One plot idea could be Tsukune's further exploration of his unique powers in the Rosario Vampire world. He might encounter a new type of enemy that challenges his abilities in ways he hasn't faced before. Another could be a love triangle involving Tsukune, Moka, and another character, creating a lot of drama and tension. Maybe Tsukune has to go on a quest to find a lost artifact that has significance in the vampire world, and along the way he discovers more about his own heritage.
Tsukune could find himself in a situation where he has to train a group of new students who are half - vampires like him. He would have to teach them how to control their powers and deal with the prejudice from both humans and full - blooded vampires. Another idea is that he discovers a hidden part of the school that holds ancient secrets about the origin of vampires. This discovery could put him in danger as there are those who want to keep those secrets buried, but it also gives him a chance to rewrite the future of the vampire - human coexistence.
A possible plot is Tsukune getting involved in a vampire politics situation. He could be used as a pawn by different vampire factions, and he has to use his wits to outmaneuver them. Or perhaps he starts a club at school that is dedicated to understanding the relationship between humans and vampires better, which attracts all kinds of strange and interesting characters. Also, Tsukune might have a prophetic dream that leads him on a journey to prevent a great disaster from befalling the vampire and human worlds.
There could be a fanfiction where Tsukune and Moka accidentally switch bodies. This would lead to a lot of comical situations as they try to adapt to each other's lives. Moka in Tsukune's body would have to deal with human school life and Tsukune in Moka's body would have to handle the vampire society. Additionally, a plot about a mysterious prophecy that involves both of them and their fates being intertwined with the future of the vampire - human relations could be really engaging.
Tsukune himself is quite interesting. He's a human in a world full of vampires, which makes him an outlier. His journey of adapting to this new world and developing his powers is always engaging. Moka is also a great character. Her dual personality, with the sweet outer self and the more powerful vampire self, adds a lot of depth. Inner Moka especially is a force to be reckoned with. And then there's Kurumu, the succubus. Her pursuit of Tsukune in the fanfiction can lead to some really fun and flirty storylines.
A more romantic plot could involve Yukari developing deeper feelings for Tsukune and trying to confess her love in a world full of supernatural distractions and challenges. It could show how their relationship might develop in a different way from the original story.
One interesting plot idea could be Tsukune having to protect his harem members from a new powerful vampire threat that has emerged in the school. This would involve a lot of action scenes where Tsukune uses his growing powers.
One interesting plot could be Tsukune and Ruby going on a secret mission within the Yokai Academy. They might have to face a new type of supernatural threat that neither of them has encountered before. This would test their skills and their relationship as they rely on each other to survive.
One idea could be Tsukune learning a new and powerful vampire ability. For example, he discovers he can manipulate shadows in a way unique to him, which helps him in battles against other supernatural foes in the Rosario Vampire world.
Another fanfiction could be about Nekonome getting into trouble and Tsukune coming to her rescue. For example, Nekonome could accidentally break a precious magical item in the school and Tsukune uses his newfound powers to fix it before anyone notices. This would show their loyalty and friendship towards each other.
A cool plot could be that a powerful vampire targets Naruto because of his unique chakra. Shinso gets involved as he senses something is wrong with Naruto. They discover that the vampire wants to use Naruto's chakra to break a curse on their clan. Shinso and Naruto must decide whether to help the vampire or fight against it.
Love is also a frequent theme. Tsukune may find love within the vampire community or have to deal with his previous human relationships while being a vampire. Sometimes it's a love triangle between a human, Tsukune as a vampire, and another vampire. This adds a lot of drama and emotional depth to the fanfictions. There are also themes of acceptance, both Tsukune accepting his new vampire self and the other characters accepting him for who he has become.
One possible fanfiction could be about Nekonome and Tsukune going on a secret adventure in the school grounds. Maybe they discover a hidden passage that leads to a place full of magical artifacts. Nekonome's feline instincts could help them navigate through the dangerous parts while Tsukune's growing powers could be used to protect them from any threats.