It could be a rewrite where Harry is raised by someone other than the Dursleys. For example, if he was raised by Sirius Black from the start, his whole outlook on magic and the wizarding world might be different. Sirius would have taught him about his family's noble history and perhaps some dark magic secrets earlier, which could change how Harry approaches challenges at Hogwarts.
If the beginning is changed, like if the Philosopher's Stone was never hidden at Hogwarts, then the whole first year's plot would be different. There would be no need for Harry, Ron, and Hermione to go on that adventure to stop Voldemort from getting it. This would mean different relationships would form as they wouldn't have had that shared experience.
One reason to start questioning Harry Potter fanfiction could be the divergence from the original lore. Some fanfictions might change key aspects of the wizarding world, like magic rules or character personalities. For example, if a fanfiction makes Harry a completely different person with no regard for his canon traits, it can be off - putting.
Well, different 'want' in Harry Potter fanfiction could mean different things. One aspect is the want for adventure. Many fanfictions explore characters' desires to go on new adventures outside of Hogwarts. Another could be the want for acceptance. A character might be an outcast in the original story but in fanfiction, they strive for acceptance within the wizarding community. Also, there's the want for revenge, which can create really intense storylines in fanfiction where a character has been wronged and wants to get back at those who did them harm.
It could also be due to the fact that a large portion of fanfiction focuses on shipping (pairing characters romantically). While shipping can be fun for some, others might feel that it overshadows other aspects of the story. For example, if most fanfictions are just about who Harry should be with instead of exploring the rich magical world further, it can make you question its overall popularity.
Perhaps you could start with 'Was Snape truly redeemed? And did Harry ever fully understand his sacrifices?' These two questions can lead to a deep exploration of the complex relationship between Harry and Snape, delving into the moral and emotional aspects of the story. It can create a fanfiction that focuses on the gray areas of the characters' personalities and actions.
In Harry Potter fanfiction, different personalities can be really fascinating. For example, some fanfics might explore a more confident and rebellious Hermione. She could be the one leading secret magical experiments outside of Hogwarts rules. Another aspect could be a Slytherin Harry. He might use his Slytherin traits like cunning and ambition to outwit Voldemort in unique ways, rather than the more Gryffindor - like bravery - centered approach in the original books.
Well, in Harry Potter fanfiction, Diagon Alley is a staple. It's where you can find Ollivander's for wands, Weasley's Wizard Wheezes for all sorts of pranks. Then there's Knockturn Alley. It's the place that gives off an eerie vibe. Some fanfictions might also create their own alleys. For example, an alley that is hidden and only accessible by a secret spell. This alley could be home to a group of outcast wizards who practice a different kind of magic that is not accepted by the mainstream wizarding society.
A pegasus Patronus is also a great concept in fanfiction. Pegasus represents grace and freedom. A character with a pegasus Patronus might be someone who values these qualities. They could be the type of person who is always looking for a way to break free from constraints, whether it's social norms or dark magic threats in the wizarding world. This Patronus could also suggest a connection to the skies and a more spiritual side of magic.