Reviews of LotR SI: Mordor for the Orcs by JManM - Webnovel

15Reviews

4.76

  • Writing Quality
  • Stability of Updates
  • Story Development
  • Character Design
  • World Background

Share your thoughts with others

Write a review
ScientistXxXx

JManM Never dissapoints ever His fics are always decent to a certain degree

1yr
View 0 Replies
Sagvey_Ay

More more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more Please please please please please

1yr
View 0 Replies
Orion1614

Great story. It kind of sucks that he had to do Tom like that though.

Reveal Spoiler
1yr
View 0 Replies
Eric8the4lost_

This one of the best lotr fics I have ever read. I never felt bored reading it, nor could I predict how the story would go. The MC is an absolute a##hole, but also charasmatic, funny, and relatable. The only issue that I could see someone having with this fic (outside of some of the jokes) would be with how how short the chapters are. I honestly don't have an issue with it. The author does a good job making each chapter satisfying to read despite the lack of length.

2yr
View 2 Replies
TreacherousVoid

The story is quite good. My only issue is that i came into it expecting it to be serious and have a plot line/goal but it does not. Theres no problem with that it just isnt what i expected when first clicking to read the story. Its full of humorous (orc big and strong) type jokes and whatnot but there doesnt seem to be an actual goal or flow to the story. MC absolutely rekts Talion, and then does it again, and again, and again….you get the idea. Thats ALL that happens storywise lol I’m currently 15 chapters into the story and will come back to read more at a later date. I think its worth the read if you know what to expect before hand.

2yr
View 0 Replies
Z4Zed
LV 4 Badge

can't recommend this enough, good writing, the story will keep you hooked [img=recommend]

2yr
View 1 Replies
Killjoy4Life

This is a extremely solid fanfic the author has a solid understanding of the background, made sure that any debatable lore was made clear fleshed out in a good way and has kept the story and character both true to there buildup.

2yr
View 1 Replies
theratking88

Great first few chapters can't wait to see more, I believe that this story idea has not fully been explored. I think the Thrag should use this opportunity to devlop orchish culture and society with schools, currency and a more civilan lifestyle for a regular orc with orcish spin. If you want orcs to be seen as a still evil and only male race maybe make it so that orcs can breed with different races of women like from goblin slayer, maybe giving more incentive to go raiding to capture women for faster gestation time and or women having a litter than longer single breeding pod.

2yr
View 0 Replies
theratking88

well good story so far. Quite interesting and unique imo from others.well good story so far. Quite interesting and unique imo from others.well good story so far. Quite interesting and unique imo from others.

2yr
View 0 Replies
Cat_Lover152

I really like the story and keep it up the way you have created the story makes a vivid setting for your merciles warlord uruk who combines humour bloodshed kingdom building and monster pets (the most important) The only issue is i want more

2yr
View 0 Replies
Kevin_Pollard

Sweet! So Sweet, The Sweetest Sweet thats ever Sweet'd. FLUFFY TOWELS! FLUFFY TOWELS! Sweeeet~ /////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////

2yr
View 2 Replies
Will_Caruso

Great first few chapters can't wait to see more, Great first few chapters can't wait to see more, Great first few chapters can't wait to see more, Great first few chapters can't wait to see more, Great first few chapters can't wait to see more, Great first few chapters can't wait to see more,

img
2yr
View 0 Replies
Gumbus

shadow of mordor is basically grunts wet dream, sexy elven booty, brutal homies to turn into even more brutal homies of grimdark warhammer proportions. dark lords to brutalize and take the place of. Just an all around good time to be had with insane oversized beasties to tame, eat, and make cool stuff out of. with what seems to be a faith/following based power up system mordor will quickly turn from raving chaotic lunatics loosly slapped together in the shape of a cohesive army into a pinical of military industrial complex glory.

2yr
View 1 Replies
Mr_Potatochu

it very cool, very cool indeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee eeeeeed

2yr
View 0 Replies
Jay_Miles_0662

Great first few chapters can't wait to see more, I believe that this story idea has not fully been explored. I think the Thrag should use this opportunity to devlop orchish culture and society with schools, currency and a more civilan lifestyle for a regular orc with orcish spin. If you want orcs to be seen as a still evil and only male race maybe make it so that orcs can breed with different races of women like from goblin slayer, maybe giving more incentive to go raiding to capture women for faster gestation time and or women having a litter than longer single breeding pod.

2yr
View 4 Replies
ScientistXxXx

JManM Never dissapoints ever His fics are always decent to a certain degree

1yr
View 0 Replies
Sagvey_Ay

More more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more more Please please please please please

1yr
View 0 Replies
Orion1614

Great story. It kind of sucks that he had to do Tom like that though.

Reveal Spoiler
1yr
View 0 Replies
Eric8the4lost_

This one of the best lotr fics I have ever read. I never felt bored reading it, nor could I predict how the story would go. The MC is an absolute a##hole, but also charasmatic, funny, and relatable. The only issue that I could see someone having with this fic (outside of some of the jokes) would be with how how short the chapters are. I honestly don't have an issue with it. The author does a good job making each chapter satisfying to read despite the lack of length.

2yr
View 2 Replies
TreacherousVoid

The story is quite good. My only issue is that i came into it expecting it to be serious and have a plot line/goal but it does not. Theres no problem with that it just isnt what i expected when first clicking to read the story. Its full of humorous (orc big and strong) type jokes and whatnot but there doesnt seem to be an actual goal or flow to the story. MC absolutely rekts Talion, and then does it again, and again, and again….you get the idea. Thats ALL that happens storywise lol I’m currently 15 chapters into the story and will come back to read more at a later date. I think its worth the read if you know what to expect before hand.

2yr
View 0 Replies
Z4Zed
LV 4 Badge

can't recommend this enough, good writing, the story will keep you hooked [img=recommend]

2yr
View 1 Replies
Killjoy4Life

This is a extremely solid fanfic the author has a solid understanding of the background, made sure that any debatable lore was made clear fleshed out in a good way and has kept the story and character both true to there buildup.

2yr
View 1 Replies
theratking88

Great first few chapters can't wait to see more, I believe that this story idea has not fully been explored. I think the Thrag should use this opportunity to devlop orchish culture and society with schools, currency and a more civilan lifestyle for a regular orc with orcish spin. If you want orcs to be seen as a still evil and only male race maybe make it so that orcs can breed with different races of women like from goblin slayer, maybe giving more incentive to go raiding to capture women for faster gestation time and or women having a litter than longer single breeding pod.

2yr
View 0 Replies
theratking88

well good story so far. Quite interesting and unique imo from others.well good story so far. Quite interesting and unique imo from others.well good story so far. Quite interesting and unique imo from others.

2yr
View 0 Replies
Cat_Lover152

I really like the story and keep it up the way you have created the story makes a vivid setting for your merciles warlord uruk who combines humour bloodshed kingdom building and monster pets (the most important) The only issue is i want more

2yr
View 0 Replies
Kevin_Pollard

Sweet! So Sweet, The Sweetest Sweet thats ever Sweet'd. FLUFFY TOWELS! FLUFFY TOWELS! Sweeeet~ /////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////

2yr
View 2 Replies
Will_Caruso

Great first few chapters can't wait to see more, Great first few chapters can't wait to see more, Great first few chapters can't wait to see more, Great first few chapters can't wait to see more, Great first few chapters can't wait to see more, Great first few chapters can't wait to see more,

img
2yr
View 0 Replies
Gumbus

shadow of mordor is basically grunts wet dream, sexy elven booty, brutal homies to turn into even more brutal homies of grimdark warhammer proportions. dark lords to brutalize and take the place of. Just an all around good time to be had with insane oversized beasties to tame, eat, and make cool stuff out of. with what seems to be a faith/following based power up system mordor will quickly turn from raving chaotic lunatics loosly slapped together in the shape of a cohesive army into a pinical of military industrial complex glory.

2yr
View 1 Replies
Mr_Potatochu

it very cool, very cool indeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee eeeeeed

2yr
View 0 Replies
Jay_Miles_0662

Great first few chapters can't wait to see more, I believe that this story idea has not fully been explored. I think the Thrag should use this opportunity to devlop orchish culture and society with schools, currency and a more civilan lifestyle for a regular orc with orcish spin. If you want orcs to be seen as a still evil and only male race maybe make it so that orcs can breed with different races of women like from goblin slayer, maybe giving more incentive to go raiding to capture women for faster gestation time and or women having a litter than longer single breeding pod.

2yr
View 4 Replies