Reviews of From Thug to Idol: Transmigrating to a Survival Show by SandKastle - Webnovel

375レビュー

4.7

  • テキストの品質
  • アップデートの安定性
  • ストーリー展開
  • キャラクターデザイン
  • 世界の背景

あなたの考えを他の人と共有してください

レビューを書く
SandKastle

Hi, Sand Kastle here!🏰 (Shamelessly rating my book 5 stars since I like it) Are you looking for a story with an unlimited level-up system that will allow an underdog to evolve into an overpowered figure in the idol industry? If yes, then, this story's for you!

1yr
72 の返信を表示する
Mister_Robot

What do I say about this. you can divide this novel into two parts : the good (1-150 chap) and the bad (post chapter 150). It starts out great that you can't put it down but slowly it's as though the engine started running out of oil, the unnecessary drama of Xie and Hoon wasn't needed that too right after the MC emerged unscathed from a controversy. Kinda felt like the author ran out of ideas. Adding to that, the MC's personality is kinda confusing, he doesn't have the vibe of a thug, too easy going and non-chalant ngl. Plus he seems too relaxed for someone who's dancing in the tune of the system to ensure his sister's well being. He seems too carefree and the system needs to remind him he's doing whatever he's doing for his sister's sake. There's no enthusiasm and it rather feels like he's receiving all blessings very easily because of the system. I wish the author made him a little more anxious and enthusiastic about saving his sister.

5d
0 の返信を表示する
swiftimmy

finally finished it and I already want to go back and read it all over again

17d
0 の返信を表示する
Elaf_Asif_1990

this story is good for those who like to read about transmigration and idols. This isn't a typical transmigration story it has a different touch to it and I like the MC June and how the other characters are represented.After every chapter you want to read more, the start of the story is also interesting although it may be slow later for a bit but trust me you won't be disappointed after reading this.

18d
0 の返信を表示する
Chigozie_Odumodu

This is an idol web novel done, right? There were some things most authors never thought of.

26d
0 の返信を表示する
DaoistJqwBN8

The story is captivating and it kept me interested Loved how the protagonist was written and how the story progressed so smoothly tha it made easier to follow along . loved the ending

27d
0 の返信を表示する
its_me_dee

One of the best transmigrated Idol novel out there. It will bring you to such a rollercoaster of emotions you can't even imagine. I laughed and cried so much with June. Give this one a try!

1mth
0 の返信を表示する
Kohi_
LV 12 Badge

This novel is a gem! Author did amazing writing the song lyrics and dramatic scenes. I can’t even count how many times this story made me giggle and cry. It’s impressive how she hooks readers, unable to make them put down the novel, despite the plot holes and (random) idiocy of the MC. For the critique. The writing is obviously amateur, esp the worldbuilding and research (eg, not knowing Korean directors are also the editors, PD, be it a variety show or film, the ageism in the culture) and the side characters (members) blurred their individuality about 300+ chapters into the story. At the start of the story, even if you cover the names, I could tell who’s speaking, but later on the members of LEVEL UP seem to have just 2 personalities —teasing or worried. Even MC seems to forget he used to be a thug, and is left helpless like 50%. I understand it’s for the sake of the plot but…So much potential untapped. All in all, it’s a decent story that needs polishing here and there, but that doesn’t change the fact this story is an absolutely enjoyable read as long as you don’t dwell on the small details.

1mth
0 の返信を表示する
Adensilvereye

For an ex mafia member MC is WAY TOO PASSIVE. I mean at certain point you feel like he is a PUSHOVER. He also acts STUPID. I even feel that mc didn't even hate his killer but just frustrated that he killed him. Many of the trainy hate him but he act like a nany who care about them not like a gangster.he ran in front of his previous co- traini like a introvert pushover and he is repeatedly said that he was a gangster. He need money but don't give his all for idol show and act naive and stupid. I feel like he was a bullied teenager in previous life not a gangster

1mth
1 の返信を表示する
Roxanne3318

This story is really good, especially I like how June is struggling with his past behavior and the system Fu, I really like both of them. So, over all I like this story 💯

1mth
0 の返信を表示する
Roxanne3318

This transmigration story is amazing. Different from other ones. once you start reading it, you'll get so invested into it, that before you know it you have finished one whole chapter. From it's title you can tell, our mc was a thug and he is going to be an idol. If you like this idea, try it. It's really good [img=Smitten]

1mth
0 の返信を表示する
Ivy_Lumina

This book is awesome. And June for me such a lovable character. Kinda sad it ended but I'll check out your other books☺️

1mth
0 の返信を表示する
NitrogenousBeing

It's an entertaining and well-written story. I knew nothing about K-pop or idles and I was fine. Worth a read. Criticism: Some middle and ending parts of the story are a little too dragged out. Initially it was hard to reconcile the MCs backstory with some of his actions and character, but if the reader can get past the initial hiccups it solidifies. It's hard to get a feel for the rhythm of the songs in text form, but that's not the author's fault. The portrayal of LA struck me as a bit odd as I’m familiar with it. The last minor gripe is everyone gets mesmerized by MC too easily near the end. (I guess he's just that otherworldly?) Try it its good.

1mth
0 の返信を表示する
Senku_07

I love this book. I just finished it and it has been amazing. No boring chapters and keep you wanting more. I love the mc and the side characters. I hope author makes books like this more.

1mth
0 の返信を表示する
Emma_Kamdem_9716

I love how the story begins, it was really entertaining . like i did not this kind of development, it was not the most original idol novel but was fun, entertainment it took all my time it had a wonderful attraction with it continuous chapters. I fell in love with each character especially June, it's sad that each character did not have their personal development, but it was nice that the author gives us a little symphony of their trauma 😭😭 i fell hard for Casper. I hope to see another novel from you

1mth
0 の返信を表示する
Noah_Emmanuel_hadi

Thank you for work Author. I am very happy to read this novel. Is the best novel i ever read. Thank you for making a great novel that i ever read.

1mth
0 の返信を表示する
Dwayne11

great story! amazing character developments! excellent plot!! i wish author will continue on writing stories as he is obviously a master at that.

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
DaoistR6XJJZ

It was an awesome read 👍 it has some minor flaws but an entertaining read nonetheless 👌

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
Mariad_45

Buena novela sobre ídols, quiero leer más jajaj

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
Faye_Abing

finished! the one of the best novel I've read

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
Emma_Kamdem_9716

i really loved this novel It's one of the best I've ever read about Idol, every day waiting for the update all I'm saying is about June, my cutie junny.

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
ninja360awsomeness

It's just too good. This is one of the few novels that I actually finished.

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
Fazle_Rabbi_5750

I wanted Lena and June to end up together or they should have Lena and lei dating each other one of these would have made the story a must favorite for me! All in all story was almost perfect!

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
Sunny_Edvard

No words can capture how amazing this novel is. Truly a wonderful read!

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
lithstg
LV 14 Badge

i absolutely loved this book but i really wished that mei would've remembered june, and maybe we could've seen june of the future. But it's absolutely fun read

ネタバレを明かす
2mth
0 の返信を表示する
Ada_Bana

An awesome story about a guy that didn't want to be an idol at first and ended up being the best in the business. WILL DEFINITELY READ AGAIN!!!

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
KXD
LV 14 Badge

This is my 2nd read a long while later- remembering why I loved it so much.

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
Ashley_Chan_4328

everything is just really well written imo although sometimes the side quests June receives can get a little repetitive and predictable its still a good read

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
_Stacy_
LV 14 Badge

Wow it's an amazing book. first book I read finished for the first time in webnovel . Author well done 👍👍👍

img
2mth
0 の返信を表示する
DaoistpM3GlP

I simply love this novel. For me, it is a masterpiece that captures you from the first moment. Each page envelops you more and more, and when you least expect it, you have already passed more than 100 chapters. This story fascinates me deeply, and I really recommend that you give it a chance. The author has such a fluid and exciting narrative that makes you feel every emotion of the characters. In a twist of fate, Jun Hao, a ruthless street thug known for his brute strength and sharp instincts, is killed by the boss he served as a slave. When he thought he would die, he saw a screen flash before his eyes: it was a system and a status window! [Integrating system: Become a top idol] Jun Hao finds himself abruptly transported into the body of Choi Joon-ho, a shy trainee who hopes to make it big in the cutthroat world of idols through "Rising Stars," a popular idol survival show. In a world unknown to him, where singing, dancing and charisma reign supreme, Jun Hao must navigate the treacherous waters of an idol survival show or risk losing the life of his beloved younger sister. The author shows the characters in such a vivid way that you feel each of their feelings. It is a story that will make you laugh, cry and have fun. Don't miss it.

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
redwitsch

I loved this story. MC is kinda overpowered, but relatable.

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
SandKastle

Hi, Sand Kastle here!🏰 (Shamelessly rating my book 5 stars since I like it) Are you looking for a story with an unlimited level-up system that will allow an underdog to evolve into an overpowered figure in the idol industry? If yes, then, this story's for you!

1yr
72 の返信を表示する
Mister_Robot

What do I say about this. you can divide this novel into two parts : the good (1-150 chap) and the bad (post chapter 150). It starts out great that you can't put it down but slowly it's as though the engine started running out of oil, the unnecessary drama of Xie and Hoon wasn't needed that too right after the MC emerged unscathed from a controversy. Kinda felt like the author ran out of ideas. Adding to that, the MC's personality is kinda confusing, he doesn't have the vibe of a thug, too easy going and non-chalant ngl. Plus he seems too relaxed for someone who's dancing in the tune of the system to ensure his sister's well being. He seems too carefree and the system needs to remind him he's doing whatever he's doing for his sister's sake. There's no enthusiasm and it rather feels like he's receiving all blessings very easily because of the system. I wish the author made him a little more anxious and enthusiastic about saving his sister.

5d
0 の返信を表示する
swiftimmy

finally finished it and I already want to go back and read it all over again

17d
0 の返信を表示する
Elaf_Asif_1990

this story is good for those who like to read about transmigration and idols. This isn't a typical transmigration story it has a different touch to it and I like the MC June and how the other characters are represented.After every chapter you want to read more, the start of the story is also interesting although it may be slow later for a bit but trust me you won't be disappointed after reading this.

18d
0 の返信を表示する
Chigozie_Odumodu

This is an idol web novel done, right? There were some things most authors never thought of.

26d
0 の返信を表示する
DaoistJqwBN8

The story is captivating and it kept me interested Loved how the protagonist was written and how the story progressed so smoothly tha it made easier to follow along . loved the ending

27d
0 の返信を表示する
its_me_dee

One of the best transmigrated Idol novel out there. It will bring you to such a rollercoaster of emotions you can't even imagine. I laughed and cried so much with June. Give this one a try!

1mth
0 の返信を表示する
Kohi_
LV 12 Badge

This novel is a gem! Author did amazing writing the song lyrics and dramatic scenes. I can’t even count how many times this story made me giggle and cry. It’s impressive how she hooks readers, unable to make them put down the novel, despite the plot holes and (random) idiocy of the MC. For the critique. The writing is obviously amateur, esp the worldbuilding and research (eg, not knowing Korean directors are also the editors, PD, be it a variety show or film, the ageism in the culture) and the side characters (members) blurred their individuality about 300+ chapters into the story. At the start of the story, even if you cover the names, I could tell who’s speaking, but later on the members of LEVEL UP seem to have just 2 personalities —teasing or worried. Even MC seems to forget he used to be a thug, and is left helpless like 50%. I understand it’s for the sake of the plot but…So much potential untapped. All in all, it’s a decent story that needs polishing here and there, but that doesn’t change the fact this story is an absolutely enjoyable read as long as you don’t dwell on the small details.

1mth
0 の返信を表示する
Adensilvereye

For an ex mafia member MC is WAY TOO PASSIVE. I mean at certain point you feel like he is a PUSHOVER. He also acts STUPID. I even feel that mc didn't even hate his killer but just frustrated that he killed him. Many of the trainy hate him but he act like a nany who care about them not like a gangster.he ran in front of his previous co- traini like a introvert pushover and he is repeatedly said that he was a gangster. He need money but don't give his all for idol show and act naive and stupid. I feel like he was a bullied teenager in previous life not a gangster

1mth
1 の返信を表示する
Roxanne3318

This story is really good, especially I like how June is struggling with his past behavior and the system Fu, I really like both of them. So, over all I like this story 💯

1mth
0 の返信を表示する
Roxanne3318

This transmigration story is amazing. Different from other ones. once you start reading it, you'll get so invested into it, that before you know it you have finished one whole chapter. From it's title you can tell, our mc was a thug and he is going to be an idol. If you like this idea, try it. It's really good [img=Smitten]

1mth
0 の返信を表示する
Ivy_Lumina

This book is awesome. And June for me such a lovable character. Kinda sad it ended but I'll check out your other books☺️

1mth
0 の返信を表示する
NitrogenousBeing

It's an entertaining and well-written story. I knew nothing about K-pop or idles and I was fine. Worth a read. Criticism: Some middle and ending parts of the story are a little too dragged out. Initially it was hard to reconcile the MCs backstory with some of his actions and character, but if the reader can get past the initial hiccups it solidifies. It's hard to get a feel for the rhythm of the songs in text form, but that's not the author's fault. The portrayal of LA struck me as a bit odd as I’m familiar with it. The last minor gripe is everyone gets mesmerized by MC too easily near the end. (I guess he's just that otherworldly?) Try it its good.

1mth
0 の返信を表示する
Senku_07

I love this book. I just finished it and it has been amazing. No boring chapters and keep you wanting more. I love the mc and the side characters. I hope author makes books like this more.

1mth
0 の返信を表示する
Emma_Kamdem_9716

I love how the story begins, it was really entertaining . like i did not this kind of development, it was not the most original idol novel but was fun, entertainment it took all my time it had a wonderful attraction with it continuous chapters. I fell in love with each character especially June, it's sad that each character did not have their personal development, but it was nice that the author gives us a little symphony of their trauma 😭😭 i fell hard for Casper. I hope to see another novel from you

1mth
0 の返信を表示する
Noah_Emmanuel_hadi

Thank you for work Author. I am very happy to read this novel. Is the best novel i ever read. Thank you for making a great novel that i ever read.

1mth
0 の返信を表示する
Dwayne11

great story! amazing character developments! excellent plot!! i wish author will continue on writing stories as he is obviously a master at that.

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
DaoistR6XJJZ

It was an awesome read 👍 it has some minor flaws but an entertaining read nonetheless 👌

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
Mariad_45

Buena novela sobre ídols, quiero leer más jajaj

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
Faye_Abing

finished! the one of the best novel I've read

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
Emma_Kamdem_9716

i really loved this novel It's one of the best I've ever read about Idol, every day waiting for the update all I'm saying is about June, my cutie junny.

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
ninja360awsomeness

It's just too good. This is one of the few novels that I actually finished.

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
Fazle_Rabbi_5750

I wanted Lena and June to end up together or they should have Lena and lei dating each other one of these would have made the story a must favorite for me! All in all story was almost perfect!

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
Sunny_Edvard

No words can capture how amazing this novel is. Truly a wonderful read!

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
lithstg
LV 14 Badge

i absolutely loved this book but i really wished that mei would've remembered june, and maybe we could've seen june of the future. But it's absolutely fun read

ネタバレを明かす
2mth
0 の返信を表示する
Ada_Bana

An awesome story about a guy that didn't want to be an idol at first and ended up being the best in the business. WILL DEFINITELY READ AGAIN!!!

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
KXD
LV 14 Badge

This is my 2nd read a long while later- remembering why I loved it so much.

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
Ashley_Chan_4328

everything is just really well written imo although sometimes the side quests June receives can get a little repetitive and predictable its still a good read

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
_Stacy_
LV 14 Badge

Wow it's an amazing book. first book I read finished for the first time in webnovel . Author well done 👍👍👍

img
2mth
0 の返信を表示する
DaoistpM3GlP

I simply love this novel. For me, it is a masterpiece that captures you from the first moment. Each page envelops you more and more, and when you least expect it, you have already passed more than 100 chapters. This story fascinates me deeply, and I really recommend that you give it a chance. The author has such a fluid and exciting narrative that makes you feel every emotion of the characters. In a twist of fate, Jun Hao, a ruthless street thug known for his brute strength and sharp instincts, is killed by the boss he served as a slave. When he thought he would die, he saw a screen flash before his eyes: it was a system and a status window! [Integrating system: Become a top idol] Jun Hao finds himself abruptly transported into the body of Choi Joon-ho, a shy trainee who hopes to make it big in the cutthroat world of idols through "Rising Stars," a popular idol survival show. In a world unknown to him, where singing, dancing and charisma reign supreme, Jun Hao must navigate the treacherous waters of an idol survival show or risk losing the life of his beloved younger sister. The author shows the characters in such a vivid way that you feel each of their feelings. It is a story that will make you laugh, cry and have fun. Don't miss it.

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
redwitsch

I loved this story. MC is kinda overpowered, but relatable.

2mth
0 の返信を表示する
next page