There was a hotel room that was known to be haunted. A traveler checked in, not believing the rumors. At night, he heard the sound of a baby crying. He thought it was coming from the next room, but when he called the front desk, they said there were no other guests on that floor. The crying got louder and louder. Then, he saw a figure of a woman in a white dress holding a baby in the corner of the room. She just stared at him with empty eyes. He tried to run out of the room, but the door was jammed, and he was left trembling in fear.
There was a cemetery on the outskirts of town. Late one night, a man was walking past it. As he did, he heard a faint scratching sound coming from one of the graves. He stopped, his heart pounding. He told himself it was just an animal, but then he saw the dirt on one of the graves start to move. A pale hand emerged from the ground. The man was frozen in fear. He wanted to run, but his legs wouldn't move. Then, a figure started to pull itself out of the grave, moaning in a way that sent shivers down his spine.
There was a small town where every Christmas, people would hear a haunting carol. It seemed to come from the old, abandoned church on the hill. One year, a curious boy named Tom decided to investigate. As he entered the church, it was freezing cold. He saw a figure in a tattered Christmas robe by the altar. The figure turned and its face was a blur. It sang a song that made Tom's blood run cold. He ran out as fast as he could, and from that day on, he never went near the church on Christmas again.
Well, start with a spooky setting. Maybe an old abandoned house or a dark forest. Then, introduce some mysterious characters and build up tension gradually.
One key factor is the element of the unknown. When readers don't know exactly what the threat is, it creates a sense of unease. For example, in a story where there are strange noises in a house but you don't know what's causing them. Another is the use of atmosphere. Dark, desolate settings like an old, empty cemetery or a run - down attic can add to the creepiness. Also, unexpected twists can make a short creepy story effective. Just when you think the character is safe, something terrifying happens.
Here is one. A man was walking alone in the forest at night. He noticed a small, dilapidated cabin. As he got closer, he heard a soft humming. When he peered through the window, he saw a woman sitting in a rocking chair, but she had no face. Only a blank, smooth expanse where her face should be. He fled in terror, the humming growing louder behind him.
The combination of dark themes, mysterious settings, and unexpected plot twists makes it creepy. The way the characters are presented and the atmosphere created adds to the overall creepiness.
A good creepy short story needs a strong sense of mystery. Take 'The Tell - Tale Heart'. You're constantly wondering what the narrator will do next and why he's so obsessed with the old man's eye. Another important factor is the use of vivid descriptions. In 'The Masque of the Red Death', Poe's detailed descriptions of the different rooms and the masked figure add to the creepiness. Also, the theme of the story can contribute. If it's about something that violates our normal sense of the world, like in 'Carmilla' with its vampire element, it can be very creepy.