One time, my neighbor's house always had a strange smell at night. And there were often odd noises like scratching on the walls. I once saw him late at night carrying a big sack into his house, and he had a very creepy look on his face. I was so scared that I avoided going near his place as much as possible.
I heard about a neighbor who would break into other people's houses when they were away. He would just sit in their living rooms, not stealing anything, just sitting there. When one family came back early and caught him, he just stared at them blankly and walked out slowly. It was so creepy.
The unpredictability. You never know what they might do next. For example, in a story I heard, a neighbor who seemed friendly suddenly started leaving dead animals on another neighbor's porch for no reason.
My old neighbor used to leave dead animals on my doorstep. At first, I thought it was some kind of sick prank by kids in the neighborhood. But then I realized it was him. He had a really mean look in his eyes whenever I saw him. I was terrified and called the police. They talked to him, but he just gave them a blank stare. After that, I installed security cameras around my house.
A truly terrifying neighbor story involves a neighbor who seemed really nice at first. But then it was discovered that they were stealing small items from other people's porches. People started to notice things missing like packages and small garden decorations. It created a sense of unease and mistrust in the neighborhood. People were constantly worried about what else this neighbor might do.
One possible scary story could be about a strange figure that appears in the neighbor's backyard at midnight. It's a tall, shadowy figure with glowing eyes that seems to be watching the neighborhood. Whenever someone tries to get a closer look, it vanishes into thin air.
I had a neighbor who constantly left strange, anonymous notes on my door. They were full of cryptic messages that made no sense. It was really unsettling. Then there was this neighbor whose house always smelled really bad, like something was rotting, and they never seemed to do anything about it. The third scary neighbor story was about a guy who would walk around the neighborhood at odd hours and mutter to himself. It made everyone feel uneasy.
Once, my neighbor always peeked through my window at night. It was really creepy. Every time I looked out, I could see a shadow moving. I was so scared that I had to keep my curtains closed all the time.
The unpredictability. You never know what a creepy neighbor might do next. One day they might seem normal, and the next they could be doing something really strange like leaving strange symbols on your door.
My worst neighbor used to blast really loud music at all hours of the night. It was impossible to sleep. I tried talking to them nicely at first, but they just ignored me. Eventually, I had to call the cops a few times before they finally toned it down.