A plot twist could be that Percy has a connection to the primordial forces that even the Titans and the Olympians are afraid of. His link to Nyx and Tartarus means he can access parts of the universe that are normally off - limits. For instance, he might be able to open portals to the darkest corners of Tartarus, which could either be a great advantage or a huge danger. Also, he could have the power to call upon the creatures of the night created by Nyx, and these creatures could be either his allies or a threat to the existing order of the demigod world, depending on how Percy chooses to use his powers.
His powers would likely be much darker. He might have the ability to manipulate shadows like Nyx, using them to hide or even attack. And from Tartarus, he could have the power to cause earthquakes or open up chasms in the earth. He could also have a natural resistance to the harmful effects of the Underworld, such as the poisonous gases and the draining of energy that normal demigods experience.
One plot idea could be Percy struggling with his new identity. Since Tartarus and Nyx are such powerful and dark entities, Percy might have to battle against the dark urges within him. He could be shunned by his friends at first, but then prove that he's not defined by his parentage. For example, he might save Camp Half - Blood from a new, powerful threat using his unique powers that come from his heritage.
In most traditional Percy Jackson lore, he is the son of Poseidon. However, in fanfiction, authors can create all kinds of alternate universes. So, it's possible for him to be depicted as the son of Gaia and Tartarus in some fan - created stories.
This is a really interesting concept. In the original Percy Jackson series, Percy is the son of Poseidon. But in this fanfiction idea, if he were the son of Gaea and Tartarus, it would completely change his character and the story. His powers would likely be much darker and more primal. He might have an in - depth connection to the earth and the abyss, which could lead to some really unique storylines.
His relationship with Annabeth would be very different. Annabeth might be initially scared of Percy because of his dark lineage. She would be cautious around him as she is used to the more 'typical' demigods. Percy, on the other hand, might feel isolated from her because he knows she is wary. His friendships with the other demigods at Camp Half - Blood would also change. Some might avoid him, while others might be intrigued by his new powers and origin. Grover, for example, might be torn between his loyalty to Percy and his fear of what Percy could become.
Developing his powers further is also a way. Since he's the son of Nyx, he could learn to manipulate different aspects of darkness like creating illusions using shadows or traveling through the dark realms faster. This would not only make him more powerful but also show his growth as a character as he masters these new abilities.
One common theme is the struggle with identity. Since Percy is the son of Erebus and Nyx in these fanfictions, he often has to grapple with being different from the 'canon' Percy. Another theme is power. Given his new parentage, he might have different or enhanced powers, and the fanfictions often explore how he uses or controls them.
The Titans could be antagonists. Since Nyx is an ancient and powerful goddess, the Titans might see Percy as a threat because of his connection to her. They could try to either turn him against Nyx or simply eliminate him.
Another plotline could involve Percy exploring the powers he has inherited from Chaos and Nyx. Maybe he discovers unique abilities that no one has ever seen before, like the power to manipulate shadows in a way that's different from a child of Hades. This could lead to him going on a journey to understand the full extent of his powers and how to control them.