Why would someone rename Hedwig as Snowly Owl in a Harry Potter fanfic?

Well, it could change the emotional connection. Hedwig was a well - known name, and if it's suddenly Snowly Owl, it might make Harry seem a bit more distanced from his owl at first. For example, when he calls for Hedwig, there's a sense of familiarity. But with a new name, he'd have to get used to it, and so would the readers. Also, in the wizarding world where names have power, it could potentially attract different kinds of magic or attention to the owl.

Another aspect is quality control. A lot of fanfic varies greatly in terms of writing quality. Some people might have had bad experiences with poorly written Harry Potter fanfic in the past and thus choose to say no to all of it. They don't want to waste their time sifting through sub - par stories when they can just re - read the original, well - crafted novels.

Maybe they just don't understand the real essence of Harry Potter. They might have only seen a small part of it or misinterpreted some of the more emotional or character - developing moments as signs of weakness, which is completely wrong.

One reason could be the unfinished business in the original story. For instance, some fans might be curious about what happened to certain minor characters after the main series ended. Fanfic provides a space to explore that. Also, the sense of community around Harry Potter fanfic can be very appealing. People can discuss and share their thoughts on different fanfic stories, which makes them want to linger. Additionally, the creativity of fanfic writers in expanding the magical world and creating new storylines can be captivating.

There is no valid reason. Harry Potter has been around for a long time with a very distinct identity. If someone thinks this, it might be because they are making a very random and baseless association. It could be that they have some misunderstanding about the nature of fanfics in general and how they are related to original works like Harry Potter.

Some writers might do it to make a statement about how Harry Potter, who is used to the grandeur of Hogwarts and the wizarding world, can adapt to a very different and confined space like a fridge. It could be a study of his character's adaptability. Also, it could be a form of satire, poking fun at the sometimes overly - serious nature of the original Harry Potter stories.

Well, it could be that the idea of a hero on a quest is present in both. Harry is on a quest to defeat Voldemort and Sherlock is on a quest to solve crimes. But this is a very general concept. In reality, the two are so different. Harry Potter has a whole world of magic, with spells, potions, and magical creatures. Sherlock Holmes has a more realistic, historical London setting with no magic involved. So, the thought that Harry Potter is Sherlock Holmes fanfic is unfounded.

One reason could be that they are a huge fan of the original books and movies and think that fanfic often takes things in the wrong direction. They might feel that the creativity in fanfic goes against what they love about the original Harry Potter, so they reject it completely with that statement.

Someone might say it if the fanfic contains really bad writing. Like if the grammar and spelling are atrocious, it can be a turn - off. Also, if the story is just plain boring or the characters are not well - developed.

Perhaps in this particular fanfic, Harry views Hedwig as his most trusted companion and decides to break the norm by taking her to the Yule Ball. It could also be a symbol of his individuality and nonconformity within the magical world.