Yes, there are many non - lemon 'Peter Pan x Reader' fanfictions. You can find them on popular fanfiction websites like Archive of Our Own. Just use the search filters to exclude mature or lemon content.
First, know the characters well. Peter Pan is carefree, adventurous, and a bit of a rebel. The reader character should be relatable. Then, create a vivid setting. Describe Neverland in all its glory, from the lush forests to the lairs of the pirates. Also, have a strong plot. Maybe the reader is on a quest to find a way back home or is helping Peter fight a new threat in Neverland.
A wonderful fanfiction is 'Flying with Peter'. It focuses on the relationship between the reader and Peter Pan. The author does a great job of showing how the reader adapts to the strange and wonderful world of Neverland. The story is full of heartwarming moments and also some thrilling parts where they face the villains of Neverland together.
One common theme is adventure. Since Peter Pan is all about adventures in Neverland, these fanfictions often involve the reader going on exciting quests, flying around the island, and facing the challenges like dealing with Captain Hook. Another theme is the discovery of self. The reader in the story often discovers new aspects of themselves while in the world of Peter Pan.
Peter Pan x Reader hurt fanfics differ from others mainly in the tone. While regular Peter Pan fanfics might focus on the magic and adventure of Neverland, hurt fanfics center around the pain and distress in the relationship between Peter and the reader. For example, in a normal fic, they might be exploring the island together happily, but in a hurt fic, the reader could be lost in Neverland and Peter is too caught up in his own fun to notice.
One common theme is adventure. Since Peter Pan is all about exploring Neverland, fanfictions often include the reader going on exciting adventures with Peter, like fighting pirates or exploring hidden parts of the island.
It could start when the reader gets lost in Neverland. Peter Pan, being the curious and adventurous boy he is, finds the reader. He's immediately intrigued by this newcomer and decides to show the reader around Neverland. Their eyes meet, and there's a spark of something special right from the start.
Perhaps 'Once Upon a Time: The Reader in Peter Pan's World'. This title emphasizes the reader's presence in the world of Peter Pan, which can lead to various interesting storylines.
In Peter Pan x Reader hurt fanfics, the emotional depth often comes from the contrast between Peter Pan's eternal youth and the reader's vulnerability. The hurt can be physical, like when Peter gets into battles in Neverland and the reader is caught in the crossfire. Or it could be emotional, for example, when Peter's carefree nature makes the reader feel left out or unimportant. These fics explore complex relationships and the pain that can come with loving someone as unpredictable as Peter Pan.
One challenge could be the fact that Peter Pan doesn't age while the reader does. The reader would have to come to terms with growing old while Peter remains a boy forever. It might create insecurities and doubts in their relationship.