Another option could be an alien from Starfire's home planet. This would add an interesting dynamic as the baby would have a strong connection to Starfire's alien heritage. It could also bring in some unique storylines about the alien culture and how it affects the baby's upbringing. Maybe the alien father has certain powers or responsibilities that are passed down to the baby.
I'm not sure exactly who Sarah is without more information from the story. But she is likely a person who has a weight problem and is the focus of the '600 pound life' story.
Maybe it's a completely new character, someone from a different part of the wizarding world. He could be a mysterious wizard with a special talent or power that Rose was drawn to. This would open up a whole new set of plotlines as the reader discovers more about this unknown character and his connection to Rose.
Another possibility is Clark Kent himself. Their friendship was very strong, and there were always some unspoken feelings between them. A situation where Clark is the father would bring about a lot of emotional turmoil as they both try to figure out how to handle this unexpected development.
The father of Vivian's baby in American Horror Story 1 is Ben Harmon. This is a significant plot point that adds to the drama and complexity of the story.