Reviews of Reincarnated as a cultivation protagonist by ShaggyJoestar69 - Webnovel

25Critiques

3.63

  • Qualité de l’écriture
  • Stabilité des mises à jour
  • Développement de l’histoire
  • Conception des personnages
  • Contexte du monde

Partagez vos pensées avec les autres

Écrire un avis
ThePath

Started good and funny but devolved to a cheap and badly written Xianxia knock-off. In the first chapters of the story I thought it would be a good "Crackfic" which is fun and making of the Xianxia trope mixed with an absurdly overpowered system. This however quickly dissolved and the MC just became a wanderer type alchemist following all the cliches this trope has to offer, I honestly think the creativity of the author died. The whole thing needs a re-write, the start although creative and funny doesn't flow correctly and is not well written, author the book "Story Genius: How to Use Brain Science to Go Beyond Outlining and Write a Riveting Novel" is a good one on the subject. I would like to see more western comical elements, you gave him the memories of the one and only Rick Sanchez, that is completely absurd and could've made this whole work funnier if you employed some of his crazy characteristics, although memories does not equal personality and thinking patterns they should have had a gigantic change to the MC. The MC should've embraced more of Ricks mad scientist instead of nihilistic genius (since he got young ricks memories), so stuff like him releasing T-Virus equivalents to power up non-cultivators and other wacky stuff that would've made the whole plot more engaging. An over-arching plot-point would be nice, for example MC is in one of the lower realms that exist and in the end we find that the one who is managing/created the realms did so he can sacrifice the souls of people living there for power. However our MC does not care about that. Anyway, in conclusion your novel sparked my imagination but failed to deliver, a good fan-fiction that did something similar would be "You are Courting Death" but that one didn't have a crazy scientist. Overall if you re-write this I know you can do a lot better

2yr
Voir 5 Réponses
DaoistElxnbZ

This story has been abandoned or is on hiatus, I really enjoyed reading it.......................................................................................................

5mth
Voir 0 Réponses
Patrick_hell123

I like your story it's very interesting to listen to

10mth
Voir 0 Réponses
DaoistH7599X

Painfully stupid. From the very start with his dumb wishes and dumb talk with a ROB that judges rinnegan worth 2 wishes and the system costs 1, don't know what else to say, it is just dumb xianxia of mediocre level even in its own league.

1yr
Voir 1 Réponses
Reykun
LV 13 Badge

Good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Ibrahim_NiR

Eres grande amigo, es una de las historias sobre cultivo más ligeras y emocionantes para leer de un solo golpe jajaja... Necesito más de esta novela

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
timeawayfromstress

You can understand that mc is stupid from the first episode. In the next episodes, he still hasn't changed his mentality, I'm a good person, I help innocent people, I don't loot, I don't do bad things for power, I take care of the child of the animal I killed. He is a complete brain disabled. If there is no system in this world, 1 week can't even survive.

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
ChiicHiimenon

I really don't like how he wasted his wishes and really don't like Naruto elements in cultivation world so I always drop them because it really doesn't match my taste and the system 🤮🤮🤮🤮

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
SAURON_

please update more that's all you really need to do I'm starving for more chapters. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------

img
2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Sinnermann

There is great flow in the story, the writing is updog , .....................................................................................................

img
2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Henrique_Paiao

[img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend]

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Lionn_

Mc is Gay! [img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap]

2yr
Voir 1 Réponses
fantacia_000

i do like this novel . but I do dislike the mc in the later chapters . it is like at first mc was smart and a bit calculative as he was living in constant danger . he was also diligent in his cultivation as he got past multiple realms easily , but in later chapters his cultivation diligence is seem decreasing . iam not badmouthing or anything it feels like he is in same realm several months . and mc also become overly emotional and and self blamer . it is like I lost the image of my mc I had in my mind from the start . mc also forgot the dangers of cultivation worlds as he severely underestimate people as uncivilized people . although i dislike mc the story of novel is good and i hope the mc come back to his usual style .

2yr
Voir 2 Réponses
wolu918

the story base is extremely good, but the the mc is too hipocrite , . And is too weak hearted, also unable to stand on one decesion. Also naive .

3yr
Voir 0 Réponses
pwrsk8r
LV 14 Badge

I enjoyed it, not many tech /cultivation fusion novels, thought it was cool. . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . .. . . . … . . . . . . . . … . . . .. . .

3yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Newnoob

MC is OP. Also he's not a pushover(so far atleast). MC's cool headed, doesn't goof around wasting his potential, currently on chapter 41, so far no love interest. It's enjoyable so far. Read at your own discretion and judge.

3yr
Voir 0 Réponses
lord_couchpotato

A Cultivation fanfics that is not ATG, TDG, Soul land and BTTH huh? i will give it 5 stars lol....................................................................................................................

3yr
Voir 2 Réponses
MachinaOnTheMoon

It has a good chunk of flaws but some good parts. I mean the flaws kinda out weigh the pros by a bit so that why my rating is so low. Sorry author guy

3yr
Voir 0 Réponses
LoverOfGula

is the mc interested in women? what i mean is if he'll pursue a woman if he likes them or if he'll never go after any woman. whether its harem or not doesn't matter if he gets in cliche sexual situations yet ignores every woman he sees.

3yr
Voir 3 Réponses
Henrique_Paiao

[img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=update][img=update]

3yr
Voir 0 Réponses
EijiSeishuu

this mc protag xiaxia or xuanhuan?? ...............................................................................................................................

3yr
Voir 1 Réponses
Henrique_Paiao

[img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend]

3yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Monarch_Of_Hell

it needs editing.[img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp]

3yr
Voir 0 Réponses
InternetSaint

This is a "With a SYSTEM" story only more cringe because it is for cultivation. ................. ................. ................. ................. ................. ................. ................. ................. ................. ................. ................. ................. ................. .................

3yr
Voir 25 Réponses
UhVise_Necro

It looks really good. but i hope he doesnt become too obsessed with strength or too scared of powerful hidden experts to actually live a little and enjoy his new life. Ive seen a lot of fics do that and its not very enjoyable.

3yr
Voir 2 Réponses
ThePath

Started good and funny but devolved to a cheap and badly written Xianxia knock-off. In the first chapters of the story I thought it would be a good "Crackfic" which is fun and making of the Xianxia trope mixed with an absurdly overpowered system. This however quickly dissolved and the MC just became a wanderer type alchemist following all the cliches this trope has to offer, I honestly think the creativity of the author died. The whole thing needs a re-write, the start although creative and funny doesn't flow correctly and is not well written, author the book "Story Genius: How to Use Brain Science to Go Beyond Outlining and Write a Riveting Novel" is a good one on the subject. I would like to see more western comical elements, you gave him the memories of the one and only Rick Sanchez, that is completely absurd and could've made this whole work funnier if you employed some of his crazy characteristics, although memories does not equal personality and thinking patterns they should have had a gigantic change to the MC. The MC should've embraced more of Ricks mad scientist instead of nihilistic genius (since he got young ricks memories), so stuff like him releasing T-Virus equivalents to power up non-cultivators and other wacky stuff that would've made the whole plot more engaging. An over-arching plot-point would be nice, for example MC is in one of the lower realms that exist and in the end we find that the one who is managing/created the realms did so he can sacrifice the souls of people living there for power. However our MC does not care about that. Anyway, in conclusion your novel sparked my imagination but failed to deliver, a good fan-fiction that did something similar would be "You are Courting Death" but that one didn't have a crazy scientist. Overall if you re-write this I know you can do a lot better

2yr
Voir 5 Réponses
DaoistElxnbZ

This story has been abandoned or is on hiatus, I really enjoyed reading it.......................................................................................................

5mth
Voir 0 Réponses
Patrick_hell123

I like your story it's very interesting to listen to

10mth
Voir 0 Réponses
DaoistH7599X

Painfully stupid. From the very start with his dumb wishes and dumb talk with a ROB that judges rinnegan worth 2 wishes and the system costs 1, don't know what else to say, it is just dumb xianxia of mediocre level even in its own league.

1yr
Voir 1 Réponses
Reykun
LV 13 Badge

Good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good good

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Ibrahim_NiR

Eres grande amigo, es una de las historias sobre cultivo más ligeras y emocionantes para leer de un solo golpe jajaja... Necesito más de esta novela

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
timeawayfromstress

You can understand that mc is stupid from the first episode. In the next episodes, he still hasn't changed his mentality, I'm a good person, I help innocent people, I don't loot, I don't do bad things for power, I take care of the child of the animal I killed. He is a complete brain disabled. If there is no system in this world, 1 week can't even survive.

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
ChiicHiimenon

I really don't like how he wasted his wishes and really don't like Naruto elements in cultivation world so I always drop them because it really doesn't match my taste and the system 🤮🤮🤮🤮

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
SAURON_

please update more that's all you really need to do I'm starving for more chapters. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------

img
2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Sinnermann

There is great flow in the story, the writing is updog , .....................................................................................................

img
2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Henrique_Paiao

[img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend]

2yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Lionn_

Mc is Gay! [img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap][img=faceslap]

2yr
Voir 1 Réponses
fantacia_000

i do like this novel . but I do dislike the mc in the later chapters . it is like at first mc was smart and a bit calculative as he was living in constant danger . he was also diligent in his cultivation as he got past multiple realms easily , but in later chapters his cultivation diligence is seem decreasing . iam not badmouthing or anything it feels like he is in same realm several months . and mc also become overly emotional and and self blamer . it is like I lost the image of my mc I had in my mind from the start . mc also forgot the dangers of cultivation worlds as he severely underestimate people as uncivilized people . although i dislike mc the story of novel is good and i hope the mc come back to his usual style .

2yr
Voir 2 Réponses
wolu918

the story base is extremely good, but the the mc is too hipocrite , . And is too weak hearted, also unable to stand on one decesion. Also naive .

3yr
Voir 0 Réponses
pwrsk8r
LV 14 Badge

I enjoyed it, not many tech /cultivation fusion novels, thought it was cool. . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . .. . . . … . . . . . . . . … . . . .. . .

3yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Newnoob

MC is OP. Also he's not a pushover(so far atleast). MC's cool headed, doesn't goof around wasting his potential, currently on chapter 41, so far no love interest. It's enjoyable so far. Read at your own discretion and judge.

3yr
Voir 0 Réponses
lord_couchpotato

A Cultivation fanfics that is not ATG, TDG, Soul land and BTTH huh? i will give it 5 stars lol....................................................................................................................

3yr
Voir 2 Réponses
MachinaOnTheMoon

It has a good chunk of flaws but some good parts. I mean the flaws kinda out weigh the pros by a bit so that why my rating is so low. Sorry author guy

3yr
Voir 0 Réponses
LoverOfGula

is the mc interested in women? what i mean is if he'll pursue a woman if he likes them or if he'll never go after any woman. whether its harem or not doesn't matter if he gets in cliche sexual situations yet ignores every woman he sees.

3yr
Voir 3 Réponses
Henrique_Paiao

[img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=update][img=update]

3yr
Voir 0 Réponses
EijiSeishuu

this mc protag xiaxia or xuanhuan?? ...............................................................................................................................

3yr
Voir 1 Réponses
Henrique_Paiao

[img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend]

3yr
Voir 0 Réponses
Monarch_Of_Hell

it needs editing.[img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp][img=exp]

3yr
Voir 0 Réponses
InternetSaint

This is a "With a SYSTEM" story only more cringe because it is for cultivation. ................. ................. ................. ................. ................. ................. ................. ................. ................. ................. ................. ................. ................. .................

3yr
Voir 25 Réponses
UhVise_Necro

It looks really good. but i hope he doesnt become too obsessed with strength or too scared of powerful hidden experts to actually live a little and enjoy his new life. Ive seen a lot of fics do that and its not very enjoyable.

3yr
Voir 2 Réponses