How about a crossover where the Riverdale characters get dragged into a Supernatural - style apocalypse? Jughead could be the one who first notices the strange things happening, like people disappearing and strange symbols appearing. He teams up with Betty and Veronica to find out what's going on. Then, the Winchesters arrive in Riverdale because they've heard about similar events. Together, they figure out that an ancient evil has been awakened and they have to find a way to stop it, all while dealing with the Riverdale drama and the Winchester's hunting style.
One idea could be that the Winchesters from Supernatural end up in Riverdale to hunt a demon that's possessing one of the Riverdale residents. Maybe it's a possessed Cheryl Blossom causing chaos in town. Another could be Sam and Dean teaming up with Archie and his friends to solve a mystery that has both supernatural elements like ghosts and the typical Riverdale high - school drama aspects. For example, a ghost is haunting the school but it's also tied to a secret society in town.
Perhaps a spell gone wrong in 'Supernatural' accidentally opens a portal to the 'Grimm' world. Sam and Dean have to navigate this new world filled with Wesen while also trying to find a way back home. They soon discover that some of the monsters they hunt in their world have counterparts in the 'Grimm' world with different powers.
A great plot could involve a powerful and ancient curse that affects both the Supernatural world of angels and demons and the more magical world of Constantine. The curse is causing strange phenomena like people seeing visions of the apocalypse and magic going haywire. Sam, Dean, and Constantine must find the source of the curse, which could be an old, forgotten artifact. Along the way, they face off against enemies who want to use the curse for their own gain, and they have to overcome their differences in approach to solve the problem.
One idea could be that the characters from Riverdale somehow find themselves in the wizarding world of Harry Potter. Maybe Jughead could be a Muggle - born wizard who discovers his powers while at Hogwarts. He might write about his strange new experiences in his journal, just like he does in Riverdale.
One idea could be that a vampire from TVD ends up in Riverdale. Maybe Damon Salvatore finds himself in the small town for some mysterious reason. He could get involved with the mystery-solving that the Riverdale gang is always up to. He might use his vampire charm and powers to help or sometimes complicate things. Another plot could be that a character from Riverdale discovers the existence of vampires and werewolves like in TVD. For example, Jughead could be intrigued by these supernatural beings and start writing a story about them, which then draws the attention of the TVD characters.
One idea could be that a strange meta - human from The Flash's world somehow ends up in Riverdale. This meta - human has the power to manipulate memories, and starts causing chaos by making the Riverdale characters forget important things about each other. Archie and his friends then team up with Barry Allen to stop this meta - human before their town is torn apart.
In some 'Riverdale Crossover Fanfiction', a crossover with a time - travel plot is really engaging. For example, when the Riverdale gang travels back in time to the 1950s and has to deal with the different social norms while also trying to get back to their own time. Also, crossovers with other teen drama shows where they have to compete in a singing or dancing competition together can be quite entertaining.
One idea could be that the NCIS team is investigating a series of strange murders that seem to have a supernatural element. They end up calling in the Winchesters from Supernatural for help. The two groups initially clash due to their different methods but eventually learn from each other and solve the case together.
One idea could be that Lucifer from 'Lucifer' enters the world of 'Supernatural'. Maybe he teams up with the Winchester brothers to fight a common enemy, like a new type of demon that is causing chaos in both their realms. He could use his devilish charm and powers in a way that the Winchesters are both skeptical and intrigued by.
Love triangles involving characters from both shows are also common. Imagine Betty falling for Dean Winchester while Jughead is trying to figure out what's going on with all the supernatural stuff in town. It adds an interesting layer of drama to the fanfiction.
One idea could be Naruto crossing over with the world of vampires. Naruto could use his chakra powers to combat the vampires' super strength and speed. Maybe he'd have to team up with some vampire hunters within that supernatural world.