There could be a new girl in town. She's curious about Jackson and his diary, and as they become friends, she gets involved in the strange events related to the diary. A nosy neighbor might also be a character. He's always spying on Jackson and suspects that there's something special about the diary. And a ghostly figure that haunts the pages of the diary, only visible to Jackson, would add an element of mystery.
An ancient demigod who was frozen in time and now awakens in the modern Percy Jackson world. This character has archaic ways of thinking and fighting but also has knowledge of long - forgotten prophecies and secrets that could either help or hinder Percy. They might have a different view on the gods and their roles compared to the modern demigods. For instance, they could believe in more direct worship and obedience, which would clash with Percy's more laid - back attitude towards the gods.
Another great addition could be Circe. She has a lot of knowledge about magic and the supernatural. In the fanfiction, she could be an ally or an enemy. If she's an ally, she could teach Percy and Artemis some spells to combat the chaos - influenced threats. If she's an enemy, she could be working with the forces of chaos to try and gain more power.
A new character could be a super - smart girl who always outsmarts Greg in class. Another could be a mysterious janitor who seems to know a lot about the school's secrets. And perhaps a foreign exchange student who has really strange habits and becomes Greg's new friend or rival.
A centaur who has knowledge of ancient prophecies involving both Percy and Artemis could be added. The centaur could act as a guide or a mentor to them during their adventure. He could provide crucial information about the enemies they are facing and how to use their combined powers effectively. For example, he might know of a weakness in a powerful foe that only Percy's unique abilities and Artemis' lunar powers can exploit.
You could add a new demigod character. Maybe a child of Hecate who can use magic in interesting ways around the school. For example, she could make the lockers disappear or change the school cafeteria into a magical forest for a short time. Another character could be a satyr who is pretending to be a normal student but is really there to protect the demigod students. He could be the one who always seems to be eating strange things from his backpack, like enchanted herbs.
A shape - shifting creature that can take on the form of any animal. It starts off as an enemy, trying to steal something important from Percy and the Wanderer, but later realizes they are on the same side and becomes an ally. This character could bring a lot of action and mystery to the fanfiction.
A character like a time - traveling demigod from the future could be really interesting. This character could have knowledge of events that are yet to happen in Percy's world and could either help or hinder him depending on their motives.
You could have a character like Marie, a young demigod with the power to control the wind. She grew up in New Orleans and knows all the secret alleyways and hidden places in the city. Another could be Jacques, an old Cajun fisherman who is secretly a protector of a magical spring near the bayou and has some knowledge of the ancient Greek magic that Percy is familiar with. And then there's Lila, a voodoo priestess - in - training who teams up with Percy to fight against a common enemy.
A new character could be a mortal who has somehow gained the ability to see through the Mist completely. This mortal is on a mission to expose the world of demigods and the gods themselves. Percy has to either convince this mortal to keep quiet or find a way to make them forget what they've seen, all while dealing with the chaos this person is causing in the demigod world.
A demigod with the power to control time in a very limited way. For example, they can slow down time for a few seconds during a battle, which could be a very interesting addition to the story. They could be an ally or an antagonist depending on their motives.