Based on a given paragraph of information, it was difficult to say which novel was the scariest because each novel had its own unique horror elements and plot. However, if you like novels that transform Cthulhu in different story worlds and scare the natives to death, then I recommend Heavens: I Can Summon Cthulhu Unlimited to you. I hope you like my recommendation. Muah ~
'Rosemary's Baby' by Ira Levin is also a good choice. It's more of a slow - burn horror, focusing on the paranoia of the main character, Rosemary. The sense of something being not quite right in her new home and her pregnancy is what makes it so scary. It doesn't rely on a lot of jump scares, which can be a plus for a beginner.
The unknown is the scariest. In 'as is horror stories', things are often left in their natural state, so you don't really know what's lurking in the shadows or what's causing those strange noises. It's that sense of not having all the answers that makes it terrifying.
Isolation is also a key element. When characters are alone in a spooky place, like an abandoned asylum in one of the stories. They have no one to turn to, and that makes the situation even more terrifying as the horror unfolds around them.
The unknown is one of the scariest elements. When things are not clearly defined, like a strange figure in the fog in some stories from '1001 horror stories', it makes our imagination run wild. We start to create the most terrifying scenarios in our minds.
In the first story, the scariest part is when the boy saw the red eyes staring at him from the attic window. It was a sudden and menacing encounter. In the second story, the cold hand grabbing the girl's ankle was terrifying as it was unexpected and she was all alone. For the third story, the dark figure lunging at the family when they opened the hidden door was the scariest moment as it was a direct threat.
The scariest Savannah horror story I've heard is about a family who moved into an old house. They started experiencing things like doors slamming on their own and hearing footsteps on the stairs when no one was there. One night, they saw a figure at the end of the hallway that disappeared when they turned on the light. They quickly moved out.
A really scary Manila horror story is the one about the haunted theater. People say that during rehearsals, actors would see a ghostly figure in the audience. It would make strange noises and sometimes cause the stage lights to flicker. Another is about a dilapidated house where a family was brutally murdered. Locals say that you can still hear their screams at night.
A really scary Indiana horror story is the one about the cursed bridge. It's said that if you cross it at midnight, you'll see a car that crashed there years ago, re - enacting the accident. The people in the car are all bloody and screaming. It gives you chills just thinking about it.