Hermione as a Death Eater in Fanfiction: How Does It Change the Story?

Well, if Hermione was a Death Eater, it would completely turn the original 'Harry Potter' story upside down. For one, her intelligence would be used for the dark side. She might use her knowledge of magic to create new dark spells or help Voldemort in his plans. It would also change her relationships. Her friendship with Harry and Ron would be non - existent or turn into bitter enmity. And Hogwarts would be a much darker place with Hermione on the side of the villains, as she could influence other students to follow the Death Eater ideology.

On the other hand, she could also become more empathetic. If she is trying to redeem the Death Eater, she has to understand his motives and background. This could lead to a deeper understanding of the people who are drawn to the Dark side, and she may become more forgiving in general. For example, she might start to see that not all Death Eaters are irredeemable monsters.

She might react with caution at first. Given that Death Eaters are known for their cruelty, Hermione would be smart to be on her guard. She would likely start by gathering information about the escaped Death Eater, like his known abilities and any possible weaknesses.

In some fanfictions, Hermione as a Death Eater is a very interesting and often controversial portrayal. Sometimes, it might show her being forced into the role due to some dark magic or blackmail. This completely flips her good - girl image from the original series and allows for a very different exploration of her character.

Bellatrix Lestrange's younger brother or some other minor Death Eater character could be used. This would allow for the creation of a new character with his own motives and backstory. He could be betrothed to Hermione as part of a larger plot by Voldemort to gain control over Hermione's knowledge and magic. This would put Hermione in a very difficult position as she would be tied to a very dark and dangerous family.

Bellatrix Lestrange is also a likely candidate. Her encounter with Hermione would be extremely intense. Given her loyalty to Voldemort and her rather unhinged nature, she would likely pose a serious threat to Hermione, but Hermione might also find a way to use Bellatrix's madness against her.

In this type of fanfiction, the relationship between Hermione and the Death Eater could be very complex. Maybe it starts as a hostile one, but as the story progresses, they might find some common ground or mutual understanding. It could also be a story of redemption for the Death Eater through Hermione's influence.

Often, these fanfictions explore the 'what - if' scenarios. If Hermione were a Death Eater, her intelligence would make her a formidable foe. However, the writers also have to be careful not to completely change her core values. Some might show her being forced into the role due to some dark magic or blackmail, which could lead to a story of her redemption later on.

It's a really strange concept. In the original 'Harry Potter' universe, Hermione is firmly on the side of good. But in fanfiction, if she's a Death Eater, it could be a result of a time - travel gone wrong. She might have made a different choice in an alternate timeline that led her down the dark path. But again, this is very much against the essence of her character.

There's also a possibility that it could be a minor Death Eater that we don't know much about from the original series. The author of the fanfiction could create a new character who was a Death Eater but is now having doubts. Hermione could be the one to find this person and start their journey of change. This would give the author a lot of creative freedom to develop the character's backstory and their relationship with Hermione.