Definitely not. Common phrases are those that are widely used and easily understood by most English speakers. This phrase is so unclear and jumbled - looking that it can't be considered common. It seems more like a very specific or even made - up phrase by someone for a particular, perhaps very private or idiosyncratic, reason.
This phrase is quite ambiguous. 'Anal' could be misspelled or used in an ungrammatical way. 'Tight' might describe a characteristic, perhaps in a relationship context. 'Wife' is clear, and 'first story' could imply the initial account or tale. But overall, without additional details, it's difficult to give a more precise meaning.
We could talk about nature stories. For example, the amazing journey of a little bird migrating across continents. It's a story full of wonder and beauty as the bird overcomes various challenges like bad weather and finding food along the way.
One example could be a mystery story where a detective has very little time to solve a complex crime. The clues are scarce and the time is 'very tight', but through his wits and perseverance, he manages to crack the case at the last minute.
I'm not entirely sure what 'Anal First Stories' specifically are. It could be a very specific genre or term within a particular community or area of literature that I'm not familiar with.
One common experience is a sense of nervousness. Both partners might be a bit hesitant at first. There could also be a focus on extra lubrication as it's a more sensitive area. Another aspect is the importance of communication. Partners often need to talk about their comfort levels and boundaries during the experience.
Many anal first time stories involve a process of exploration. People may talk about how they first got the idea, perhaps from reading or hearing about it. Then, when they decided to try, they started with small steps. They might describe how the body initially resisted a bit, but as they got more used to the sensation, it became a more positive experience.
Guys can start by educating themselves. Reading reliable information about the anatomy and the process can be helpful. This can reduce some of the fear of the unknown.