Well, the idea of it being a 'true story' adds to the creepiness factor. The events described, like the presence of a malevolent spirit, are what make it so haunting. There were reports of things moving on their own and a feeling of being watched all the time. This all combined makes it a truly spooky tale.
There was this one time when I visited an old, dilapidated mansion. The moment I entered, I smelled a strange, musty odor. As I explored the rooms, the doors would close on their own. In one of the rooms upstairs, I found an old diary. When I opened it, I could swear I heard a voice whispering my name. I dropped the diary and ran out. I'm still haunted by the mystery of that place.
Once, I was in an old, abandoned house. The moment I stepped in, a cold chill ran down my spine. I heard strange creaking sounds that seemed to come from every corner. As I walked further, I saw a shadowy figure at the end of the hallway. It disappeared in an instant. I ran out of that house as fast as I could, and I still get shivers thinking about it.
Yes, it is based on a supposedly true story. The events in Amityville were widely publicized and led to books and movies. However, there are also many who question the authenticity of the claims.
The Bell Witch Haunting is also a very well - known creepy story. In Tennessee, the Bell family was terrorized by a malevolent spirit known as the Bell Witch. It would make strange noises, pull hair, and even slap people. It tormented the family for years and there are many accounts from the family members themselves that make this story truly spine - chilling.