A more complex plot could be that Tyler is actually a reincarnation of someone who was wronged in the FNAF backstory. The animatronics sense this and are initially hostile, but as Tyler starts to remember his past life, he is able to use his knowledge to try and bring peace to the pizzeria. He might have to face off against an evil force that has been using the animatronics for its own malevolent purposes.
For Tyler, you can start by giving him a clear backstory. Maybe he's a big FNAF fan, so he has a lot of knowledge about the lore which he can use to his advantage. His reactions to the dangerous situations in the pizzeria should be realistic, like being scared at first but then gradually getting more determined.
Tyler, as a male OC in FNAF fanfiction, can bring a fresh perspective. He could be a new night guard, facing the terrors of Freddy Fazbear's Pizza. His character might have unique traits like extraordinary courage or a special backstory that makes his interactions with the animatronics interesting.
In FNAF fanfiction, a male Tyler OC might be designed as a tech - savvy character. He could be trying to figure out the secrets behind the animatronics' glitches and abnormal behavior. This OC could add new plotlines to the already complex world of FNAF, like attempting to reprogram the animatronics to stop their murderous tendencies.
The male Tyler OC can act as a catalyst in the FNAF fanfiction story. He might be the one to start uncovering the dark secrets of the pizzeria. For instance, he could find hidden rooms or documents that reveal the true nature of the animatronics.
Well, in 'fnaf x male reader fanfiction', the theme of isolation is common. The male reader is often alone in the pizzeria or in the FNAF world, which adds to the sense of dread. Another theme is the struggle for power. Sometimes the male reader has to fight against the animatronics' control or the power they hold over the environment. Additionally, the theme of redemption can also be found in some stories. For example, the male reader might try to redeem the animatronics from their haunted state or find a way to make peace with the horrors of the FNAF world.
One popular trope is the 'protective animatronic'. In these stories, the male FNAF character (like Freddy or Bonnie) might protect the male reader from other threats in the spooky FNAF world.
Another theme could be the struggle of being in a relationship that is not considered 'normal' in the context of the FNAF world. There might be challenges like acceptance from other characters or dealing with the dangerous and spooky nature of the FNAF setting while being in a relationship. Often, there is also a theme of protecting each other. The male reader and the FNAF character might protect each other from the threats within the FNAF universe, which in turn strengthens their bond.
One great fem FNAF x male reader fanfiction is 'A Night at Her Place'. It has an interesting plot where the male reader character gets involved in a unique situation with the female FNAF character. The story is well - written with good character development.