Reviews of One Piece: Starting in God Valley as a Slave by tambeerg - Webnovel

22Ulasan-ulasan

4.65

  • Kualitas penulisan
  • Stabilitas Pembaruan
  • Pengembangan Cerita
  • Desain Karakter
  • Latar Belakang Dunia

Bagikan pikiran Anda dengan orang lain

Tulis ulasan
JhakqueZyx6

Great story so far and the world building around the secrets of the celestial dragons and dark fruit is amazing. if it keeps up this pace it might just get better and better. can't wait for how everything will play out. If i have to say something bad about it is that gion is somehow the same age as akainu/ kizaru. they 3 including kuzan were known as monsters within the marine and somehow she thought that she is better than them which seems weird and off but AU things doing AU things

Membuka SPOILER
3mth
Lihat 0 balasan
Trafford

This is probably the best One Piece fanfiction (non-crossover one) that I have ever read and that are out there. Everything from the world development to the powers of MC is well done. I especially like the fact that MC is a Celestial Dragon, and the story delves into the topic of the Celestial Dragons as well. The translation itself is superb.

1d
Lihat 0 balasan
Sky_novel_lover

Need more chapters!

6d
Lihat 0 balasan
Britcio
LV 13 Badge

Hasta el momento bastante entretenida con una gramática y traducción decente, es genial que tenga su toque de originalidad en el desarrollo de la historia con los antecedentes y el linaje del MC

img
17d
Lihat 0 balasan
Sasha_Deyton

—————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— ——————

1mth
Lihat 0 balasan
Gold_Manthea

I am enjoying this story quite a lot and o am looking forward to further development. Truly your OCs and use of story characters are great and they flow well together. I especially enjoy your depiction of Kuma.

1mth
Lihat 1 balasan
Gold_Manthea

This is great so far and I really can't wait for more and the confrontation with the various known people. Ofc this fic interests me greatly because I have wondered if Monkey D. Dragon could have made it to fleet Admiral and then maneuver the navy away from the WG somehow, instead of what ever he is doing now.

1mth
Lihat 0 balasan
Daoistw0gD5Q

This count as decent translation compared to MTL. And the novel itself is good but sadly, the novel suffer from Chinese author disease of 'greedy', prolonging and dragging the story to the point nonsense. It has the same fate like "build the strongest beast pirate(kaido's brother)" novel. It's really really pity such good 200 chapter novel just get ruined because of this disease.

Membuka SPOILER
2mth
Lihat 0 balasan
Kaguyume

The story is really good, the author is enthusiastic about continuing to update it

2mth
Lihat 0 balasan
Melshan

HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM

img
2mth
Lihat 2 balasan
micheal_armonda

Despite the idea being great, The writing needs a lot of improvement grammar wise, especially the descriptive language that's being used. Big shots like Big mom, garling, Rocks or whoever shouldn't be stunned and shocked at every little action that happens, no matter how small it is. For dialogue I would recommend going back to one piece and analyzing how characters actually talk because as of right now they behave like OC's. This is by far the hardest part of writing one piece fanfics. On the otherside I do commend you for sticking to a consistent upload schedule and appreciate the use of correct punctuation for the most part. And I do have one small suggestion that might sound silly: I don't think the mc name 'carl' fits one piece at all. So maybe something like 'Carlos' might? Or maybe give him a nickname to not ruin immersion. Please don't be discouraged by my review and keep writing

2mth
Lihat 2 balasan
LordAion

The story begins in a timeline before the start of the anime, which is quite common in One Piece fanfics. It's a little difficult to determine the MC's personality, the only objective he has so far is revenge on a certain person, in addition to some characters appearing to be very submissive towards the MC. So far (chapter 50+-) the novel is going well, but it needs to delve deeper into the protagonist and give a little more personality to the secondary characters.

2mth
Lihat 0 balasan
Rafael_Ferrer

Una gran novela por favor saca mas ajjadhajajdjajfbjsbdiebdu3bxudbcuhehejdbeudbdudh3hudebu3hksudidhddidhdjdudhdudhdijdidjdudhdidhdudhduhjsdudududududu

2mth
Lihat 0 balasan
DaoistoTRlpz

........................................................................................................................................................

2mth
Lihat 0 balasan
Derek_Lycan

So far, this is already one of the top 5 one piece fanfic I have read. story and character building is surprisingly great, it is very interesting. update rate is good too. KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK.

3mth
Lihat 1 balasan
Ty_Chaos62

Enjoying the fic so far. MC has pretty good development and we get to see a different side to the one piece world.

3mth
Lihat 0 balasan
orangegummy

I like mc devil fruit but this story feel like there little element of young master it will be great if u change something that are too chinese. 😁😁😁 this ff are great overall

3mth
Lihat 0 balasan
Lordzbot

................................................................................................................. ..................................... ................................ .......................

img
3mth
Lihat 0 balasan
Butcher_

Good shit.........................................................................................................................................................................

3mth
Lihat 5 balasan
DaoistCEJSmI

Primero para esta aventura. Depósito la fe con un granito de arena (y para motivarte a que sigas esta magnifica obra muy poco vista en estas paginas) muy buen comienzo, espero verla terminada. No te desmotives en el tema de personas porque vendrán a su debido tiempo. Nada más que decir nos vemos y ojala la obra llegue lejos. Ánimos 💪

3mth
Lihat 1 balasan
tambeerg

Really good story, at least the best of my fanfics. I like that it's not a canon time, the MC's unusual ethnicity, pretty quick development, he's become powerful, but it's grounded so it's not like it just fell out of the sky

3mth
Lihat 9 balasan
JhakqueZyx6

Great story so far and the world building around the secrets of the celestial dragons and dark fruit is amazing. if it keeps up this pace it might just get better and better. can't wait for how everything will play out. If i have to say something bad about it is that gion is somehow the same age as akainu/ kizaru. they 3 including kuzan were known as monsters within the marine and somehow she thought that she is better than them which seems weird and off but AU things doing AU things

Membuka SPOILER
3mth
Lihat 0 balasan
Trafford

This is probably the best One Piece fanfiction (non-crossover one) that I have ever read and that are out there. Everything from the world development to the powers of MC is well done. I especially like the fact that MC is a Celestial Dragon, and the story delves into the topic of the Celestial Dragons as well. The translation itself is superb.

1d
Lihat 0 balasan
Sky_novel_lover

Need more chapters!

6d
Lihat 0 balasan
Britcio
LV 13 Badge

Hasta el momento bastante entretenida con una gramática y traducción decente, es genial que tenga su toque de originalidad en el desarrollo de la historia con los antecedentes y el linaje del MC

img
17d
Lihat 0 balasan
Sasha_Deyton

—————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— —————— ——————

1mth
Lihat 0 balasan
Gold_Manthea

I am enjoying this story quite a lot and o am looking forward to further development. Truly your OCs and use of story characters are great and they flow well together. I especially enjoy your depiction of Kuma.

1mth
Lihat 1 balasan
Gold_Manthea

This is great so far and I really can't wait for more and the confrontation with the various known people. Ofc this fic interests me greatly because I have wondered if Monkey D. Dragon could have made it to fleet Admiral and then maneuver the navy away from the WG somehow, instead of what ever he is doing now.

1mth
Lihat 0 balasan
Daoistw0gD5Q

This count as decent translation compared to MTL. And the novel itself is good but sadly, the novel suffer from Chinese author disease of 'greedy', prolonging and dragging the story to the point nonsense. It has the same fate like "build the strongest beast pirate(kaido's brother)" novel. It's really really pity such good 200 chapter novel just get ruined because of this disease.

Membuka SPOILER
2mth
Lihat 0 balasan
Kaguyume

The story is really good, the author is enthusiastic about continuing to update it

2mth
Lihat 0 balasan
Melshan

HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM HAREM

img
2mth
Lihat 2 balasan
micheal_armonda

Despite the idea being great, The writing needs a lot of improvement grammar wise, especially the descriptive language that's being used. Big shots like Big mom, garling, Rocks or whoever shouldn't be stunned and shocked at every little action that happens, no matter how small it is. For dialogue I would recommend going back to one piece and analyzing how characters actually talk because as of right now they behave like OC's. This is by far the hardest part of writing one piece fanfics. On the otherside I do commend you for sticking to a consistent upload schedule and appreciate the use of correct punctuation for the most part. And I do have one small suggestion that might sound silly: I don't think the mc name 'carl' fits one piece at all. So maybe something like 'Carlos' might? Or maybe give him a nickname to not ruin immersion. Please don't be discouraged by my review and keep writing

2mth
Lihat 2 balasan
LordAion

The story begins in a timeline before the start of the anime, which is quite common in One Piece fanfics. It's a little difficult to determine the MC's personality, the only objective he has so far is revenge on a certain person, in addition to some characters appearing to be very submissive towards the MC. So far (chapter 50+-) the novel is going well, but it needs to delve deeper into the protagonist and give a little more personality to the secondary characters.

2mth
Lihat 0 balasan
Rafael_Ferrer

Una gran novela por favor saca mas ajjadhajajdjajfbjsbdiebdu3bxudbcuhehejdbeudbdudh3hudebu3hksudidhddidhdjdudhdudhdijdidjdudhdidhdudhduhjsdudududududu

2mth
Lihat 0 balasan
DaoistoTRlpz

........................................................................................................................................................

2mth
Lihat 0 balasan
Derek_Lycan

So far, this is already one of the top 5 one piece fanfic I have read. story and character building is surprisingly great, it is very interesting. update rate is good too. KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK.

3mth
Lihat 1 balasan
Ty_Chaos62

Enjoying the fic so far. MC has pretty good development and we get to see a different side to the one piece world.

3mth
Lihat 0 balasan
orangegummy

I like mc devil fruit but this story feel like there little element of young master it will be great if u change something that are too chinese. 😁😁😁 this ff are great overall

3mth
Lihat 0 balasan
Lordzbot

................................................................................................................. ..................................... ................................ .......................

img
3mth
Lihat 0 balasan
Butcher_

Good shit.........................................................................................................................................................................

3mth
Lihat 5 balasan
DaoistCEJSmI

Primero para esta aventura. Depósito la fe con un granito de arena (y para motivarte a que sigas esta magnifica obra muy poco vista en estas paginas) muy buen comienzo, espero verla terminada. No te desmotives en el tema de personas porque vendrán a su debido tiempo. Nada más que decir nos vemos y ojala la obra llegue lejos. Ánimos 💪

3mth
Lihat 1 balasan
tambeerg

Really good story, at least the best of my fanfics. I like that it's not a canon time, the MC's unusual ethnicity, pretty quick development, he's become powerful, but it's grounded so it's not like it just fell out of the sky

3mth
Lihat 9 balasan