The fem gymnastics reader could be curious. Despite the differences in the two areas, she may want to explore this new type of fanfiction. Maybe she'll be interested in how the writers create such a spooky atmosphere and unique characters in creepypasta fanfiction.
She could be fascinated. Despite the contrast, the unique and often complex storytelling in creepypasta might draw her in. She might start to analyze how the authors create such an intense atmosphere, which could be different from any analysis she's done in relation to gymnastics, but still engaging in its own way.