There could be. Fanfiction writers like to take creative liberties with existing characters and relationships. But in the 'Twilight' series, Bella's relationship with Edward is central, and this kind of plot would be a major deviation. Some fans might write it to explore different character dynamics, but it may not be as common as more traditional fanfiction plots.
Many fans would likely be divided. There would be those who are open to new interpretations and might find it an interesting take on the characters. However, a large portion would probably be against it as it goes against the established love story between Bella and Edward. They might feel that it changes the essence of the characters as they were presented in the original books.
One common theme is the family dynamic. Carlisle being the patriarch, his influence on Edward and Bella's relationship within the family framework is often explored. For example, in many fanfictions, he helps them navigate the difficulties of being part of a vampire family.
I really like 'A New Beginning in Forks'. In this fanfiction, Carlisle's wisdom has a great impact on how Edward and Bella handle the challenges in their relationship. It has a very engaging writing style that makes you feel like you're right there in Forks with them.
Yes, there are likely such fanfictions out there. Fanfiction platforms host a wide variety of stories based on different interpretations of characters and relationships. However, these often deviate from the original story's canon.
One common theme is the exploration of family dynamics. Since Carlisle is sort of the father figure in the Cullen family, fanfictions often look at how he accepts or influences Bella's relationship with Edward within the family structure.
Another theme is the moral and ethical aspects. Carlisle has strong moral beliefs, and in fanfiction, this can clash or align with Bella and Edward's relationship. For instance, some stories might explore how Carlisle's medical ethics come into play when dealing with Bella's transformation or the consequences of their relationships in the vampire - human world.
The theme of self - discovery is quite prevalent too. Bella is often portrayed as a character who is on a journey of self - discovery, especially when caught between Carlisle and Edward. This includes understanding her own feelings, her place in the vampire - human world, and her future with either of them.
Obviously, Edward and Bella are the main characters as the title suggests. Their relationship is at the center of the story, even if it's a non - canonical take on it.
I'm not sure specifically. Fanfiction quality can vary greatly. You could try searching on popular fanfiction websites like Archive of Our Own or FanFiction.net and look through the reviews and ratings to find well - liked ones in this category.