a system? Years of training to become a "colonel" navy...)

6mth
Xem 1 lời trả lời
Daoist906425

Tried to read it but had an aneurysm in the middle of it thanks to the horrible MTL translation

6mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Chris457

The grammar is all over the place, as is the stories factual information. Nothing seems consistent with Canon details, e.g. baileys vs belli, colonel vs captain, sky gold vs heavenly gold. I like the premise of the story, however the incorrect details in the story from canon, without any forewarning or explanation has put me off. If this is a translation, the author should be noticing and fixing these issues, or getting a Beta reader to do it for them.

7mth
Xem 2 lời trả lời
ShinigamiNoInochi

Yamamoto alone can raze the whole one piece world

7mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Aris82
LV 15 Badge

by far the best One Piece fanfiction I have ever read. the concept of having characters or templates of another anime inserted in One Piece is not new, but the story, the characters, the update speed and also the fun in reading this novel is very very good! im looking for more chapters!!!

7mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
ImWatchingYou

One of my favorites Chinese fanfic... Thank you for translation author ........... ............ .............. ............ .............. Weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

7mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
malhiharjot

Writer only have one good ability, one and only ability to brag about and stretch anything to make it long enough to made one chapter out one single line ,some time make two chapters from one single line. Last 10 or so should be one chapter and author Bragg and stretch them into 10 or many more chapters.

7mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Leonz
LV 6 Badge

Author ch 38 is wrong, control it because the content are for your Naruto fanfiction

8mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
dertyp2021

This fanfic is just bad. Just imagine a machine translated fanfic, but about 10% better.

8mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
Max_Kaster

Ich finde die Idee gut ein starken Charakter in den teil der Geschichte wurden von one piece einzufügen. Aber die Umsetzung ist schlecht da die Geschichte nicht wirklich von dem hauptcharakter handelt sondern eher die Reaktion auf ihm, die dann auch mehrfach von allen möglichen Parteien wiederholt dargestellt wird weshalb die einzelnen Kapitel kaum Inhalt bieten die die Geschichte voranbringt. Daher erinnert mich die Geschichte stark an chinesischen KI stories.

8mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
markwew

source? what the source? Chinese title? ofj

8mth
Xem 1 lời trả lời
CocumberMonster

upto chapter 16. every chapter are toooooo stretch. it could be summarized as " he retired, got cheat, buster call on his hometown, and killed the celestial dragon. i hope next chapter will not be stretch to much. some sentences are repeated over and over. ot has good story just toooo stretch.

img
8mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời
VerzVerx

Excellent book! Can't wait for more... [img=Your move][img=Your move][img=Your move][img=Your move]

8mth
Xem 0 lời trả lời