Yes. Some people are extremely sensitive, and horror stories can have a profound negative impact on them. They might have nightmares, develop phobias related to the elements in the stories, or experience high levels of anxiety. For example, a person who is already prone to anxiety might be so terrified by a horror story that they can't sleep at night or feel constantly on edge during the day, which shows that people can be too scared in such cases.
Sure. For example, children or those with a weak psychological constitution may be too scared. Horror stories often contain elements of the unknown, violence, and death. When exposed to these for a long time or if they are overly immersed, it can lead to excessive fear. They may start to fear the dark, being alone, or certain objects that are similar to those in the stories.
They often have a sense of mystery. For example, in many horror stories, the characters might have strange abilities or secrets that are gradually revealed as the story unfolds. This adds to the sense of unease and horror.
A group of 13 hikers went into the forest. They found an abandoned cabin. When they entered, they felt an immediate sense of dread. Darkness seemed to seep into their very souls. Then, they noticed strange symbols on the walls. As night fell, a howling wind outside signaled the start of their harrowing encounter with the unknown, and they soon realized they might not make it out alive.
It could be that horror allows us to confront our fears in a safe way. We get to experience the terror but know it's not real. Plus, the element of surprise and the build-up of tension can be really addictive.