Once upon a time, there was a girl named Lily. She had an old, ornate mirror in her attic. One night, as she passed by it, she thought she saw a face in the mirror that wasn't her own. It was a pale, gaunt face with sunken eyes. Every night after that, the face became clearer. It seemed to be trying to reach out from the other side of the mirror. Lily was so scared that she covered the mirror with a sheet, but she could still feel a cold presence. Eventually, she couldn't take it anymore and moved out of the house.
A young boy was staying at his grandmother's house. His grandmother had a big, ornate mirror in her bedroom. One evening, the boy was playing near the mirror when he noticed that his reflection wasn't acting the same as he was. His reflection just stood still while he was jumping around. Then, as he stared longer, his reflection's eyes turned black. He became scared and ran to his grandmother. She told him that there were old rumors about the mirror being cursed. From that day on, the boy always avoided looking at that mirror when he visited.
There was a man who bought an old house. In the bathroom, there was a large mirror. One evening, while shaving, he noticed a figure in the mirror that wasn't his reflection. It was a man with a distorted face and wild eyes. He blinked and rubbed his eyes, but the figure remained. As days passed, the man in the mirror started to get closer each time he looked. Eventually, the man in the mirror was so close that he could feel his cold breath on his face when he stared into the mirror, even though it was impossible. Terrified, he smashed the mirror, but he could still feel an eerie presence in the room.
There was a man who moved into an old house. One night, as he was getting ready for bed, he glanced at the mirror in his bedroom. In the mirror, he saw a strange apparition. It was a ghostly woman with long, flowing hair. She seemed to be reaching out from the mirror towards him. He blinked, thinking it was his imagination, but when he looked again, she was closer. He quickly turned off the light and hid under the covers, praying that the ghost would disappear. In the morning, he avoided looking at the mirror, but every night, the same thing would happen.
Once, a girl woke up in the middle of the night to use the bathroom. As she passed the mirror, she saw a faint figure. She rubbed her eyes, thinking it was a trick of the light. But when she looked again, a pale face with hollow eyes stared back at her. She screamed and ran back to her bed, pulling the covers over her head. She could still feel the cold stare from the mirror all night.
In a haunted mansion, there was a large, ornate mirror. At midnight, when the moonlight shone on it, strange things began to happen. A man staying there for the night saw in the mirror a woman in a white dress with a sad face. But when he turned around, there was no one there. Every time he looked back at the mirror, the woman seemed closer. He was so terrified that he hid under the bed until morning and left as soon as he could.
One scary window mirror story could be about a woman who always saw a strange face in her bedroom mirror at night. Every time she looked, it was just for a second, but it was always there. One night, she decided to face it and found out it was the face of a girl who died in that room long ago.
The unknown. In a mirror, you expect to see your normal reflection. But in a scary story, when something different or unexpected appears, it's terrifying. For example, a strange face or figure that shouldn't be there.
The isolation of the person in relation to the mirror can make a story scary. If someone is alone in a big, empty house with just a mirror for company, and strange things start to happen with the reflection, it creates a sense of vulnerability. Also, if the mirror reflects something that shouldn't be there, like a figure from a past tragedy or a supernatural being. It makes you question what is real and what isn't. And when the mirror starts to affect the real world, like the reflection reaching out and causing physical harm, that's extremely frightening.
One common element is the distortion of the reflection. Like in many stories, the reflection in the mirror doesn't look like the person looking into it, which is really creepy. For example, the face might change into something monstrous.