Well, it could be a fanfic where the author bashes all the characters in Harry Potter. Maybe they don't like the way the original characters were developed or they just want to create a really dark and critical take on the whole Harry Potter universe. It might involve making the characters look bad, stupid or evil in some way that's different from the original books.
It depends on what you consider 'good'. Some people might enjoy a fanfic that completely turns the original story on its head and bashes all the characters if they like that sort of edgy, subversive storytelling. But many die - hard Harry Potter fans would probably be turned off by it as it goes against their love for the characters. So, in a sense, whether it's 'good' is subjective.
Probably not as popular as the regular positive or canon - compliant Harry Potter fanfiction. Most fans love the characters and the world, so bashing everyone might not appeal to the general fanbase.
It could be fanfiction where the author bashes or is critical of all the characters in Harry Potter. Maybe it's a form of exploring different perspectives by showing the flaws of everyone in that magical world.
They're popular because many fans feel that the Ministry in the original books had a lot of flaws. These fanfics allow them to explore and expand on those flaws in creative ways.
Not really. The vast majority of Harry Potter fans love the original series and its characters. So, fanfiction that bashes the main elements of the story is not as popular as positive or alternative - but - still - respectful fanfiction. However, there are some niche groups who might be interested in it, usually those who have very strong opinions about what they perceive as flaws in the original work.
No. The Harry Potter fandom generally values the original themes and positive messages of the series. This kind of fanfic goes against those values as it involves inappropriate and unethical content that is not in line with the spirit of the books.
One common trope is making Hermione Granger overly bossy or annoying in a way that doesn't match her character in the original books. Another could be having her make mistakes that are out of character just to make other characters look better. Sometimes, in these fanfics, she might be made to be a know - it - all in a negative sense, where her intelligence is portrayed as a flaw rather than an asset.
One common theme could be a sense of betrayal. For example, in some fanfics, Dumbledore might be portrayed as having ulterior motives that betray Harry's trust, which is different from his more benevolent portrayal in the books. Another theme could be jealousy towards the Weasleys. Maybe the author of the fanfic feels that the Weasleys got too much attention or special treatment in the series. However, these are often extreme interpretations that deviate from the original source material.
One common theme could be the exploration of Dumbledore's perceived manipulative nature. Some fanfics might show how his actions,看似为了大局 but actually had negative impacts on individual characters like Harry. Another theme could be the revelation of his past mistakes and how they are presented as more than just minor flaws.