Family is a common theme. It could be about how Ben and Joshua deal with the situation of having a baby together or separately. Another theme might be love, like romantic love between them or with other characters in the story.
Well, you could try looking on fanfiction.net. There are often a variety of stories in different genres related to this topic. Just search for 'baby daddy ben and joshua' and you'll find some.
In a fanfiction scenario, Ben and Riley could be at a masquerade ball in their town. They don't recognize each other at first because of the masks. They start dancing and chatting, and there's an instant connection. When they finally take off their masks, they are both surprised and happy, and this event could be the start of a romantic relationship between them.
In this fanfiction, Riley discovers she's pregnant. Ben might be hesitant at first because he has some insecurities about being a father. However, as time passes, he sees Riley's strength and determination. They go through the usual pregnancy journey together, like going to doctor's appointments, shopping for baby stuff. Their relationship also deepens during this time as they face the challenges and joys of impending parenthood.
Love and romance also play a big part. Often, the stories will start with them just being connected through the baby, but then they gradually fall in love. For example, in many fanfictions, Ben might realize how strong and amazing Riley is while they are dealing with a baby - related crisis, and that realization can spark his deeper feelings for her. It's a common trope in these stories.
The fanfiction could revolve around Ben getting injured and Riley taking care of him. During this time, Riley discovers a more vulnerable side of Ben that she hadn't seen before. Ben, in turn, realizes how much he appreciates Riley's presence in his life. This situation could lead to a romantic development between them. For example, one night when Ben has a fever, Riley stays up all night to take care of him. As he wakes up in the morning, seeing Riley asleep next to his bed, he feels a warmth in his heart that he hadn't felt before.
Ben and Josh are the central figures. Ben could be portrayed as the more impulsive of the two. He might make hasty decisions that often get them into funny or tricky situations. Josh is probably the one who tries to keep things in order. He's the one who thinks about the consequences and tries to guide Ben in a more responsible direction. Their relationship is what drives the fanfiction forward.
The baby daddy is obviously one of the main characters. He's the one whose journey and growth are often central to the story. Then there's usually the mother of the baby, who has her own role in the relationship dynamic.
One possible plot could be Tucker and Ben getting into a friendly competition over a girl they both like in the fanfiction world. They might start off trying to outdo each other in impressing her, but then realize they value their friendship more.
There could be a fanfiction where the baby daddy in Ben Wheeler has to face various challenges in a small - town setting. Maybe he has to deal with the judgment of the community while also trying to build a relationship with the mother of the baby. It can be a story full of drama and character development.