Percy's reaction could be complex. Initially, he'd be hurt and angry. But as time passes, if Annabeth is sincere in her attempts to get him back, he might start to question his own feelings. He could be torn between his love for her and the pain of the betrayal.
In such a fanfic, the plot could be very complex. Maybe Annabeth realizes she made a huge mistake. She might start by trying to approach Percy subtly, like showing up at his favorite places. But Percy would be hurt and angry. He might initially reject her attempts. However, as she keeps trying, she could start to show real remorse and explain the reasons for her cheating, which could be due to some external influence or her own insecurities. And Percy might gradually start to question his own feelings towards her again.
In most fanfics, this is often just a fictional and sometimes out - of - character plot device. There's no real evidence within the official Percy Jackson canon for such a thing, but in fan - created stories, it could be based on the author's desire to create drama. However, it goes against the core relationship we know from the original books.
One possibility is that Annabeth has to face some challenges to prove to Percy that she truly wants him back. She could be on a quest to find something important to Percy, like a lost item from his past. This would show her dedication. Also, there might be some new characters in the fanfic who try to stop her from getting back with Percy, adding more drama to the story.
Annabeth could try to be more understanding of Percy's needs. In the fanfiction, she might give him space at first, but then slowly show up in his life in small, positive ways. Like bringing him his favorite food or helping him with a difficult task without being pushy.
The storyline could develop with Annabeth first reflecting on what went wrong in their relationship. She might write in a journal all the things she misses about Percy. Then she could take the bold step of showing up at Percy's new place unannounced. This would shock Percy but also open the door for communication.
There could also be external factors. For example, there might be a prophecy or some sort of danger that keeps Percy away from Annabeth. He might be so focused on dealing with this external threat that he doesn't have time or energy to think about getting back together with her.
I don't think there are many 'worth reading' ones in this category. Fanfics about cheating often go against the core of the relationship in the original story. The relationship between Annabeth and Percy is based on trust and a long - journeyed bond. Most of these kinds of fanfics might be created just for shock value rather than for good storytelling.
Well, it's possible that such a fanfiction exists given the creativity of fanfiction authors. They like to experiment with different relationship dynamics. But considering the popularity and the nature of Annabeth and Percy's relationship in the source material, this would be quite a shocker. It could also attract a lot of criticism from fans who are attached to the original relationship, while others might be interested in seeing how such a different plot would unfold.
There might be such fanfiction out there in the vast world of fan - created content. However, this kind of plot goes against the original relationship dynamics in many fans' eyes. It's important to note that fanfiction can cover a wide range of scenarios, some of which may be controversial or not in line with the general perception of the original story.