There's a story in the Creepypasta True Ghost Stories where a man was driving on a lonely road at night. He saw a figure on the side of the road that seemed to be a girl. As he got closer, she disappeared. But then his car started having problems. When he finally got it started again and drove off, he saw the girl's face in his rear - view mirror. It's a classic example of the kind of ghostly encounters in these stories. These stories often play on our fears of the unknown and the supernatural.
The way the ghosts interact with the living in Creepypasta True Ghost Stories can be really terrifying. For example, in stories where ghosts manipulate objects around people. They might move things around in a room while someone is sleeping, or turn on appliances unexpectedly. It gives a feeling that the ghosts are toying with the living, and that there's no escape from their influence. Also, the sudden appearances of ghosts, like a face suddenly showing up in a mirror or a figure emerging from a wall, are extremely scary.
It depends on the person. Some people might find creepypasta scarier because it can be very graphic and often plays on modern fears like technology going wrong. For example, stories about haunted apps or cursed websites can be really creepy. Others might find ghost stories scarier because they have a sense of timelessness and mystery. The idea of a ghostly apparition in an old, dark place can send shivers down one's spine.
There's a story of an old abandoned house. People say that at midnight, if you pass by it, you can see a ghostly light in one of the upper - floor windows. A young boy once decided to be brave and peek inside. He saw a pale face staring back at him, and then he heard a wailing sound that made him run for his life.
The sense of realism. Many of these stories are set in ordinary places like our own homes or the woods near our neighborhoods. When we can easily picture the setting in our minds, it becomes more terrifying. For instance, the idea of 'Bloody Mary' appearing in our own bathroom is a very chilling thought. Also, the characters in these stories often have disturbing features. Jeff the Killer's disfigured face and his maniacal grin are really scary, and it makes us imagine how horrible it would be to encounter such a being in real life.