Yes, it can be quite popular. Mixing characters from different storylines in fanfiction often creates interesting and unique scenarios. In this case, having Hermione be the daughter of James Potter completely changes the dynamics of the Harry Potter universe we know. It allows for new relationships to be explored, different character developments, and a fresh take on the magical world's lore.
If Hermione was James' daughter in fanfiction, Harry and Hermione's relationship would become more like a family one. They'd be closer in a different way, more like siblings.
A frequent plot element is the exploration of the past. How did James Potter come to be Hermione's father? Was there some kind of magic involved? Maybe a time - travel spell or some other magical interference. This can lead to stories where Hermione travels back in time to uncover the truth. Another aspect could be how the wizarding world reacts to this new family connection. Some might be accepting, while others might be suspicious or even hostile, which can create a lot of drama and conflict in the story.
A popular one is 'Hermione and James: Destined Souls'. In this, their soulmate bond is pre - destined by a prophecy. The fic shows their journey as they come to terms with this prophecy. It has a lot of character development, especially for Hermione as she tries to understand her role in this unexpected connection with James. There are also some great action scenes that are intertwined with their relationship development.
In fanfiction, James is often portrayed as confident and a bit of a daredevil. He might be more open - minded towards new magical ideas. Hermione, on the other hand, is still the brilliant and studious witch. She uses her vast knowledge to solve problems. For example, in some fanfictions, James might be the one to pull Hermione out of her books and into an adventure, while she uses her logic to keep them out of too much trouble.
In fanfiction, anything is possible. It could be that there's some sort of time - travel or alternate reality magic involved. Maybe a spell gone wrong that altered the timelines so much that Hermione ended up being James' daughter in this new, fictional version of the story.
For Harry, it would be a huge shock. He was best friends with Hermione, and now she's his sister in a sense. His relationship with her would have to be re - evaluated. Ron might feel a bit left out or confused as his relationship with Hermione was heading towards something romantic in the original story. And for the other Hogwarts students, they would be very surprised at this new family connection.
One possibility could be that Hermione's intelligence would blend really well with the Avengers' skills. She could use her vast knowledge of magic to assist in situations where the Avengers' technology or brute force might not be enough. For example, she could use spells to disable high - tech security systems during a mission or heal the Avengers' wounds more quickly than normal medical means.
In fanfiction, anything can be possible. Writers might create a scenario where time - traveling or some sort of magical alteration to the past occurred. Maybe a powerful spell was cast that changed the course of events so that Hermione could be born to James and Lily. However, it's a huge departure from the original story's timeline.
Maybe James has a very different view of the original relationship between characters in the story. He might think that fanfiction distorts the essence of the original story and characters, especially when it comes to Hermione. He could be a purist who only likes the original portrayal and doesn't like the various interpretations in fanfiction.