The 'Eragon' series is sometimes considered bad in the YA fantasy genre. The plot is quite derivative, borrowing heavily from other established fantasy works. The writing style is also a bit clumsy at times, with descriptions that can be overly long and not very engaging.
Well, 'The Selection' is often regarded as one of the not - so - great YA fantasy novels. It has a rather shallow concept where girls are basically competing for a prince in a very contrived way. The characters lack depth and the plot doesn't really offer much in terms of original ideas.
Well, 'The Darkest Minds' can be considered one of the worst ya dystopian novels. The plot is all over the place and the dystopian elements feel forced. It jumps from one event to another without proper build - up. 'Rebel Belle' is another one. It has a strange mix of magic and dystopia that doesn't really gel well. The characters are not very engaging either. And 'Shatter Me' has a very inconsistent writing style. The dystopian world it creates is not very clear, and the relationships between the characters seem rather forced and not very well - developed.
One of the novels often considered among the worst in the fantasy genre on Goodreads could be 'Twilight' by Stephenie Meyer. Many critics feel that its take on vampires and werewolves is rather simplistic and the writing style lacks depth. However, it's also extremely popular, which shows the divide between popular and critically 'good' in the fantasy genre.
One of the worst could be 'Twilight' by Stephanie Meyer. While it has a huge fan base, from a pure fantasy perspective, it has a very weak world - building. The vampires are more like sparkly humans rather than the traditional, complex and often menacing creatures in classic fantasy. Also, the plot is mainly centered around a love triangle which overshadows the fantasy elements.
Some ideas for ya fantasy novels include a world where dreams are real and can be manipulated. The protagonist, a young dreamwalker, has to enter the nightmares of people to fight off dark entities that are trying to spread fear through the dream world. Another could be a story set in a forest that has a mind of its own. The trees can move, and the young characters must figure out how to communicate with the forest to save their village which is under threat from a neighboring, more aggressive tribe. Additionally, a fantasy idea could be a world where there are different levels of reality, and a young girl discovers she can shift between these levels, and she has to use this ability to stop a chaos - causing entity that is breaking down the barriers between the levels.
Definitely 'Harry Potter'. It has been a global phenomenon, loved by millions for its detailed magical world, memorable characters like Harry, Hermione, and Ron, and its themes of friendship, courage, and good versus evil. Another well - known one is 'The Hunger Games'. It's known for its intense and thought - provoking story about survival and resistance in a harsh, controlling society.
Sure. 'The 5th Wave' is a bit of a letdown. The story tries to be this big, epic dystopian tale but ends up being a bit of a mess. The different 'waves' of the alien invasion are not well - coordinated in the plot. Also, the characters don't have much depth. 'The Giver' is often misclassified as a great dystopian novel when it actually has some problems. It's very slow - paced and the dystopian world is not as fully explored as it could be. The ending is also rather ambiguous and not very satisfying. 'Legend' is another one. The world - building is not very detailed and the love story seems tacked on rather than an integral part of the dystopian narrative.
Well, from the list of ya fantasy novels, there's 'Throne of Glass' by Sarah J. Maas. This series follows the story of Celaena Sardothien, an assassin in a fantasy world filled with magic, politics, and danger. Also, 'Shadow and Bone' is quite good. It has a unique magic system and interesting characters set in a world inspired by Russian folklore. Then there's 'A Court of Thorns and Roses' which features a strong - willed protagonist and a richly imagined faerie world.
I think 'The Mortal Instruments' series has some issues. The plot gets really convoluted as the series progresses. There are so many characters and sub - plots that it becomes hard to follow. And the world - building isn't as consistent as it could be.