Once upon a time, I was walking alone in a dark forest. I suddenly felt a strange tickling on my big toe. I looked down, but there was nothing there. As I continued walking, the tickling turned into a sharp pain. I screamed, but no one could hear me. Then, I saw a pair of glowing eyes in the bushes. I tried to run, but my big toe felt like it was being held back by an invisible force.
My big toe story is a bit funny. I was walking on the beach and stepped on a sharp shell with my big toe. It bled a little, but the beautiful view made me forget the pain quickly. I just rinsed it in the ocean water and carried on enjoying my day.
Since there's no more context about this 'cut off big toe with axe story', it's impossible to say who did such a thing. It could be anyone in the story's context, but without further details, we can't determine it.
Yes, there are some big toe scary stories that claim to be based on real events. For example, there was a story about a surgical mistake where a patient's big toe was amputated wrongly. After that, the patient reported seeing apparitions of their lost big toe at night. They said it would float around their room, which was really terrifying for them.
In a horror story, your big toe could be the target of a cursed object. For example, you find an old ring at a flea market and put it on your toe. But then, every time the clock strikes midnight, your big toe feels like it's being squeezed by an invisible hand, and the pain is excruciating.
The 'big toe ghost story' is often a spooky tale. Usually, it involves a big toe having some sort of strange or supernatural encounter. Maybe it's a story where a person wakes up in the middle of the night and sees a disembodied big toe floating around their room, creating a sense of horror and mystery.