One creepy element is the unknown. In many true creepy stories, there's something that can't be explained, like the disappearing hitchhiker. You don't know where she came from or where she went. It gives a sense of mystery and fear.
One really creepy Muslim ghost story is about a jinn. In some tales, a jinn might haunt an old, abandoned mosque. People claim to have heard strange noises like whispers in Arabic prayers coming from the empty hallways. It gives the feeling that the spirits of the past are still lingering there.
There was a story of a cursed doll. It was found in an old attic. Whoever owned it would start having nightmares. People reported seeing the doll move when no one was around. Its eyes seemed to follow them. Eventually, the doll disappeared mysteriously, leaving only fear behind.
It depends on your tolerance for the creepy. If you're easily spooked by things like ghosts or unexplained events, then you'll probably find many of the stories in Creepy Catalog True Stories really scary. For instance, the stories about haunted asylums with the sounds of patients still screaming can be quite disturbing.
One creepy true ghost story is about the Winchester Mystery House. Sarah Winchester, the owner, kept building onto the house non - stop. It's said that she was haunted by the spirits of those killed by Winchester rifles. Workers on the house reported strange noises and apparitions. Doors would open and close on their own, and cold spots were felt throughout the house.
The unknown is a key element. When you don't know what's causing the horror, like in a story where there are strange noises in the dark and you can't see the source. It's terrifying.
Yes. There was a story where a player's entire island seemed to distort. The trees were bent in strange ways, and the buildings looked like they were melting. It was as if the game world was falling apart, and the player couldn't do anything to fix it. It was really disturbing.
How about 'The Forgotten Graveyard', 'The Malevolent Mansion', and 'The Ghastly Glade'? 'The Forgotten Graveyard' is a place filled with the dead and forgotten, which is always a spooky concept. 'The Malevolent Mansion' implies that the building has an evil presence within it. 'The Ghastly Glade' gives the impression of a small, creepy clearing in a forest where something unnatural might occur.
There could be various reasons why it's considered 'creepy'. It might deviate from the standard MLP lore regarding Pinkie Pie. For example, it could have Pinkie in a desolate or nightmarish setting that is not at all like the bright and colorful Equestria we know. Or perhaps it gives Pinkie some powers or behaviors that are not in line with her character, like some form of mind control or a really odd obsession. Without reading it, this is all speculation, but these are the types of things that could potentially make a fanfic about Pinkie 'creepy'.