In a crossover, the reapers from Black Butler could interact with Death in Supernatural. They might have different methods of collecting souls, and this could lead to some interesting conflicts or collaborations. For example, Grell Sutcliff could be overly excited to meet Death from Supernatural and try to show off his scythe skills, much to the annoyance of the more stoic Supernatural characters.
A fun plot could be a cross - over where the Trickster from Supernatural ends up in the Black Butler world. He starts causing chaos by playing tricks on the characters. Sebastian tries to outwit him while also protecting Ciel. Meanwhile, the Trickster's antics might expose some secrets within the Phantomhive household that were better left buried.
Ciel and Dean Winchester would be an interesting pairing. Ciel is a young, determined noble who is used to getting his way, while Dean is a tough hunter with a lot of experience. They could learn from each other's ways of dealing with difficult situations. Ciel could teach Dean some of his strategic thinking, and Dean could show Ciel how to handle more physical threats.
One idea could be that Ichigo Kurosaki from Bleach somehow gets transported to the Victorian era world of Black Butler. He could be mistaken for a demon or some kind of otherworldly being. Sebastian, being the ever - curious demon, might be intrigued by Ichigo's powers and his strong sense of justice. Another idea is that Ciel Phantomhive has to deal with Hollows suddenly appearing in his world. He enlists the help of the Soul Reapers from Bleach to combat this new threat. They could form an uneasy alliance where the Soul Reapers are not used to the complex politics of the Black Butler world, and Ciel has to figure out how to work with these super - powered beings.
Definitely Sam Winchester and Sebastian. Sam is always so morally conflicted in Supernatural, and Sebastian is a demon with his own code. Sam would likely be both intrigued and repulsed by Sebastian. He might try to figure out if there's a way to save Sebastian's soul, while Sebastian would be amused by Sam's naivete in thinking a demon can be redeemed.
First, you need to do your research on both universes. Know the characters, their powers, and the settings well. For example, know all about Naruto's jutsus and Sebastian's demonic abilities. Then, think of a good plot device to bring the two worlds together. It could be a portal or a powerful spell. After that, start with an interesting introduction that hooks the reader, like Naruto suddenly finding himself in the Black Butler's Victorian - era London.
One idea could be that Yuuri Katsuki, being a world - class figure skater, is invited to perform at an event in the Victorian - era setting of Black Butler. Sebastian could be tasked with making sure the event runs smoothly and he's both intrigued and somewhat amused by Yuuri's unique form of art. Ciel, on the other hand, might initially be dismissive but then becomes interested in the grace and athleticism Yuuri shows on the ice.
Power dynamics is also a common theme. Kaneki has his own set of powers as a ghoul, and the characters in Black Butler have their own abilities. Fanfictions might play around with who is more powerful in different situations or how they can use their powers together. Another theme could be the exploration of morality. Both series touch on moral grey areas, and in the crossovers, it can be interesting to see how the characters' moral compasses interact when they meet.
One great Black Butler and Harry Potter crossover fanfiction is 'A Butler in Hogwarts'. It has an interesting plot where Sebastian, from Black Butler, somehow ends up in the wizarding world of Harry Potter. He uses his skills to navigate the strange new place while also causing some chaos. Another good one could be 'The Dark Arts of a Demon Butler'. It combines the dark elements of both universes really well.
Power dynamics is another theme. Naruto is a very powerful shinobi and in the Black Butler world, there are different power hierarchies. Fanfictions often play with how Naruto's power fits in or disrupts the existing power structures in the Black Butler universe. For example, how he might deal with demons or the Queen's orders. And also, friendship is a theme. Characters from both series form unexpected friendships, like Naruto befriending Sebastian. Their different personalities and goals make these friendships interesting to read about.