Why would Amy defend Sonic fanfic?

She might hate sonic fanfic because she has her own ideas about how Sonic's story should progress. Fanfics are written by many different people with different interpretations, and perhaps she doesn't agree with the general direction that a lot of fanfics take. Also, some fanfics could be poorly written, which might also contribute to her dislike.

Maybe she feels that fanfic often distorts the real relationship between her and Sonic. In fanfic, their characters might be misrepresented, which could make her uncomfortable.

Some fans might be very shocked and disappointed. Sonic and Amy have a long - established relationship in the Sonic franchise, and this would be a huge deviation from what they expect.

It's hard to say whether the 'amy kills sonic fanfic' is popular. The Sonic fanfic community is diverse, with fans having different tastes. Some might enjoy exploring the darker and more controversial storylines like this one, but it could also be that a large portion of the community prefers the more traditional, positive stories. So it might not be as mainstream popular as some of the more typical Sonic fanfics.

Sonic would probably be very shocked at first. He trusts Amy, so her betrayal would be unexpected. He might initially try to talk to her to understand why she did it.

Tails could be one of the main characters. He might play a role in helping Amy realize that her chasing Sonic isn't healthy. For instance, he could give her advice based on his own observations.

For Amy, she could become more understanding of the 'evil' or opposing side. Instead of just seeing Metal Sonic as a bad guy, she might learn to look deeper into his existence as a creation. This could make her more empathetic in general.

No, it's not that common. Most Sonic fanfics tend to focus on Sonic's adventures, his battles with villains, or his relationships in a more positive light. Fanfics about a character dreaming of another character dying are not as prevalent as those with more action - packed or romantic themes.

Love is a very common theme. Most of the time, it's about Amy's love for Sonic and Sonic's growing realization of his feelings for her. Adventure is also common. They often go on quests or face challenges together.

The 'amy kills sonic fanfic' might be a product of the writer's creativity to subvert the typical Sonic story. Usually, Amy loves Sonic, but in this fanfic, things take a drastic turn. It could be set in a world where the power dynamics have shifted, or new threats have emerged. Maybe a new villain has manipulated Amy into believing that Sonic is the key to all the problems, leading her to kill him. This would create a whole new set of conflicts and character developments within the Sonic fanfic community.