Surprise elements can make an awesome first date story. For example, if one person arranges a private concert or something unexpected like that. It makes the date memorable.
The location can be a key factor. A beautiful and unique place like a rooftop with a great view of the city or a beach at sunset. It sets the mood and makes the whole experience special. Also, little gestures matter. If one person gives a small but meaningful gift, like a handmade bookmark or a flower picked from the side of the road, it adds a sweet touch to the first date story.
A shared adventure is also great. Like when two people try something new together, such as rock climbing or learning to make pottery on their first date. It creates a bond and a unique story to tell. And of course, good conversation throughout the date. If they can talk about deep topics, their interests, and just have a natural flow of communication, that makes for an awesome first date story.