The Headmaster Punishes Hermione: Fanfiction. What could be the reasons for the headmaster to punish Hermione in fanfiction?

Another reaction could be that Hermione becomes a bit rebellious. If she feels the punishment is too harsh or unfair, she might start to secretly oppose the headmaster's rule. This could lead to a series of events where she tries to find loopholes in the school rules or even starts a small movement among the students to question the headmaster's decision - making.

Most likely not. The idea of one character being a slave to another, especially in the context of a well - known and generally positive fictional universe like Harry Potter, goes against the values of equality and freedom that are often promoted. It can also be seen as a form of abuse of the original characters and their relationships.

I'm not entirely sure as there could be many interpretations. It might be a rather dark and unethical take on the relationship between Hermione and the headmaster within the fanfiction world, perhaps exploring themes of power imbalance in a fictional and often disturbing way. But this is just speculation without actually reading the specific fanfiction.

Yes, there are likely many non - smut fanfictions involving Hermione, a headmaster (presumably of Hogwarts), and Harry. Fanfiction writers often explore their relationships in various ways that focus on friendship, mentorship, or adventures without delving into inappropriate content. You can find such fanfictions on popular fanfiction platforms by using specific search filters to exclude adult - themed stories.

One interesting fanfiction could be where Snape discovers Hermione's hidden potential in a different area of magic not explored in the original books. For example, in a story, Snape might take Hermione under his wing to study ancient and dark magics that are on the verge of being lost. This could lead to a series of adventures where they break traditional Hogwarts rules together in the pursuit of knowledge.

In lemon fanfiction, if McGonagall punishes Hermione, it could be due to violating school rules in a more extreme way than in the original books. For example, if Hermione gets involved in inappropriate behavior during a time when she should be studying or following Hogwarts' code of conduct.

Perhaps in the fanfiction, Hermione was involved in some sort of political activism that the Minister of Magic didn't like. Maybe she was fighting for the rights of house - elves in a way that the Ministry thought was too radical and thus they decided to punish her.

A popular choice could be a character like Sirius Black. If he had survived, he could have become headmaster with his rebellious yet caring nature. He would bring a different kind of leadership to Hogwarts, one that is more in tune with the students' desires for change and adventure.

Sure. There's a fanfiction where Snape becomes headmaster earlier than in the original series, and Hermione is his most trusted student - advisor. They have to deal with a new threat to Hogwarts that involves a powerful dark wizard who is using ancient spells to corrupt the school's magic. Their relationship in this story is one of mutual respect and they rely on each other's strengths to protect Hogwarts.

One possible reason could be a miscommunication. Maybe some evidence is misinterpreted, and Dumbledore thinks Hermione has broken a major rule. For example, if he thought she was involved in some dangerous magic experiments without permission. But this is a hasty conclusion for him to make.